web analytics
April 18, 2015 / 29 Nisan, 5775
At a Glance
Blogs
Sponsored Post


Disappointed But Not Surprised

There ought to be a process of exempting yeshiva students via bechinos (tests).
Rabbi Yoel Schwartz greets Religious Jewish soldiers attending a swearing in ceremony as they enter the IDF "Nahal Haredi" unit. May 31, 2012.

Rabbi Yoel Schwartz greets Religious Jewish soldiers attending a swearing in ceremony as they enter the IDF "Nahal Haredi" unit. May 31, 2012.
Photo Credit: Noam Moskowitz/FLASH90

I know that this is their view. Nonetheless, it still pains me when I see them saying so in such stark black and white terms. I am referring to the recent statement by the Agudah Moetzes endorsing the views of their Israeli counterparts on the issue of drafting Yeshiva students. They are obviously very opposed.

While I accept that the members of the Moetzes are talmidei hachamim with few peers; and that their views should be respected, I have to say that there are times – like this one – that makes it very difficult for me to do so. Not because I don’t respect their knowledge. Nor do I suspect that their views are anything but l’shem shomayim – for the sake of heaven. I truly believe that they are selfless human beings that have dedicated their lives to doing the will of God and serving Klal Yisroel.

Here is a translation of their most recent proclamation from the Baltimore Jewish Life:

We are deeply dismayed by the efforts in Eretz Yisroel to draft B’nei Yeshiva and remove them from the Beis Medrash, the wellspring of Torah to which they dedicate their days and nights. The perseverance and security of Hashem’s people are rooted in its dedication to Torah study, as Chazal comment on the posuk “Our feet were standing at your gates, Yerushalayim”: “What will enable our feet to stand firm in war? The gates of Yerushalayim, where [Jews] devote themselves to Torah study.”

We appeal to the members of the government in Israel not to take any steps that will in any way negatively affect the B’nei Yeshiva and their study of Torah. For Torah study is “our life and the length of our days,” which will “lead us, upright, forever.” Like I said, this is no surprise. But it bothers me just the same. I understand the issue. They say that Torah study is what saves the world. That without it, the world would cease to exist… and that certainly Torah study is what protects the Jewish people. Granted. But what this statement does not say is that security requires not only Torah study but in the case of Israel – an army. This very simple fact – and it is a fact – was acknowledged in public by Rav Haim Shmulevitz, a Gadol of an earlier generation. I can’t even count anymore the times I’ve quoted this revered sage of the 20th century on this issue. He did not make it up. Nor is there any rabbinic opposition to this fact. It is the truth. It’s called hishtadlus – maximum mental and physical effort. Hishtadlus in this case requires that we do whatever earthly things we can to accomplish the goal of protecting Jewish lives. Which means that we do not rely on miracles. If there were no army, there would be no hishtadlus. It is true that Torah holds up the world. But as R’ Haim said we need not only a spiritual army. We need a physical army as well. If that were not so, there would no such thing as a milchemes mitzvah (a war mandated by God). We would just all sit in a beis hamedrash and study Torah until our enemies were destroyed by fire and brimstone from heaven. David HaMelech captured Jerusalem not by staying in the beis hamedrash but by going to war.

This statement does not address that issue. Nor does it answer the pain and suffering of families whose sons have been maimed or killed in doing their hishtadlus in battle, while yeshiva students do theirs in relative safety. The idea of “sharing the burden” which is what proponents of drafting Haredim want – is based on this kind of inequity. Why do they not address it? How can they not? How can they just say they are dismayed by a possible draft without addressing this issue?

Nor do they explain why they feel that the status quo ante should remain untouched in any way? I could better understand if they had said that there ought not be a draft for Haredim – if they qualified it with the requirement to root out those who are faking it or just going through the motions because of peer pressure. Or maybe even those who are learning but not quite at the level one would expect of someone who is Torah umnaso (Torah is his job).

About the Author: Harry Maryles runs the blog "Emes Ve-Emunah" which focuses on current events and issues that effect the Jewish world in general and Orthodoxy in particular. It discuses Hashkafa and news events of the day - from a Centrist perspctive and a philosphy of Torah U'Mada. He can be reached at hmaryles@yahoo.com.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

One Response to “Disappointed But Not Surprised”

  1. Yehuda Cohen says:

    Liad, Talmud Ta’anit 21b. Every day a heavenly voice emanated from the academy on High and sent greetings to Abba Umna. The same greeting was made to the more learned scholars of that time, Abbaye every Friday afternoon and to Rava was greeted only on the day before Yom Kippur. Why the big difference in Heavenly greetings between the sages of that time? It was revealed to them that they could not match Abba Umna when it came to good deeds.
    Deut: 4:1, “And Israel, listen to the statutes and laws that I am teaching you to do….” Moses stressed “to do.” In Psalms 111:10 “The beginning of wisdom is the fear of G-d (a person should study Torah to know what to do and what not to do) good intelligence to all those who do it.” If a person’s intent in studying Torah is to do the commandments, G-d opens His heart and gives him the intelligence to understand the Torah.
    Avoth 2:2 “Rabban Gamaliel, …said: ‘The study of Torah is good together with the way of the world (derekh eretz דרך ארץ) … And all Torah that is not accompanied by work will be abandoned in the end, and it will bring about sin….” Dererkh eretz is not only getting along with people but many authorities say that dererkh eretz is a worldly occupation, profession, trade or business. (IMO, this does not mean to go out and beg for money as a profession). It is stated that Torah is fine with a worldly occupation. One must have Torah together with an occupation. Both are necessary; one cannot exist without the other. (Rashi; Rambam; Bertenoro (Yad, Talmud Torah 3:10)

Comments are closed.

Binyamin and Chaya Maryles, uncle and aunt of Emes Ve-Emunah author Harry Maryles.
Current Top Story
Daniel Lubetzky  president of V15 and CEO of Kind "healthy" bars
No Victory for V15 and Not Healthy ‘Healthy’ Snack Bars
Latest Blogs Stories
Doug Goldstein

How do money managers take care of your money? And have you ever heard of “socially responsible” investing?

05_04_51---Candle_web

In the memory of loved ones, I commit to continue the fight for our survival in their blessed memory

taxes-646509__180

The US Consulate in Israel should have people helping US citizens on various tax & benefits issues

Abbas sits behind "Palestine" sign at the United Nations.

This whole Arab Palestinian myth was concocted to prevent a viable Jewish state.

Teaching integrity is allowing family, friends, and associates see the business of living your life.

Chumros-YES! But when it comes to the Chilul HaShem described in the article they couldn’t care less

Yarmouk is the opportunity for “Pro-Palestinian” groups to prove they aren’t just anti-Israel.

Why are employers reluctant to hire Charedim? Legitimate concerns or plain old fashioned prejudice?

Obama’s policies are endangering world peace. This isn’t just an “Israel problem.”

What are common market risks and how do they affect your investments?

Regavim is an NGO whose mandate is to preserve the land of Israel for the State & the Jewish people

The “elephant in the room” is concern a deadlock pressures Bibi to forge a National Unity Government

Just like the shoppers on Black Friday those attending Rav Wosner’s funeral were oblivious to others

America’s in trouble. Is Obama too young or too close-minded to recall Americans fleeing Vietnam?

That Soren Kam, a totally unrepentant Nazi murderer, died a free man is a failure of justice

Iran not only hates the ‘Little Satan’, Israel, they hate the US- “The Great Satan too.

More Articles from Harry Maryles
litter

Chumros-YES! But when it comes to the Chilul HaShem described in the article they couldn’t care less

Chareidi at work on computer

Why are employers reluctant to hire Charedim? Legitimate concerns or plain old fashioned prejudice?

Just like the shoppers on Black Friday those attending Rav Wosner’s funeral were oblivious to others

Iran not only hates the ‘Little Satan’, Israel, they hate the US- “The Great Satan too.

Daas Torah has been extrapolated to include ‘asking a Gadol’ about every decision one makes in life

Studies have shown that there are more people leaving Orthodoxy than are coming in.

Obama wants a deal at any price, ending sanctions that brought Iran to the table in the first place

Israel’s Charedi world is in financial crisis. If the trend worsens it may be their breaking point.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/blogs/haemtza/disappointed-but-not-surprised/2013/02/21/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: