web analytics
November 26, 2014 / 4 Kislev, 5775
At a Glance
Blogs
Sponsored Post
IDC Herzliya Campus A Day on Campus

To mark IDC Herzliya’s 20th anniversary, we spent a day following Prof. Uriel Reichman, IDC’s founder and president, and Jonathan Davis, VP for External Relations, around its delightful campus.



Is Renouncing United States Citizenship Effective Protest?


cancelled passport

My fellow blogger and mainstay of Havel Havelim, the one and only Esser Agarot, has announced that he has begun the process of renouncing his American Citizenship. There was a time when American immigrants olim to Israel had to choose between holding onto their American citizenship and refusing Israeli citizenship or giving up (renouncing) American citizenship when they became Israeli citizens. Soon before our aliyah the law in the states changed which made it possible to be dual Israeli and American citizens.  Actually, it wasn’t the law, it was the interpretation of the law by the Supreme Court Justices.  As one of my Great Neck North Social Studies teachers, whose name I have unfortunately forgotten, used to say:

“American Law is whatever five out of nine Supreme Court Justices say it is.”

He made it clear that there was a fluidity in Law due to interpretations, which doesn’t require actually rewriting the law.

The problematic issue in being both American and Israeli had to do with serving in the Israeli Army, if I remember correctly.  It was permitted to be drafted, but if an American enlisted in the IDF, it could be seen as a disloyalty which would endanger citizenship.  So, in the middle of the 1960′s Israeli citizenship was written tailor-made to suit American immigrants. There was a status of “Temporary Resident” that automatically morphed into full citizen after three years unless the person went to the Israeli Ministry of the Interior and filled out a form refusing citizenship.  There was no such procedure when I brought my father on aliyah a few years ago.

There was a time when Israeli dual citizens could serve in the Knesset as MK’s, but it was changed.  One of the steps one must do to run for a seat in the Knesset is give up aka renounce all foreign citizenship, which does make sense. I think all elected office holders and even other high ranking public officials should be required to give up foreign citizenship. Since I’ve never even attempted any such lofty job or postilion, it doesn’t affect me personally.

But here we’re dealing with pragmatic question. Is foreign citizenship a matter of national loyalty or is it just the convenience of not needing to deal with visas when traveling to various other countries? Recent American citizenship laws or rulings have expanded on the rights of expatriates like myself to not only permit our foreign born children to be eligible for an American passport (though not full-citizenship including voting rights) but the children of those children, too. My grandchildren have all gone to the states to finalize their USA citizenship and now have passports and won’t need visas to enter the United States.

Since over the decades we’re here my husband is in touch with American Consular Officials people come to us with visa nightmare stories.  We have been able to help on very rare occasions. Nowadays the decisions aren’t made locally.  Once someone is refused a visa to the states he or she is pretty-much blacklisted for quite a while.  I don’t see the point in risking being forbidden a visit to family.

I’m glad that we never had to choose between the country of our birth and the country of our choice!

Esser Agaroth has chosen to give up his citizenship as a protest.

But, simply put, the U. S. is no longer my country.  How many times on Esser Agaroth have I said that Israel is the only true homeland of the Jewish People? A lot. Why should I keep my U. S. citizenship? For travel? For emergencies? Well, I have already gotten those scenarios covered, and I can use my Israeli passport,…if I really needed to. I have not left Eretz Yisra’el in 15 years, and have not set foot in the U. S. for 16 years, and have no intention of ever doing so again.

Also, why on earth should I allow the government of a country, not my own, continue to stick its nose into my business, financial and otherwise?

I have also not voted since before the presidential election of 2000, due to never getting my application for an absentee in time, in order to send it back in time, in order to receive my absentee ballot with enough time to send it back on time. Bush vs. Gore. Remember that one?

Esser Agaroth’s decison is his own and it suits him. It’s not for me.

Visit Me-Ander.

About the Author: Batya Medad blogs at Shiloh Musings.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

5 Responses to “Is Renouncing United States Citizenship Effective Protest?”

  1. Don’t wanna be here. Then by all means leave. Bye bye.

  2. Debbie Henderson says:

    So, when US and Israeli interests collide, you're not prepared to choose one over the other?

  3. Debbie Henderson says:

    I doesn't appear to be a "protest" as much as a decision based on principle. One which other principled people can only admire, even if they might
    disagree.

  4. Thanks, Batya, for bringing this issue into a more public discussion! Flewelling Bennie and Haddad Mansour, I already have,…going on 17 years now! :-) http://esseragaroth.blogspot.com/

  5. Joshua Grady-Share says:

    I still have not got Canadian citzenship for my kids and not sure if I will. I myself still have a CAN passport because my company has paid to renew it instead of the cost of a US visa. If I fly anywhere but North America, it is always on my Israeli passport, only. I thank Canada for giving a haven for my grandparents and think it is an awesome country, but I left 20 years ago, and have left pretty much everything lapse into expiration. Thankfully, Canada does not hound ex-pats.

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
President Obama overlaid against photo of Jonathan Pollard.
The Hidden Reason the United States Won’t Release Pollard.
Latest Blogs Stories
About 7 in 10 Americans view Israel favorably – making Israel the only positively viewed Middle East country. But the younger Americans get, the more they like some Arab countries.

Undoubtedly, once he’s “former president Obama” he’ll join anti-Israel Jimmy Carter against Israel.

train track grafitti

The silly people on the left have created a new campaign to try and force the rest of the country to capitulate to their suicidal fantasies, this time by riding trains and imposing themselves onto other people’s conferences.

Doug Goldstein

Find out how to set goals and take better care of your finances.

Does this look like a scene where Israeli police might have shot "two Palestinian civilians," as CNN claimed?

As events over the last couple of weeks amply demonstrate, the status quo isn’t working out either

Australian Ambassador to Israel ran to the hospital in J’m to visit the wounded and to donate blood

Those celebrating violence with “No Justice No Peace” signs are opposed to both justice and peace.

Pop quiz: The shortest book ever written? “Palestinian History and Positive Contributions” text book

We are the continuing generations from our Father Avraham who was given this Land by our L-rd.

When a country supports ($) the PA or Gaza or “recognizes,” “Palestine,” they promoting terrorism.

There is no question whatsoever that Odeh was behind the fatal bombing of a SuperSol market in 1969

As we Jews returned to the Holy Land and prayed at our holy sites, forces fighting holiness came too

Channel 10 TV published on Sunday a poll they commissioned asking Israeli Arabs a rather straightforward but important question:

Today”s discussion: “The effects of current geopolitical situation around the world on investing.”

According to PM Netanyahu, the bill would enshrine full equality under law to all Israeli citizens.

Master Sergeant Zidan Saif (Zt”L) a Druze from the Galilee, was shot and killed saving Jewish lives.

President Rivlin’s recent statements are only half right, and that’s why he’s completely wrong.

More Articles from Batya Medad
About 7 in 10 Americans view Israel favorably – making Israel the only positively viewed Middle East country. But the younger Americans get, the more they like some Arab countries.

Undoubtedly, once he’s “former president Obama” he’ll join anti-Israel Jimmy Carter against Israel.

Pal nation

Pop quiz: The shortest book ever written? “Palestinian History and Positive Contributions” text book

When a country supports ($) the PA or Gaza or “recognizes,” “Palestine,” they promoting terrorism.

According to PM Netanyahu, the bill would enshrine full equality under law to all Israeli citizens.

Bibi’s promising a good battle, not a victory in the war; We need to WIN the war against terrorism!

For 1000s of years it was perfectly OK for Jews to pray on Herod’s Extension of the Temple Mount.

The Leftist Israeli media has always been unabashedly political;To them “objective”=”in my opinion”

Why do Moslems have de facto sovereignty in the place holiest to Jews?

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/blogs/shiloh-musings/is-renouncing-united-states-citizenship-effective-protest/2014/03/05/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: