Wednesday, May 16, 2012 - 24 Iyar 5772
 
Scoops

 
You must be logged in to post
Search Forums:


 






Minimum search word length is 4 characters – Maximum search word length is 84 characters
Wildcard Usage:
*  matches any number of characters    %  matches exactly one character

Friedman's Flying Elephant in the Room

This post is: FOR DISCUSSION
No Tags
Post
Junior Member
Junior Member

D. G.

posts 53

9:49 am February 23, 2012

Thomas Friedman writes in Egypt's step backward:

Amazing. What Abul Naga is saying to all those young Egyptians who marched, protested and died in Tahrir Square in order to gain a voice in their own future is: “You were just the instruments of the C.I.A., the U.S. Congress, Israel and the Jewish lobby. They are the real forces behind the Egyptian revolution — not brave Egyptians with a will of their own.”
Not surprisingly, some members of the U.S. Congress are talking about cutting off the $1.3 billion in aid the U.S. gives Egypt’s army if these Americans are actually thrown in prison. Hold off on that. We have to be patient and see this for what, one hopes, it really is: Fayza’s last dance. It is elements of the old regime playing the last cards they have to both undermine the true democratic forces in Egypt and to save themselves by posing as protectors of Egypt’s honor.
Egyptians deserve better than this crowd, which is squandering Egypt’s dwindling resources at a critical time and diverting attention from the real challenge facing the country: giving Egypt’s young people what they so clearly hunger for — a real voice in their own future and the educational tools they need to succeed in the modern world. That’s where lasting dignity comes from.

There's something missing in all this. One group has come to the defense of the old regime, threatening to reconsider the Camp David Accords, if the United States (justifiably) cuts its aid to Egypt. That is the Muslim Brotherhood, as David Kirkpatrick of the New York Times reported last week:

The Islamist party that leads the new Egyptian Parliament is threatening to review the 1979 peace treaty with Israel if the United States cuts off aid to the country over a crackdown on American-backed nonprofit groups here.
The pact is considered a linchpin of regional stability, and the statements, from at least two senior leaders of the party, the political arm of the Muslim Brotherhood, represent the first time that Egyptians have explicitly raised it during an escalating standoff over the crackdown.

Why wouldn't Friedman mention that the Muslim Brotherhood is in cahoots with Mubarak's old cronies?

Nearly two months ago, Friedman wrote Watching elephants fly:

To not be worried about the theocratic, antipluralistic, anti-women’s-rights, xenophobic strands in these Islamist parties is to be recklessly naïve. But to assume that the Islamists will not be impacted, or moderated, by the responsibilities of power, by the contending new power centers here and by the priority of the public for jobs and clean government is to miss the dynamism of Egyptian politics today.

The blind optimism of the column was readily apparent at the time. Now, the Muslim Brotherhood shows its true colors and Friedman doesn't acknowledge his mistake; he just ignores it and assumes that no one will remember what he wrote just a few weeks ago.


About the JewishPress Forum

Forum Timezone: Asia/Jerusalem

Most Users Ever Online: 146

Currently Online:
14 Guests

Currently Browsing this Topic:
1 Guest

Forum Stats:

Groups: 2
Forums: 10
Topics: 594
Posts: 801

Membership:

There are 5262 Members

There are 4 Admins
There are 18 Moderators

Top Posters:

News 1 – 489
D. G. – 53
Jameel@Muqata – 21
The Tazpit News Agency – 2
Asher Schwartz – 1

Recent New Members: dvoraelyachar, The Tazpit News Agency, wisemanchelm, alizaeven-tov, heshyr, Hennie

Administrators: Steve (23 Posts), Stephen Leavitt (2 Posts), marc (1 Post), Dovid (0 Posts)

Moderators: Black Hawk (244 Posts), Jewish Press Staff (4 Posts), Shirag Gupta (2 Posts), Yori Yanover (1 Post), Yishai Fleisher (0 Posts), Rafi Harkham (0 Posts), rosieperper (0 Posts), esterweiss (0 Posts), Meir (0 Posts), Chumi Friedman (0 Posts), Malkah Fleisher (0 Posts), TestAdmin (0 Posts), Sam Ser (0 Posts), Jason (0 Posts), Yocheved Seidman (0 Posts), marimordfin (0 Posts), Steve K. Walz (0 Posts), Jason Maoz (0 Posts)



 

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/opinions/why-do-some-jewish-groups-have-a-problem-with-legal-protection-for-jewish-students/2012/05/16/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: