web analytics
July 28, 2015 / 12 Av, 5775
At a Glance
InDepth
Sponsored Post


The Tal Law and Jewish Law – In Conflict?

Ultra Orthodox Jewish youths studying religious texts at a Yeshiva in Jerusalem

Ultra Orthodox Jewish youths studying religious texts at a Yeshiva in Jerusalem
Photo Credit: Nati Shohat / Flash90

The concept of ‘Toratan omanutan’ (‘Torah is their occupation’) has become distorted in recent decades. In the Talmud, it is applied to Rabbi Shimon Bar Yochai and his cohorts, who were so completely devoted to Torah, they did not need to interrupt their studies to recite the Shema and Amidah (Shabbat 11a). The ‘Kollel Concept’ has evolved into a societal expectation, where it assumed that every young Haredi man spend many years studying fulltime before and after marriage. Even those who are not the best and brightest, not our future spiritual leaders – rabbis, teachers, and poskim – are expected to devote themselves fully to Torah study, instead of pursuing a career.

This was not always the case. Jewish Tradition has always valued Torah im derech eretz, the healthy balance of Torah study and work. After all, the Sages of the Talmud were woodcutters and water-carriers. Even into the 20th Century, many Rabbis balanced their role as spiritual leader with a parnassa. Rabbi Moshe Feinstein and family, for example, used to sell candles and yeast in Luban. And as is well known, the Chafetz Chaim owned a small grocery store with his wife.

In the early days of Statehood, when Rabbi Avraham Yeshaya Karelitz, the famed Chazon Ish, and other leading rabbis reached a compromise with David Ben Gurion to provide military exemptions for yeshiva students, only some 400 students were exempted. Writing about a Milchemet Mitzvah, the Chazon Ish himself recognized that “if there is a need for them, they must come to the aid of their brethren” (Orach Chaim, Eiruvin, no. 114). Over time, the number of exemptions has grown to become %15 of the population, a significant percentage. How the words of the Chazon Ish ring true today!

Those who do not serve in the IDF claim exemption under the guise of Toratan omanutan, their complete commitment to Torah study. But the real issue is not one of halacha. The truth is that for many, the insistence on exemption is one of convenience. Yet others are motivated by anti-Zionism. They do not want to recognize the Modern State of Israel or serve in its army. If we were honest with ourselves, we would admit that halacha requires some form of service – for everyone. No exceptions. No exemptions.

Moshe’s argument to the Tribes of Reuven and Gad, “Shall your brothers go out to battle while you sit here?” (Num. 32:6) resonates today with those who see the imbalance of the current situation. Israelis who do serve in the IDF harbor feelings of anger and resentment towards their coreligionists who do not. Many are also upset by the government’s financial support of Haredi yeshivot and institutions, whose beneficiaries do not serve. What’s missing is a sense of equality; a sense of shared responsibility; and a sense of shared destiny.

For those who want to balance their commitment to Torah study with a commitment to Army service, Hesder (lit. arrangement), is the best of both worlds. Hesder units are comprised of the best and the brightest – serious talmidei chachamim and serious soldiers – serving in the most elite combat units, many of whom rise in rank due to their devotion.

Recent years have seen a gradual shift in the Haredi attitude towards military service. Haredi units, which offer religious accommodations to soldiers, are growing in size due to the educational and career opportunities they offer young people. In addition, new technical schools, catering to Haredi men and women, encourage greater integration into Israel’s workforce. While only a small percentage of the Haredi community currently takes advantage of these programs, there is movement in a positive direction.

The future is uncertain, with the Kadima party leading a committee that will propose an alternative to the Tal Law, set to officially expire on July 31st. But one thing is certain: The current situation has become untenable. Prime Minister Netanyahu has stated that he is committed to “a more egalitarian and just law,” to replace the status quo. His promise is not just good politics in an election year – it’s what Jewish Law requires.

About the Author: Rabbi Shimshon HaKohen Nadel lives and teaches in Jerusalem.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

No Responses to “The Tal Law and Jewish Law – In Conflict?”

Comments are closed.

Current Top Story
Muslim man speaking with a group of women at the Dome of the Rock mosque on the Temple Mount.
‘Israel Police Should Give Jews a Free Hand on Temple Mount, Like They Do Arabs’
Latest Indepth Stories
Hamas on the Temple Mount - Jul 3, 2015

Magnanimity by Moshe Dayan, allowing Muslim control of the Temple Mount, led to today’s situation.

Community-Jewels-logo

It was modeled upon a similar fund that had been set up by Sephardic Jews in Venice. But Amsterdam’s Dotar was initially more ambitious in scope.

Brudner-072415-Rav-Aharon

Rav Aharon Margalit is a bestselling author – his book, As Long As I Live, has been translated into four languages – and a standing-room only lecturer. Both religious and non-religious audiences flock to hear him. What makes him so extraordinary? Rav Margalit is a Chasidic Jew who experienced incredible challenges from a very young […]

J Street president, Jeremy Ben-Ami.

J Street is the vanguard (Jewish face)in support of Obama’s Vienna Accords Nuclear Deal with Iran

“I hold the woman’s place over that of men in every fundamental aspect of public and private life.”

The US-UNRWA accord is another example of this White House, hostile to Israel, disregarding truth.

On the saddest day on the Jewish calendar, Tisha B’av, a reflection on the dangerous deal with Iran

The Kotel gained significance around 1550. Previously, many Jews prayed on the Temple Mount itself.

All Jews MUST stand together to oppose boycotts against Israel. So why does NIF & JCF support BDS?

This year it is hard to concentrate on anything but Iran building nuclear weapons to destroy Israel

Bibi failed the moment he transferred Israel’s Iran problem to the international arena.

I was entranced by Kaddish, a song of sorrow of the whole of Israel for the 1000s of years of exile

Like the Avos, we are invested with the mission to inspire humanity to become nobler and greater

Iran accords are worse than Munich; even Chamberlain would be shocked at what is transpiring again.

An unhappy person cannot become happy by acquiring items. Happiness has to come from somewhere else.

Torah wasn’t given to be kept in Sinai; Brooklyn or Beverly Hills-It was meant to be kept in Israel!

More Articles from Rabbi Shimshon HaKohen Nadel
The Vilna Gaon

All secular wisdom is essential for our Holy Torah and is included in it.

Nadel-050313

A flag with the Star of David hung prominently in the synagogues of Prague since the mid-14th century, with the approval of their great rabbis.

Minutes after candle-lighting, sirens rang out in Jerusalem, disturbing the peace and tranquility ushered in by Shabbat. Earlier that day, my wife and I assured our parents that we are far from the rockets in our home in Har Nof, a quiet suburb nestled in the Jerusalem Forest.

In February, Israel’s Supreme Court ruled the Tal Law discriminatory and unconstitutional in a vote of six to three. The law, which provides exemptions for young men studying in yeshiva full time, has been the subject of much criticism and controversy.

The message of the Biblical account of the Spies has tremendous relevance today, here in the modern State of Israel. With a nuclear threat from Iran, enemy states on its borders, the ever-constant fear of terrorism, and pressure from the International Community, Israel is not without its challenges. But it’s also the ‘Start Up Nation,’ with a healthy, growing economy when most of the world’s economies are failing.

In the early days of Statehood, when Rabbi Avraham Yeshaya Karelitz, the famed Chazon Ish, and other leading rabbis reached a compromise with David Ben Gurion to provide military exemptions for yeshiva students, only some 400 students were exempted. Writing about a Milchemet Mitzvah, the Chazon Ish himself recognized that “if there is a need for them, they must come to the aid of their brethren.”

It has been said ‘It is easier to take the Jew out of the Exile, than to take the Exile out of the Jew’. While in Egypt, the Jewish people could not even hear Hashem’s promise of Redemption because of their “shortness of spirit.” Their bondage wasn’t merely a physical bondage, but a mental one. And so, while still in Egypt, Hashem began the process of taking the Jew out of the psychology of Exile, ridding him of his slave mentality.

With thousands of Haggadot in print, it can be overwhelming to decide what to buy and what to use at the Seder. Just like kashering the home for Pesach requires preparation, so too the material for the Seder. And according to the investment is the return. Below are twenty of my favorite Haggadot.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/analysis/the-tal-law-and-jewish-law-in-conflict/2012/06/11/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: