web analytics
August 30, 2016 / 26 Av, 5776
InDepth
Sponsored Post


Time For A Presidential Clarification

Palestinian Authority president Mahmoud Abbas’s statement last Saturday that “Israeli intransigence” was behind the collapse of the recently convened Israel-Palestinian talks in Jordan may provide a moment of truth for President Obama.

According to The New York Times’s Ethan Bronner, citing senior officials from both sides, Israeli negotiators told their Palestinian counterparts that their guiding principle for future borders in a two state solution would include existing settlement blocs as part of Israel. The Palestinians summarily rejected this. Significantly, a Palestinian spokesman said that “Our starting point is the 1967 borders with minor swaps and theirs is the wall and settlements.” (The wall refers to the separation barrier Israel has been building for a number of years.)

President Obama famously said last spring that he favored final borders based on the 1967 lines with mutual swaps – by which he said he meant to include the major Jewish population centers in the West Bank. Mr. Obama’s formulation, which he claims to have been initially misunderstood, caused a very public confrontation with Prime Minister Netanyahu.

The Palestinian position now pushes things beyond the debate over what President Obama really meant. In the here and now, the Palestinian focus on the 1967 lines with “minor changes” is plainly inconsistent with the notion that “swaps” would include tradeoffs for large population centers.

The question is thus whether President Obama is prepared to take the next step and tell the Palestinians that America stands for Israel’s retaining the major settlement blocs. At the very least, he should declare who he thinks is at fault for the breakdown in the talks.

Editorial Board

About the Author:


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

No Responses to “Time For A Presidential Clarification”

Comments are closed.

Current Top Story
Defense Minister Avigdor Liberman (C) seen during a visit to the North Front Command.
Liberman: No Negotiations With Hamas Over IDF Soldiers’ Bodies
Latest Indepth Stories
West_bank_and_Gaza_Governotates

Rostow, co-author of the November 22, 1967 UN Security Council Resolution 242, resolved that under international law: “Jews have the same right to settle in the West Bank as they have in Haifa.”

Rabbi Nathan Lopes Cardozo

Real religious leaders should not be “honored,” “valued,” or “well respected.

Yishai Fleischer at the HaBeit Conference

Controversial and compelling. the discussion touched on essential issues concerning the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, RESPECTFULLY.

Harvey Rachlin

Jews constitute an insignificant portion of the world’s population, 0.2% Considering the minuscule number. why is there such disproportionate coverage of Jews and Israel?

Drug abuse can be cured, the toll of an overdose reversed. But suicide is irrevocable.

By avoiding confrontations in which Israel can win, Israeli governments risk backing the country into a confrontation which it cannot win.

When one can truly appreciate his uniqueness, he will be able to ascribe value to himself and to others, laying the groundwork for healthier and more fulfilling relationships.

Scottish Police threatened to arrest anyone waving Palestinian flags during the Hapoel Be’er Sheva/Glasgow Celtic. match. There were not a few flags – there were hundreds. And the police did nothing

True peace with Israel’s enemies is not a territorial issue. It’s deeper than that. If we fail to connect to our identity, they will continue to see us as a foreign entity in the Land. Justifiably so.

The admonition not to mistreat gerim in this week’s parsha is not limited to converts. Anyone in any social situation can feel like a ger, it’s just the inevitability of social dynamics

The chasm between how the parties view Israel is clear: Democrats, at best, see moral equivalence between Israel and the PA; Republicans see Israel as a close and valued ally under unprecedented attack

Rabbi Riskin was surprised to learn that a peace plan he supported would make him a Palestinian citizen and thoroughly endanger the existence of the state of Israel.

Applying “intersectionality”—a pseudo-academic theory asserting all social justice movements are inexorably linked, anti-Israel activists have made opposition to Israel and support for BDS a litmus test

Again, this story has dominated the news for days and is doubtlessly known to a wide audience. Yet, for all its potentially serious import, it has still to be fully explored.

He and his family have been key to the remarkable renaissance the borough has enjoyed in recent years.

More Articles from Editorial Board
JewishPress Logo

Again, this story has dominated the news for days and is doubtlessly known to a wide audience. Yet, for all its potentially serious import, it has still to be fully explored.

JewishPress Logo

He and his family have been key to the remarkable renaissance the borough has enjoyed in recent years.

In any event, Mr. Pollard seems unable to persuade federal judges to override the dictates of our prosecutorial bureaucracy and cut him some slack.

Notwithstanding the media spin at the time, led by The New York Times, there were no two sides to the violence.

The candidates we have endorsed are capable, bright, personable, and enthusiastic, and have shown they work well with the Jewish community and all the many other ethnic and religious communities that comprise or will comprise their districts.

As a leader who understands that freedom and earned success are the pathways out of the ghetto, I’m disappointed, too, in any Republicans who feel they need to tiptoe around the patently obvious issue at hand…

The voters will ultimately have to decide how far she can reasonably rely on the competence issue.

Her election to the civil court would be an inspiration to all frum girls, from chassidic as well as non-chassidic

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/editorial/time-for-a-presidential-clarification/2012/02/01/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: