web analytics
September 17, 2014 / 22 Elul, 5774
At a Glance
InDepth
Sponsored Post
Apartment 758x530 Africa-Israel at the Israel Real Estate Exhibition in New York

Africa Israel Residences, part of the Africa Israel Investments Group led by international businessman Lev Leviev, will present 7 leading projects on the The Israel Real Estate Exhibition in New York on Sep 14-15, 2014.



Who Speaks for Modern Orthodoxy?


Clearly, the Modern Orthodoxy envisioned and informed by the teachings of the great Torah leader Rav Yosef Dov Soloveitchik, zt”l, has been gradually disappearing before our eyes.

Clearly, the Modern Orthodoxy envisioned and informed by the teachings of the great Torah leader Rav Yosef Dov Soloveitchik, zt”l, has been gradually disappearing before our eyes.
Photo Credit: YU News

Last week’s announcement by two prominent Modern Orthodox yeshivas that they will permit female students to put on tefillin is just the latest indication of a widening schism among Modern Orthodox Jews. For a concise overview of recent developments, see Uriel Heilman’s article, Tefillin Controversy Latest Sign of Emerging Orthodox Schism.

And while debate over halachic permissibility has been the focus of this newest controversy, the issue itself has brought to the fore a crisis facing the Modern Orthodox movement. Briefly, there seem to be few universally accepted standards as to precisely what constitutes Modern Orthodoxy and, perhaps more significantly, a crisis of leadership has become apparent.

The movement’s outliers, apparently intent on defying consensus and going where none have gone before, are rarely confronted, at least publicly, by mainstream Modern Orthodox leaders. Thus the new becomes the norm and the movement changes by accretion. Clearly, the Modern Orthodoxy envisioned and informed by the teachings of the great Torah leader Rav Yosef Dov Soloveitchik, ztl, has been gradually disappearing before our eyes.

We are not unmindful of the many social pressures – particularly those emanating from Orthodox feminist circles – that drive the outliers. But for the community of the Ribbono Shel Olam, which believes in the centrality and transcendence of halacha, the questions of who decides for us and by what process are on a par with what is decided.

Halachic decisions affecting the community are not properly made by self-appointed agents of a popular movement. That is a function of those with the greatest erudition in the Talmud and halachic sources, and even within that august grouping consensus building is central.

And so, in the face of this latest assault on the Modern Orthodoxy envisioned by the Rav, we find disheartening the relative silence of the Rabbinical Council of America, the Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations of America, and the roshei yeshiva of Yeshiva University’s Rabbi Isaac Elchanan Theological Seminary. Only these institutions and individuals, as the flagships of Modern Orthodoxy, have the standing and influence to stanch the movement’s creeping leftward drift.

As the old maxim has it, shtikah kehoda’ah – silence is assent.

About the Author:


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

13 Responses to “Who Speaks for Modern Orthodoxy?”

  1. Israel Man says:

    Those who keep silent know in their heart that the leading forces of modernity are correct. Yes, halachically correct, but they have no guts to join in. There is no halachic base to keep women out of the Synagogue. There is historical evidence of great women who put on Tefillin. Keeping modernity out will send poeple out of the camp too. Only a generation ago women were discouraged from learning Torah and look at the women's yeshivot today. Pulling Orthodoxy toward extremism and rejection of modernity will be its demise.

  2. Larry Rosen says:

    With all due respect, I know what I think, and you are totally wrong. I respect the Rabbeim that I grew up with, who I learn with today and that's what is "IN MY HEART'. I know what's in my heart – you don't.

  3. It is worth at least noting that most of the participants in the lively debate that *has* been taking place in Modern Orthodox circles about this question are students (or grand-students) of Rabbi Soloveitchik.

  4. Daniel Schwartz says:

    I don't know who does, but the Jewish Press doesn't.

  5. Shimon Chaim Ben Michael says:

    Really, 'Israel Man', what 'historical evidence of great women who put on Tefillin' would you like to share with us?

  6. Samuel Heilman says:

    I had no idea that modern orthodoxy was "the community of the ribono shel haolom." I thought as Isaiah said (41:10) fear not, for I am with you; be not dismayed, for I am your God;

  7. Reb Yid says:

    And Moshe Rabbeinu's descendant worshipped avodah zara.

  8. Israel Man says:

    Shimon Chaim Ben Michael
    Bruria, rabbi Meirs wife and Rashi's daughters.

  9. Shimon Chaim Ben Michael says:

    Israel Man oh dear, a peddlar of fairy tales… http://www.ou.org/torah/article/tzarich_iyun_rashis_daughters#.Uuq2PPl_uX8

  10. Rabinic bullies hiding their misogyny in a barrage of halachic jargon.

  11. What could be more true than the subtitle: "Clearly, the Modern Orthodoxy envisioned and informed by the teachings of the great Torah leader Rav Yosef Dov Soloveitchik, zt”l, has been gradually disappearing before our eyes" – of course it is disappearing, since so much of the world we know is different than the world he knew. The Rav created a great movement – in the middle of the last century. Since than we have lived through "post-modernity" and "post-post-modernity". In mystical terms – "the breaking of the vessels". See Rabbi Shegar.

    The past is very important, but cannot be the sole determinant of the present or the future. Has "Modern Orthodoxy" succeeded in bringing people back to observance? Or only in preserving the members of Modern-Orthodox families? How many of the "new orthodox" [over 110,000 in the USA according to PEW] – are Modern Orthodox, how many Hareidi? The movement of the Rav has split into "more Hareidi" and "less Hareidi" than in the time of the Rav, in Israel and in the US. Changing society is a fact – and an opportunity. Nostalgia will not enable us to make the best of the opportunity.

  12. Motti Inbari says:

    they are afraid Orthodoxy would lean to the left. Come on – the left?! Don't worry, it won't happen.

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
PLO / PA / Fatah leader Mahmoud Abbas.
PA Unity Government Not Unified
Latest Indepth Stories
Egyptian president Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, former Field Marshal and Minister of Defense

Sisi:”The religious nature of the Middle East creates challenges for the governing authorities.”

A Gaza building, reportedly used by Hamas, destroyed by the IDF on August 26, 2014.

For too long the media and international community have been preaching that “Palestinians” bear no responsibility for the consequences of their decisions and they are passive victims of the conflict.

The Iron Dome was called on for the first time in 2013 to intercept a missile fired by terrorists in Sinai at Eilat.

Iron Dome intercepted over 1,000 rockets aimed at Israel with a success rate of over 90% in 2014

We talked about the responsibility that comes with the pen, its potential to influence and inspire.

Amnesty International:The crippling of the power station was “collective punishment of Palestinians”

Originally scheduled to be held elsewhere, the hotel canceled, pressured by local missionary groups

It’s likely that some of the rebel factions, including US clients, have indeed made pacts with ISIS

Imam Tafsirli of the Harlem Islamic center: “You cannot be a Muslim without believing in Jesus”

If simple fuel choice were implemented, the power of petroleum and those who sell it would cease.

Value of IS: It enables people to see the place to which all other Islamist fascism is headed.

“When Frank does something he does it well and you don’t have to worry about dotting the i’s or crossing the t’s.”

President Obama: “ISIL is not Islamic. No religion condones the killing of innocents”

he time of the Uman pilgrimage is upon us, and we dare not ignore the opportunity to highlight the danger.

Healing requires that the victim be validated for being harmed and the guilty assume responsibility.

More Articles from Editorial Board
Arnold-Fine-091214

His many articles on education showed great insight into the problems facing Jewish teachers in a changing student environment.

We cannot forget Secretary Kerry’s obsessive and relentless focus on the Middle East peace process.

The Jewish Press endorses Governor Andrew Cuomo in the Democratic Party gubernatorial primary election.

Reportedly, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, and the United Arab Emirates have formed a bloc that seeks to counter Islamist influence in the Middle East.

One wonders how the IDF could be expected to so quickly determine the facts.

And why would the U.S. align itself on these issues with Turkey and Qatar, longtime advocates of Hamas’s interests?

Several years ago the city concluded that the metzitzah b’peh procedure created unacceptable risks for newborns in terms of the transmission of neo-natal herpes through contact with a mohel carrying the herpes virus.

“Friends stand together in times of crisis,” said Gov. Cuomo.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/editorial/who-speaks-for-modern-orthodoxy/2014/01/29/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: