web analytics
April 2, 2015 / 13 Nisan, 5775
At a Glance
InDepth
Sponsored Post


Seeking Unity In The Ranks Of Israel

Front-Page-061413

The U.S. Supreme Court has taken a similar approach concerning the limiting of fundamental constitutional rights, requiring that any such infringement serve a compelling government interest and be narrowly tailored to serve that interest. In upholding the Conscription Act of 1917, mandating military service for men of suitable age, the court, in Arver v. United States, unanimously recognized the Constitution’s delegation to Congress of the power to declare war and to raise and support armies. The court also recognized the principle of the reciprocal rights and duties of citizens:

It may not be doubted that the very conception of a just government and its duty to its citizens includes the reciprocal obligation of the citizen to render military service in case of need, and the right to compel it.

The U.S. law was universal. Its subsequent repeal, when the nation adopted an all-voluntary military service, did not change its legality. And the country maintained a mandatory selective service registration.

The Israeli Supreme Court revisited the viability of the Tal Law in 2012, holding that the law violated the right to equality and that the Knesset could no longer extend its application. The repeal of the Tal Law required the government to attempt to introduce alternative legislation to stop the differential treatment extended to sectors of the public. It also created momentum for the absorption of the haredi community into the workforce and national or military service.

The recent election brought into the government the HaBayit HaYehudi (Jewish Home) and Yesh Atid (There is a Future) parties, under the leadership, respectively, of Naftali Bennett and Yair Lapid. While holding differing philosophies on certain core issues, the two parties are united in seeking to end inequality in shouldering the military burden.

The legislation they’ve been hammering out would put an end to the rampant military exemptions within the haredi community. Haredi men would be allowed to postpone military or national service for three years, until the age of 21, during which they will still receive state funding for their Torah learning. Following this period, a maximum of 1,800 exemptions per year would be granted for the most talented haredi Torah scholars, with the rest doing either IDF service or civilian national service.

Bennett rejects the notion that haredim are doing their equal share by remaining full time in the yeshivas. “My haredi brothers, army service is also a mitzvah, no less than that,” he says, adding that “the current situation in which thousands of haredim do not serve or work cannot continue. It’s not ethical and it’s not sustainable.”

* * * * *

The Netzah Yehuda Battalion, also known as Nahal Haredi, founded in 1999, is a fully functioning battalion of haredi combat troops established within the IDF to accommodate the religious needs of these soldiers. By all accounts, the battalion functions effectively. In 2007, the Israeli Air Force began the Shahar Program, which integrates haredi youth into technological, logistics and intelligence service for the military, while training them to incorporate these skills into civilian employment. There is no reason why such concepts cannot be implemented on a much larger scale within the IDF.

Bennett’s mention of the mitzvah of military service stems from the words of the Mishnah in Sotah and in Parshat Shoftim. The Mishnah mentions two types of military conflict: obligatory wars (milchemet mitzvah) and discretionary wars (milchemet reshut). According to the Rambam, obligatory wars were those fought by Joshua to liberate Eretz Yisrael from the Seven Nations, the war to eradicate Amalek, and wars “to defend Israel against an enemy that attacks.” A discretionary war would be one undertaken to obtain some other objective, such as extending the borders of the state.

The parshah discusses the nature of warfare and the limited military exemptions during times of discretionary armed conflict. The kohen addresses Israel in collective terms and then advises the military officers to speak to the people, enunciating four exemptions from battle. The first three deal with newly built homes, newly planted vineyards, and the first year of marriage – during which the mind of the would-be soldier is not directed on the mission ahead. The fourth exemption is for the fearful and fainthearted, lest such a person instill the same fear and uncertainty in other soldiers.

About the Author: Charlie Miller is a criminal defense attorney in New York. He served on active duty for six years in the United States Navy from 1994-2000 as an officer in the Judge Advocate General’s Corps, including a year in the White House as a military aide to the president. He is a national board member of the National Council of Young Israel.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

No Responses to “Seeking Unity In The Ranks Of Israel”

Comments are closed.

Current Top Story
Desperate crowd awaits relief aid at Yarmouk Palestinian refugee camp in Damascus.
ISIS Raids Palestinian Camp and Begins to Fulfill Netanyahu’s Prophecy
Latest Indepth Stories
Colonel John Henry Patterson, Commander of the Jewish Legion

An eye-witness claimed, “British troops just stood by” while Arab attacked Jews in then Palestine

Indeed, some caucus members based their decision to stay away from Mr. Netanyahu’s speech on their contention that the Israeli leader had disrespected America’s first black president.

These are fundamental issues for Israel’s security and yet Mr. Abbas refuses even to acknowledge them as grist for negotiations.

Those seeking accounting, finance, business, healthcare, technology, etc., will often enter a specialized graduate degree “track” created by Lakewood’s Professional Career Services, in conjunction with local institutions of higher education, for our alumni.

We are grateful to Hashem that we have been privileged to institute this program and that over the years we have experienced tremendous siyata d’shmaya, with the program spreading throughout the world and its membership rapidly rising.

Indifference to the pain of the many singles should require us to have our heart, not head, examined

The rededication of the Hurva caused international hysteria.Arabs called the action a “provocation”

{Originally posted to author’s website, FirstOne Through} TRUST Trust is the bedrock of a functional relationship. It enables one party to rely on the other. A trust that includes both intention and capability permits a sharing of responsibility and workload. The relationship between US President Obama and Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu started off badly and further […]

Jabotinsky said “Go To Hell” was a good retort to opponents of the Jewish people; fitting for Obama.

Obama pulled off one of US history’s greatest cons,twice fooling a gullible electorate and most Jews

While in Auschwitz I felt a tangible intensity. I could sense that I was in a place of sheer evil.

Obama needs to wake up. The real enemy is not Netanyahu but Iran, Hizbullah, Hamas, Islamic Jihad,IS

My beliefs & actions have led to numerous death threats against me; my excommunication by my church

In November 2014, Islamic Relief Worldwide was classified as a terrorist organization by the United Arab Emirates.

More Articles from Charlie Miller
Netanyahu and Obama at the White House, July 2010. The Israeli PM is trying to do damage control following the, apparently successful, Rouhani charm offensive this week.

What is it about Israel’s Prime Minister Netanyahu that so irks this president?

Front-Page-061413

In every society there is always an internal struggle between individual liberty and collective responsibility. It exists here in the United States, in the form of mandated jury service, for example, and it is at the forefront in Israel where the raging debate regarding mandatory conscription for military service touches on all aspects of societal existence, including religion, economics, and notions of equality.

The ongoing war between Israel and the Hamas terrorist organization brings front and center the nature of this conflict: Palestinian unwillingness to accept the permanent presence of a Jewish state in the Middle East.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/front-page/seeking-unity-in-the-ranks-of-israel/2013/06/12/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: