web analytics
October 24, 2014 / 30 Tishri, 5775
At a Glance
InDepth
Sponsored Post
Meir Panim with Soldiers 5774 Roundup: Year of Relief and Service for Israel’s Needy

Meir Panim implements programs that serve Israel’s neediest populations with respect and dignity. Meir Panim also coordinated care packages for families in the South during the Gaza War.



Home » InDepth » Op-Eds »

Commanders, Rabbis, And The Great Divide


We are told that “a soldier must have a commander, and it isn’t a rabbi.” The defense minister of Israel accuses us – this writer and other Hesder rabbis – of “destabilizing the foundations of Israeli democracy, inciting toward insubordination, damaging the spirit of the Israel Defense Forces,” adding, “there is no room for such things in a civilized state.”

This is a libel – against us and against our holy Torah, whose words are good and correct. Such statements lead the public to think the rabbis are endangering the existence of the army and are designed to arouse hate and animosity toward the rabbis and their positions.

After all, who in his right mind would not be worried about those who endanger the existence of an army that is meant to protect us all? The truth, however, is that there is absolutely no contradiction between a military commander and a rabbi on issues of security, for Jewish law obligates one to listen to the commander, whether during military exercises or an actual war.

Our disagreements with the defense minister are over issues that in no way are connected to security operations, but rather with the use of soldiers against their fellow Jews.

To illustrate just how great a libel has been promulgated, I will relate what I experienced during the Second Lebanon War. At that time, a large sector of the public was suffering from the destruction of Gush Katif and the expulsion of Jews from Gaza. The prime minister, Ehud Olmert, made a miserable statement that victory over Hizbullah would enable hitkonsut (“convergence” – or, in everyday language, retreat from territory in Judea and Samaria).

A question arose from a number of reserve-duty soldiers who received a call-up before the ground forces were about to enter Lebanon: Should they go to war?

I made it clear that it was a mitzvah to go to war. Even when the heads of the army are problematic, and there are errors and obstacles in their directives, it is still a mitzvah to serve in the army. When we Jews did not have an army, our situation was far, far worse.

Some called to ask me whether it would better not to serve in the army because if we won in Lebanon we would be ensuring the future loss of land in Judea and Samaria, thus subjecting the nation to even greater danger. Again I replied – as per my obligation to do so according to my understanding of halacha – that it is a mitzvah to serve.

There were some women who pleaded for an exemption for their husbands, fearing that perhaps because the army took part in the expulsion of Jews from Gush Katif, it hadn’t prepared properly for war, and therefore the risk to the lives of their husbands would be greater. I answered that while the decision was theirs, if the question is what must be done according to halacha, the answer is that their husbands must serve.

Once the women understood it was a mitzvah, they calmed down a little, and were able to sleep at night. I, however, could not sleep.

I was sure that military commanders who for nearly two years had devoted themselves to preparing for the expulsion of Jews from Gaza would not be able to defeat the enemy, because their basic outlook was so distorted. Nevertheless, we were obligated to face the enemy together.

We had 150 students, regular soldiers and reserve, in Lebanon, and with the kindness of God they all returned peacefully, with only one moderately injured. And officers who had been students of Yeshiva Har Bracha killed numerous terrorists and brought all their soldiers home safely.

The IDF is the army of the people, and the boundaries of its use must be clear: to protect against the enemy. When our political and military officials breach this basic rule and use soldiers against their countrymen, as in the expulsion of Jews from their homes in the land of Israel, they are breaching military unity. Not only that, but a Great Divide is erected between the halacha and the military command, for according to the decisions of the great Torah scholars of the previous generation, it is forbidden to expel Jews.

The horrible results of such a divide are twofold: First, the distancing of non-religious and even traditional Jews from the holy Torah, which was given to all of Israel. Second, the distancing of God-fearing Jews from the army, for if the military command blatantly declares it is forbidden for a religious soldier to accept the words of halacha from the rabbis, it creates a conflict between guarding the Torah and serving in the army.

Libel against the Torah and its bearers is nothing new; it has been used for decades by non-religious political parties and caused severe damage. Many Jews have been alienated from their heritage because of such arguments, to the point where the future of many families within the framework of the Jewish nation hangs in doubt.

We, the bearers of Torah, also have a share of blame in this. We closed ourselves up with questions related to our small communities while neglecting issues concerning Klal Yisrael and the society around us. Such behavior has made it all that much easier for the public to accept the anti-religious arguments.

About the Author: Rabbi Eliezer Melamed, a leader of Israel’s religious-Zionist community, is dean of Yeshiva Har Bracha and a prolific author on Jewish Law. His books “The Laws of Prayer,” “The Laws of Passover” and “Nation, Land, Army” are being translated into English. He can be contacted at yonaton@yhb.org.il.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

No Responses to “Commanders, Rabbis, And The Great Divide”

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
Do you know where your vegetables grow?
Not So Kosher Shemittah L’Mehadrin
Latest Indepth Stories
Eller-102414-Cart

I had to hire a babysitter so that I could go shopping or have someone come with me to push Caroline in her wheelchair.

Bills to restore the balance of power in Israel will be fought by the not-so-judicial left.

Widespread agreement in Israel opposing Palestinian diplomatic warfare, commonly called “lawfare.”

Chaye Zisel Braun

Arab terrorism against Jews and the State of Israel is not something we should be “calm” about.

Peace Now Chairman Yariv Oppenheimer

The Israeli left, led by tenured academics, endorses pretty much anything harmful to its own country

We were devastated: The exploitation of our father’s murder as a vehicle for political commentary.

Judea and Samaria (Yesha) have been governed by the IDF and not officially under Israeli sovereignty

While not all criticism of Israel stemmed from anti-Semitism, Podhoretz contends the level of animosity towards Israel rises exponentially the farther left one moved along the spectrum.

n past decades, Oman has struck a diplomatic balance between Saudi Arabia, the West, and Iran.

The Torah scroll which my family donated will ride aboard the USS Gerald R. Ford aircraft carrier

The Jewish Press endorses the reelection of Gov. Andrew Cuomo. His record as governor these past four years offers eloquent testimony to the experience and vision he has to lead the Empire State for the next four years.

I think Seth Lipsky is amazing, but it just drives home the point that newspapers have a lot of moving parts.

Myth #1: It is easy to be a B’nai Noach. It is extraordinarily hard to be a B’nai Noach.

The question of anti-Semitism in Europe today is truly tied to the issue of immigration.

Polls indicate that the Palestinians are much more against a two state solution than the Israelis.

More Articles from Rabbi Eliezer Melamed
Hamas leader Ismail Haniya speaking with Arab security officers, before giving a speech on the first day of the Muslim holiday of Eid al-Adha.

Islam’s approach to God extends to all interpersonal relationships, which are based on honor.

In recent times we have witnessed increasing support for Israel on the part of evangelical Christians. They view the establishment of the State of Israel as the miraculous fulfillment of the vision of the biblical prophets.

The recent appalling murders in Itamar shocked everyone – not just settlers but every Jew without exception, because it wasn’t the Fogel family alone whom the enemy wished to murder, but rather each and every one of us.

We are told that “a soldier must have a commander, and it isn’t a rabbi.” The defense minister of Israel accuses us – this writer and other Hesder rabbis – of “destabilizing the foundations of Israeli democracy, inciting toward insubordination, damaging the spirit of the Israel Defense Forces,” adding, “there is no room for such things in a civilized state.”

Once again, Israeli leftists, with assistance from the media, are composing songs, lighting candles and organizing dances around a new golden calf. This time it is the demand to do “everything possible” to bring home the captured soldier Gilad Shalit.

In reading Parshat Zachor (Deut. 25:17-19) we fulfill the commandment to remember what the nation of Amalek did to us. The sages instituted its reading just before Purim in order to link this mitzvah to the feast day on which we celebrate the blotting out of Haman, who was of Amalekite genealogy.

Rabbi Avraham Isaac HaCohen Kook (1865-1935) was an extraordinary Torah giant. His genius was astounding – there was no field of Torah study he had not mastered. His recall was astonishing – great scholars related that no matter what Torah subject they discussed with him it would appear as if he had just recently learned the issue in depth.

With the arrival of the new year, we must stop to reflect upon our deeds in order to pave the way for self-improvement. The current crisis here in Israel indicates that there is a serious problem. By drawing the necessary conclusions now, we can emerge from these difficulties into the light of solace and salvation.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/opinions/commanders-rabbis-and-the-great-divide/2009/12/23/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: