web analytics
May 28, 2015 / 10 Sivan, 5775
At a Glance
InDepth
Sponsored Post


Home » InDepth » Op-Eds »

God Bless America: A Response

22072-L[1]

I’m writing this as a short response to Tzvi Fishman’s (“Felafel on Rye”) recent blog posts on the 4th of July and Jewish identity.

Tzvi,

I want to start off by saying I agree with much of what you’ve written about Jewish identity and America. American Jews do face serious assimilation and identity issues as they waver between whether they are Americans or Jews first, and all that implies.

In the arguments I saw you have offsite about this, it is abundantly clear that some Jews seem to no longer identify with our daily prayers to return to Israel and to regain our national independence. But consider this, even in Yetziat Mitzraim (Exodus) only 20% of the Israelites left – obviously we should aim for more.

My criticism lies in that I don’t believe you offered enough ‘Hakaras HaTov” (acknowledgement of the good) for what America has given the Jews, and that bothered me.

My grandmother told me that we have to thank God for America, and for all it’s done for us.

Not that it hasn’t done bad by us at different points, or made mistakes, just look how its shamefully using Jonathan Pollard as a loyalty warning to Jews; but still, there have only been a handful of countries that have consistently been good to us and offered us refuge and freedom, and the USA is one of them.

Yes, being in an open society has exasperated the challenges that the Jewish community already faced. But it didn’t create them. It’s not responsible for them. The Enlightenment and assimilation weren’t created in America, it just more easily continued there.

If non-Torah observing Jews are assimilating and disappearing at super-fast rates, they need to consider why (though this sentence does answer the question). While Orthodox Jews need to ask themselves, why have they given up on our 2000 year dream to return home to Israel, while short-sightedly ignoring the very blatant lessons of Jewish history?

The Lubavitch Rebbe, in an answer to a question once said that the US could turn on the Jews overnight.

As strange as it sounds, for a period of time even Poland was once a place of refuge and religious freedom for Jews.

Just like in every other country, no matter how long we’ve been there (particularly ironic if you subscribe to the theory that Columbus and much of his crew were Jews), and how much we’ve given back, we’re still considered guests by our hosts.

So Tzvi, you’re right, America is not the permanent home of the Jews. And our identity is a very different one than America’s.

But also consider this, the Midrash tells us that Moshe Rabeinu refused to strike the water to bring about the plague, because the river has protected him as a baby.

All the more so, America, which has given us the freedom to keep Judaism – even if not all Jews were up to the challenges freedom brought with it.

On July 4th, I will have my frank and beer and proudly say “God Bless America” (TM Irving Berlin) – while I’m at home in Israel.

About the Author: Stephen's company, WebAds, builds and manages online newspapers and websites to high volume readership and profitability - including JewishPress.com.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

4 Responses to “God Bless America: A Response”

  1. Tzvi Fishman says:

    Very nicely stated. How about switching positions? I'll be the JP editor and you write a blog.

  2. Anat Gan says:

    לקח לי קצת זמן להבין למה צבי מתכוון, הרי איש אינו כופה התבוללות על יהודי אמריקה, אבל כל הדרכים מובילות להתבוללות הזאת. ומהן הדרכים? הגשמת החלום האמריקאי רדיפה אחרי כסף וויתור על ערכים…כבר הרבה זמן שזה גם החלום הישראלי. בישראל כולם יהודים אבל הדרך הזאת גם היא תביא להתבוללות, כי אנשים עוזבים את הארץ.

  3. Guests? We are not guests. We are citizens and fully integrated into virtually all facets of American society. I don't think Jews are considered anything but equals among peers in the US. We are all Americans Jews and gentiles alike. It is our national credo. See my post tomorrow, July 4th.

  4. John DeLancy says:

    "The Lubavitch Rebbe, in an answer to a question once said that the US could turn on the Jews overnight."

    It is possible that this will happen; prophecy implies that all 70 nations will be arrayed against Israel. If so, America like every other nation would be judged.

    It is also possible that the US, Canada, Australia, South Sudan, and other countries will remain friends of Israel, sharing the grave danger and great deliverance of G-d's chosen.

    There are lots of people in the named countries and many more who are praying and working for the latter possibility to be what happens in this universe.

    Either way, your task is to come up home to Israel. The rebirth of Israel is Ha'Shem returning you from your exile. To choose to remain in exile is kind, but you can still bless us from the Promised Land. America is and will always be your home; you are and will always be not only accepted but welcome here. Never be afraid of that changing.

    But if G-d's word says be regathered to Israel (or if He says anything at all), follow G-d's word. That's what makes us know your very big family is in fact His Chosen People.

Comments are closed.

Current Top Story
FIFA president Sepp (Joseph) Blatter and PM Benjamin Netanayhu
Netanyahu Warns FIFA: Palestinian Threats Will Destroy International Sport
Latest Indepth Stories

As for the president’s new, softer tone vis-à-vis Prime Minister Netanyahu and Israel, this is most likely being driven by the results of the recent Israeli election.

What especially appeals to us is his grand – some critics would say extravagant –view of what the borders of Israel should look like.

There was something else of great importance in play – something we would have liked to see him take into account before deciding to stand with the boycotters.

Front-Page-052915

The establishment of Hebrew University was a cause much beloved to Einstein who in 1923, during what would be his only trip to Eretz Yisrael, delivered the university’s inaugural lecture on Har Hatzofim (Mt. Scopus) and, discussing the theory of relativity, spoke the first few sentences of his address in Hebrew.

The Golden Square wanted Germany to destroy the British and Jewish presence in their country. The Third Reich craved what was beneath the ground – oil.

Ida Nudel’s account of how the Soviet’s persecuted and punished her was far worse than imagined

{Guest columnist Sarah Manning) Jenny and Sima Solomon are joining with women from all over Israel to swim across the Kinneret to raise funds for Sadnat-Shiluv, a unique program of empowerment for young adults with special needs. Hundreds of religious women are expected to gather on the Kinneret shore for the annual Swim4Sadna women-only sponsored-swim […]

Prof. Wistrich, was THE foremost historian of anti-Semitism; committed spokesman & advocate of Jewry

Jewish Voices for Peace’s 2015 Haggadah is a blatant anti-Israel screed crying, “L’chayim to BDS!”

On his shloshim, I want to discuss a term I’ve heard countless times about Rav Aharon: Gedol HaDor

After obsequious claims of devotion to Israel, Obama took to criticizing Israel on peace process

Mr. Obama, Israeli voters have democratically chosen to apply Israeli sovereignty over Judea&Samaria

Netanyahu so disdains Shaked’s appointment he completely ignored her after the swearing-in ceremony

Ronen Shamir’s just the latest tenured Leftist convicted of sexual misconduct with his own student

More Articles from Stephen Leavitt
Rav Aharon Lichtenstein

What was supposed to have been a 15 minute interview, turned into an intense learning session and intellectual battle, the likes of which I had never experienced in my entire life.

The funeral of Rabbi Shmuel Wosner.

When a body is found murdered in a field, the community leaders must declare, “Our hands did not shed this blood.”

5774 was notable for the national unity the Jewish people achieved. 5775 will bring with it new challenges we must be prepared to face.

Congratulations to all the winners of the JewishPress.com raffle at The Event

There’s a battle going on for Jerusalem’s soul, and Cinema City proves you don’t need to compromise on Shabbat or Kashrut to be a success.

A soldier called up to talk to my 5 year old son…

Your generous donations are helping soldiers continue their search for the kidnapped boys. Thank you.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/opinions/god-bless-america-a-response/2012/07/03/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: