web analytics
October 30, 2014 / 6 Heshvan, 5775
At a Glance
Judaism
Sponsored Post
Meir Panim with Soldiers 5774 Roundup: Year of Relief and Service for Israel’s Needy

Meir Panim implements programs that serve Israel’s neediest populations with respect and dignity. Meir Panim also coordinated care packages for families in the South during the Gaza War.



Following The Majority

Cohen-Rabbi-J-Simcha

Tradition has it that a bat kol declared that we follow Beit Hillel’s rulings over those of Beit Shammai.

Tosafot (Eruvin 6b) note that more people belonged to Beit Hillel than Beit Shammai and therefore the halacha should have followed Beit Hillel based on the rule that we follow the majority opinion (“acharei rabim l’hatot”). What, then, was the purpose of the bat kol? Tosafot suggest that the bat kol taught that the halacha follows Beit Hillel despite the fact that Beit Shammai was sharper and more intellectually agile than Beit Hillel.

Not only does the halacha not follow Beit Shammai, but it seems that ruling like Beit Shammai is actually assur. Berachot 10b states that Rav Tarfon even deserved to be punished for ruling like Beit Shammai.

This Gemara seems strange, though. To apply its reasoning to modern times: The majority of poskim often disagree with the rulings of the Vilna Goan or Rabbi Akiva Eiger, for example, but no one would ever say that a posek deserves to be punished for ruling like these two great rabbinic figures.

The Chatan Sofer (Chatan Torah, P’ticha l’shitat Rov, p.2) notes that majority opinions are not necessarily correct. Indeed, a minority opinion can be more logical and sharper than a majority opinion. Yet, the bat kol in the case of Beit Hillel and Beit Shammai declared that the halacha follows Beit Hillel irregardless and the opinion of Beit Shammai is considered meaningless – “k’man deleisa.” Does that mean that the minority opinions of the Vilna Gaon are also “meaningless”?

One theory (Get Pashut, Kuntras Haklalim 20) maintains that the rule that we follow the majority opinion – even when the minority opinion is offered by a sharper mind – only applies to cases where the two parties talk to one another and hear each other’s arguments. When both opinions, however, are just found in books, one need not follow the majority opinion since the party with the majority opinion might have changed its ruling had it heard the other side’s reasoning.

About the Author: Rabbi Cohen, a Jerusalem Prize recipient, is the author of eight sefarim on Jewish law. His latest, “Jewish Prayer the Right Way” (Urim Publications), is available at Amazon.com and select Judaica stores.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

No Responses to “Following The Majority”

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
Abbas and the Temple Mount: "It's mine, all mine. No Jews allowed.
Abbas Declares Closure of Al Aqsa Mosque a ‘Declaration of War’
Latest Judaism Stories
Rebbetzin Esther Jungreis

Why does Hebrew refer to mothers-in-law as “sunshine” when society often calls them the opposite?

Rabbi Avi Weiss, head of theYeshivat Chovevei Torah. Rabbi Asher Lopatin will be replacing him as head of the school.

Having herself been victimized by Pharoah, Sarah should have been more sensitive to Hagar.

The-Shmuz

Avram’s father was not impressed with the cleverness of his son. In fact, he was so unimpressed that he took him to Nimrod the king, who pronounced him an enemy of the state and attempted to execute him.

Lech Lecha Thumbnail

How do the stories in Lech Lecha help us understand the central tension of Abraham’s life, legacy?

Abraham did not govern society but instead was the representative of God’s kingdom on earth.

Hagar grossly miscalculated her own merits and demonstrated a serious lack of gratitude for Sarai.

Noach was the lonely man of faith living in a depraved world, full of wickedness.

Avraham became a great man during the 175 years of his life, while his predecessors became increasingly wicked, despite staggering knowledge, during their lifetimes of hundreds of years.

Shem realized that he owed his existence to his father who brought him into the world.

Law-Abiding Citizen
‘That Which Is Crooked Cannot Be Made Straight…’
(Yevamos 22a-b)

The flood was not sent to destroy, but to restore the positive potential of the world.

Question: I recently loaned money to a friend who has been able to repay only part of it. This was an interest-free loan. We exchanged a signed IOU, not a proper shtar with witnesses, since I have always trusted her integrity and only wanted a document that confirms what was loaned and what was repaid. Now that shemittah is approaching, what should I do? Should I forgive the loan? And if my friend is not able to repay it, may I deduct the unpaid money from my ma’aser requirement?

Name Withheld

Why is there is no mention of dinosaurs, and other prehistoric animals, in the Torah?

Strict din demands perfection. There is no room for shortcomings and no place for excuses; you are responsible.

Surprisingly, my husband and one son arrived home over half-an-hour earlier than usual. I excitedly shared my perfect-timing story, but my better half one upped me easily.

More Articles from Rabbi J. Simcha Cohen
Cohen-080814-Sign

Is God apologizing for taking away my Father? Is God telling me that He is sorry?

Cohen-Rabbi-J-Simcha-NEW

Question: At Birkat Kohanim, who says the phrase, “Am k’doshecha ka’amur”?

Question: How can one determine whether someone is a true disciple of a rav, Rebbe, or rosh yeshiva?

Question: Does halacha agree with the Supreme Court decision of Roe v. Wade permitting women to have abortions?

Question: When someone puts on a talit to lead services, should he recite a berachah?

Question: A number of synagogues feature bar mitzvah celebrations for elderly Jews. Is this proper?

Hashem understood their complaint and therefore selected the ritual mitzvah of sukkah to test them.

Question: Why is Shavuot celebrated as a two-day Yom Tov?

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/judaism/halacha-hashkafa/following-the-majority/2013/05/30/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: