web analytics
October 25, 2014 / 1 Heshvan, 5775
At a Glance
Judaism
Sponsored Post
Meir Panim with Soldiers 5774 Roundup: Year of Relief and Service for Israel’s Needy

Meir Panim implements programs that serve Israel’s neediest populations with respect and dignity. Meir Panim also coordinated care packages for families in the South during the Gaza War.



Home » Judaism » Parsha »

Can Hashem Tell Us What The Halacha Is?

Taste-of-Lomdus-logo

This column is dedicated to the refuah sheleimah of Shlomo Eliezer ben Chaya Sarah Elka.

There is a famous pasuk in one of this week’s parshiyos, Parshas Nitzavim, which carries strong halachic ramifications.

The pasuk says, “Lo bashamayim hee – the Torah is not in the heavens.” The Gemara in Baba Metzia 59a-b cites a dispute between Rabi Eliezer and the Chachamim regarding the tumah status of an achinai oven. The Gemara says that Rabi Eliezer brought all of the proofs in the world, but the Chachamim did not accept his opinion. Rabi Eliezer then said that if the halacha is indeed like his view, this carob tree should indicate that to us.

Just then the carob tree uprooted and moved either 100 amos or 400 amos. To which the Chachamim responded that one cannot bring a proof from a carob tree. Rabi Eliezer then responded that if the halacha is in accordance with his opinion, the water would prove it. Just then the stream of water began flowing in the opposite direction. The Chachamim responded that this too couldn’t serve as a proof.

Rabi Eliezer then said that the walls of the beis medrash should serve as proof that the halacha is in accordance with his view. Just then the walls of the beis medrash began shaking and nearly fell, until Rabi Yehoshua told the walls that they should not get involved in a dispute among talmidei chachamim. The walls did not fall out of kavod for Rabi Yehoshua, but did not stand erect out of kavod for Rabi Eliezer; rather they remained in their shaken position. Rabi Eliezer then said that the shamayim would prove that the halacha is in accordance with his judgment.

Just then a bas kol asked, “Why are you bothering Rabi Eliezer when the halacha is in accordance with his view in every dispute?” Rabi Yehoshua stood up, saying, “The Torah is not in shamayim.” The Gemara explains that since the Torah was given on Har Sinai, we no longer must listen to what a bas kol says regarding the determination of the halacha. The Torah says that the halacha follows the majority opinion. In this case the Chachamim are the majority – so the halacha should follow them.

Shortly after, Rabi Nosson asked Eliyahu HaNavi what Hashem was doing right then. Eliyahu HaNavi answered that Hashem was smiling and saying, “You have won me over, my son.”

Tosafos there asks about the Gemara in Yevamos 14a that says that the halacha follows Beis Hillel because a bas kol said that the halacha follows them over Beis Shamai. This seems to directly contradict the drasha that the Gemara in Baba Metzia (see above) made from the pasuk in this week’s parshah. Tosafos answers that there is a simple difference. The bas kol in the Gemara in Baba Metzia instructed us to do something that was against the Torah, namely to not follow the majority opinion. However, the bas kol in the Gemara in Yevamos instructed us to follow the Torah; therefore, we listened to that bas kol from shamayim. The reason for the uncertainty is because Beis Shamai was sharper than Beis Hillel. But Beis Hillel was the majority. Tosafos suggests another answer: the bas kol in the Gemara in Baba Metzia only came out of honor for Rabi Eliezer.

According to Tosafos’s second answer, we would generally follow a bas kol if we knew that it was not said out of kavod for someone. According to Tosafos’s first answer, a bas kol can determine who the halacha follows if it does not contradict a law in the Torah.

The Rambam (Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah 9:3) says that we derive from the pasuk that tells us that the Torah is not in the shamayim any longer that if a navi proclaims that Hashem has told him to add a mitzvah, change one in any form, explain a mitzvah in a new manner, or say who the halacha follows, he is a navi sheker and should be put to death by chenek. This applies even if he performs a sign from heaven. The Kesef Mishnah there questions how we could have listened to the bas kol that said that we should follow Beis Hillel if the Torah is not in the heavens, and that a navi may not determine who the halacha follows?

About the Author: For questions or comments, e-mail RabbiRFuchs@gmail.com.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

3 Responses to “Can Hashem Tell Us What The Halacha Is?”

  1. yes. hashem is the one who diticted it to the rabbis who wrote it.

  2. yes. hashem is the one who diticted it to the rabbis who wrote it.

  3. yes. hashem is the one who diticted it to the rabbis who wrote it.

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
Do you know where your vegetables grow?
Not So Kosher Shemittah L’Mehadrin
Latest Judaism Stories
Greenbaum-102414

Noach was the lonely man of faith living in a depraved world, full of wickedness.

Parsha-Perspectives-logo

Avraham became a great man during the 175 years of his life, while his predecessors became increasingly wicked, despite staggering knowledge, during their lifetimes of hundreds of years.

Rapps-Rabbi-Joshua-logo

Shem realized that he owed his existence to his father who brought him into the world.

Daf-Yomi-logo

Law-Abiding Citizen
‘That Which Is Crooked Cannot Be Made Straight…’
(Yevamos 22a-b)

The flood was not sent to destroy, but to restore the positive potential of the world.

Question: I recently loaned money to a friend who has been able to repay only part of it. This was an interest-free loan. We exchanged a signed IOU, not a proper shtar with witnesses, since I have always trusted her integrity and only wanted a document that confirms what was loaned and what was repaid. Now that shemittah is approaching, what should I do? Should I forgive the loan? And if my friend is not able to repay it, may I deduct the unpaid money from my ma’aser requirement?

Name Withheld

Why is there is no mention of dinosaurs, and other prehistoric animals, in the Torah?

Strict din demands perfection. There is no room for shortcomings and no place for excuses; you are responsible.

Surprisingly, my husband and one son arrived home over half-an-hour earlier than usual. I excitedly shared my perfect-timing story, but my better half one upped me easily.

Noach felt a tug, and then heard a rip. His jacket had been caught on the nail, and the beautiful suit had a tear.

Boundaries must be set in every home. Parents and children are not pals. They are not equals.

Noah and his wife could not fathom living together as husband and wife and continuing the human race

The Babel story is the 2nd in a 4-act drama that’s unmistakably a connecting thread of Bereishit

Our intentions are critical in raising children because they mimic everything we parents do & think

A humble person who achieves a position of prominence will utilize the standing to benefit others.

More Articles from Rabbi Raphael Fuchs
Taste-of-Lomdus-logo

Others suggest that one cannot separate Shabbos from Yom Kippur by accepting Shabbos early.

Taste-of-Lomdus-logo

While women are exempt from actually learning Torah, they are obligated in a different aspect of the mitzvah.

The Chafetz Chaim answered that there are two forms of teshuvah; teshuvah m’ahava and teshuvah m’yirah.

Since it is a Rabbinic prohibition we may follow the more lenient opinion.

They ask, how can Rabbeinu Gershom forbid marrying more than one wife, when the Torah explicitly permits it in this parshah?

First, how could a beis din of 23 judges present a guilty verdict in a capital punishment case? After all, only a majority of the 23 judges ruled in favor of his verdict.

According to Rabbi Yishmael one was not permitted to eat such an animal prior to entering Eretz Yisrael, while according to Rabbi Akiva one was permitted to eat animals if he would perform nechirah.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/judaism/parsha/can-hashem-tell-us-what-the-halacha-is/2013/08/29/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: