web analytics
November 28, 2014 / 6 Kislev, 5775
At a Glance
InDepth
Sponsored Post
IDC Herzliya Campus A Day on Campus

To mark IDC Herzliya’s 20th anniversary, we spent a day following Prof. Uriel Reichman, IDC’s founder and president, and Jonathan Davis, VP for External Relations, around its delightful campus.



Israel Guilty of Disproportionate Attacks by not Wiping Out Hamas

The only thing disproportionate is the world’s hatred of Israel.
A miracle, and instructions from Home Front Command, saved hundreds from death when a Grad missile fired by Hamas struck a gas station in Ashdod. Most civilians were in their bomb shelters at the time.

A miracle, and instructions from Home Front Command, saved hundreds from death when a Grad missile fired by Hamas struck a gas station in Ashdod. Most civilians were in their bomb shelters at the time.
Photo Credit: IDF Spokesperson's Unit

International condemnation of Israel is beginning to mount for its supposed “disproportionate response” to Hamas’ latest and escalated missile and rocket war on Israel, but Western leaders do not state what exactly is a “proportionate” response.

The United States, United Nations and the European Union constantly take the lead in pleading for Israel to show “restraint” and not to “escalate” violence after Palestinian Authority attacks, whether from Judea and Samaria, controlled by Mahmoud Abbas, or from Gaza.

What really ruffles the feathers of the Western bleeding hearts is that Israel kills more terrorists and civilian shields in Gaza than the number of Israeli citizens and soldiers who are killed by rocket and missile fire from Hamas, Islamic Jihad and other “unity government” allies.

“The rising death toll has sparked international concern over the proportionality of Israel’s response to rocket fire from Gaza,” The LA Times reported Sunday. “The rockets have struck deeper into Israel than in past conflicts, but have caused only one serious civilian injury. There have been no Israeli deaths as a direct result of a rocket strike.”

It simply is not a fair fight, according to the media establishment and the bleeding heart lefties. Hamas fires inaccurate missiles while Israel uses pinpoint aerial bombing raids to eliminate terrorists.

According to that logic, when Hamas fires rockets that land in open areas in Israel, Israel should fire at open areas in Gaza.

Hamas got “lucky” on Sunday when shrapnel from a rocket seriously injured a 16-year-old boy in Ashkelon. Presumably, Israel should have responded by seriously injuring an innocent 16-year-old Arab.

When Hamas terrorists kidnapped three Israeli yeshiva teenagers a month ago in the Hebron area, Israel promptly clamped a curfew on dozens of Palestinian Authority villages in a search for the boys, who more than two weeks later were found murdered.

Before their bodies were discovered. Israel was vilified for inflicting supposed  “collective punishment” on the Palestinian Authority by looking for the murderers. Days after the bodies were found, Jewish hoodlums barbarically kidnapped and burned to death a 16-year-old Arab from Jerusalem.

The depraved crime was a wrenching punch in Israel’s collective gut, but according to Western logic, the Israeli government itself should have carried out the unthinkable act of kidnapping three Arabs and killing them.

No one would suggest such a horrid thought.

And no one should anyone suggest that Israel react to every missile and rocket attack on its citizens by responding with the same number of rockets and the same results.

A proportionate response to the intention to kill is to kill before the intention is fulfilled.

Why don’t police in American cities, or in any other civilized place in the world, shoot and kill someone trying to kill them? Shouldn’t they wait until the killer “succeeds” before responding?

Of course, then it is too late, but that is a small detail that would ruin the principle of a “proportionate response.”

The real reason that “proportionate response” applies primarily to Israel is the world cannot stand seeing Jews have the upper hand.

Some of the worst condemnations come from American Jews, for whom Israel is supposed to be a nice doggie that woofs when his master, not God but the American liberal Jewish community, says, “Sit.”

They can’t stand Israel being anything that is not an expression of their own attempt at being good Americans by encouraging a State of Israel that doesn’t upset the apple cart of the “loyal American Jew” who needs to be trusted by his non-Jewish government. Israel must not do anything that jeopardizes American Jews’ standing as good loyal Americans. Israel is supposed to be nothing but a safe haven for other Jews who suffer from anti-Semitism in Russia and France, among other countries.

Israel must not be too religious, lest it make it difficult for the top-heavy non-Orthodox American Jewish community to identify with it and according to the American Constitution.

Israel as a nice doggie makes the liberal Jewish American establishment feel safe from anti-Semitism.

A disproportionate response by Israel would make Israel too strong for any American administration, whether headed by Obama , Reagan, Clinton, Bush or whoever is next, to call the shots in the Middle East.

And what would happen if Israel played nice doggie and refrained from killing those who try to kill Israelis?

The Israeli Air Force has eliminated thousands of rockets in Gaza. If they were still in the terrorists’ stockpile, it is more probable, and still is possible, that one or two would kill Israelis. Lots of us.

And you know what the international response would be?

Gee, you see what happens when you don’t sit down and make peace with Hamas.

Arf, arf.

(In the CNN clip below from 2009, during Operation Cast Lead, then-New York Mayor Bloomberg said at 1:00 in the video, “There is no such thing as a proportionate response to terrorism.”)

About the Author: Tzvi Ben Gedalyahu is a graduate in journalism and economics from The George Washington University. He has worked as a cub reporter in rural Virginia and as senior copy editor for major Canadian metropolitan dailies. Tzvi wrote for Arutz Sheva for several years before joining the Jewish Press.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

141 Responses to “Israel Guilty of Disproportionate Attacks by not Wiping Out Hamas”

  1. What is the virtues of a Proportional attack and just what is a Proportional attack? In my book a Proportional attack is you murder one of our people I will kill 1,000 of your, you murder 2 of mine I will kill 10,000 of yours! Get the POINT!? Stop murdering my people are there won’t be any of your people left to murder my people!

  2. lol yeah right.. what are Israeli supposed to do? walk over with flowers and candy and ask nicely to stop firing missiles at civilians?? O.o a multitude of 10,000lbs bunker buster gets the point across much more effectively that firing at civilians is not acceptable behavior. Israel has gone above and beyond to protect civilian collateral damage.. G-D bless Israel

  3. Carolin Knox says:

    As an american Jew, I personally wpuld like to see Israel re-take Gaza. That is the only way to get any quiet. Sort of.

  4. I stand with and pray for Israel.

  5. Ivan Masarik says:

    No , you shoot rockets you get forceful reply…..!

  6. Kahane was right. Self hating Jews should go live with their good friends the ” Palestinians “.

  7. no there guilty of being to good to those Hamas palaistinians terrorist and should have kicked there ass years ago.

  8. Kick their asses!!! They have been begging for it!! Give it to them!!!

  9. Raine Balite says:

    it’s not tit for tat. you do whats necessary to subdue and conquer your enemies.

  10. Barbara Ann says:

    God will curse those who curse Israel :)

  11. Hamas has bitten off a lot more than it can chew.

  12. Go Israel. God will protect the IDF and his people

  13. Yes, but soon the illegal state of the Arabs will be permanently broken.

  14. I know I’m “preaching to the choir” here, but really this is quite crazy; there is no such thing as a disproportionate act; there is only the act of stopping the terror; whatever it takes. We are not negotiating for a better price for girl scout cookies; we’re trying to save the Jewish Nation!

  15. Remember those children’s sports leagues where everyone gets a trophy and nobody “wins”? The gentiles want to set up a summer league for Israel and the Arabs. Stick the trophies where the sun doesn’t shine.

  16. America loves Israel!!

  17. Paula Martin says:

    Um, wasnt it 3 Israeli teens who were found dead first and no one did anything? Israel didnt even launch the first missel… It WAS hamas who fired the first rockets from Gaza! You attack a country, you can expect they will fight back! At least Israel warned the civilians to leave Gaza before striking. Hamas did not…

  18. Karen Bryant says:

    If it was any other country they would have wiped out Hamas. Israel has been patient and shown a great deal of restraint and mercy.

  19. Too bad! What did they think would happen when Israel finally decided to defend herself?! What? Is Israel supposed to set aside all their technology and go back to the stone age with them?!

  20. Too bad! What did they think would happen when Israel finally decided to defend herself?! What? Is Israel supposed to set aside all their technology and go back to the stone age with them?!

  21. Holy Nation of Israel !

  22. Holy Nation of Israel !

  23. Claude Amiel says:

    Dear Jordan I praise your commitment and tenacity I wish all of us will not stay on the sidelines god bless you and your entire family

  24. elliminate islam!

  25. Barbara Ann says:

    If you reference the true law (the law of God Almighty) you will see Israel was appointed and given by God. The law of man has no standing if it contradicts Gods law.

  26. what other nnationn tells the ennemy there going to bomb here this day get real its nnot disperportionnate enough hit them till there ability to strike bback are dismall

  27. what other nnationn tells the ennemy there going to bomb here this day get real its nnot disperportionnate enough hit them till there ability to strike bback are dismall

  28. Barbara Ann says:

    There is one God you will see :)

  29. Barbara Ann says:

    There is one God you will see :)

  30. Gaza has Ben Palestinian since 2005. What are you talking about?

  31. what a crock Israel is only defending herself and I applaud B.Netanyahu for the love for his people. Wish we could say the same here.!!!!! Why dos the world not ask hamas to show restraint they are the murderers

  32. better a strong israel. a weak israel would be even more disrespected.

  33. better a strong israel. a weak israel would be even more disrespected.

  34. Victory does not equate guilt.

  35. Tom Harmon says:

    hit them HARDER!!!!

  36. Tom Harmon says:

    hit them HARDER!!!!

  37. Jane Folkard says:

    Don’t worry about world hatred Israel. You are the apple of Gods eye.

  38. ISIS just created an extremest caliphate Islamic State in Iraq. … let Hamas and any other extremist Palestinians move there.

  39. ISIS just created an extremest caliphate Islamic State in Iraq. … let Hamas and any other extremist Palestinians move there.

  40. ISIS just created an extremest caliphate Islamic State in Iraq. … let Hamas and any other extremist Palestinians move there.

  41. Wil Son says:

    Am yisrael chai (עם ישראל חי)

  42. Wil Son says:

    Am yisrael chai (עם ישראל חי)

  43. How asinine! But that is what the ragheads always say, going back to 1948.

  44. How asinine! But that is what the ragheads always say, going back to 1948.

  45. How asinine! But that is what the ragheads always say, going back to 1948.

  46. Why Nena says:

    hurrah Yisrael…God have mercy of the entire world

  47. Jane O'grady says:

    We support Israel! God bless and protect Israel.

  48. Disproportionate! What are they trying to say. Good on Israel for standing up to Hamas and terrorism. Israel in my opinion should go in 100% and rid the earth of this evil.

  49. Barry Gibson says:

    Israel has a right to defend.go israel

  50. Interesting the Jewish press allows all the hateful Arabs post here amazing

  51. Interesting the Jewish press allows all the hateful Arabs post here amazing

  52. Faye Tay says:

    Do what you have to do ISRAEL ! GOD”S HOLY LAND !

  53. Am yisrael chai!! HaShem is on our side, we cannot possibly lose!!

  54. Bull ****. They kill civilians…and they put their women and children up as shields. **** em

  55. Bull ****. They kill civilians…and they put their women and children up as shields. **** em

  56. Israel is not guilty or responding to attacks. Look at the chronology of events before you start with those irresponsible remarks.Shall they be quiet like those who suffered in countless countries, martyred because of their faith? They as a nation, as a people have every right to defend their way of life, their borders and even against those who threaten to “kill, steal and destroy!” Annihilate them because they’re Jews? What about the Christians, the Catholics, the irradical Muslims who want peace and believe in the culture of blessing? Israel never forced anyone to become a jew, so why should all believers in G_d, or Yeshua be condemned or intimidated just because your book says so? Allow us to exercise our freedom of religion even as you exercise your freedom of religion.

  57. Loren Gee says:

    First things first – there is no such thing as disproportionate attacks under international laws. They just don’t exist – this is an invention to attack Israel.

    Second it could not be disproportionate since the rockets are still falling. Proportionate would mean they used enough force to stop the war crimes. They have not done so – so more force is required.

  58. Go Israel go Yahweh is your strength blessing for Israel

  59. Go Israel go Yahweh is your strength blessing for Israel

  60. EGal Soaring says:

    Israel has every right to defend itself.

  61. the world is too stupid to understand the difference

  62. the world is too stupid to understand the difference

  63. Dewey Baines says:

    I don’t like self haters.

  64. Dewey Baines says:

    I don’t like self haters.

  65. Dewey Baines says:

    I don’t like self haters.

  66. I pray for Israel.

  67. I pray for Israel.

  68. I pray for Israel.

  69. they have done NOTHING WRONG”

  70. If Israel is “Disproportionate” Why Isn’t Israel Shooting Rockets Everywhere Into Gaza? That Would Be Proportionate!

  71. If Israel is “Disproportionate” Why Isn’t Israel Shooting Rockets Everywhere Into Gaza? That Would Be Proportionate!

  72. Shula Conley says:

    As an American Jew all I can say is go Israel! Take Gaza annex it as well as the West Bank.

  73. Peter Resz says:

    Lets see 1,000 missiles against what? If there is a disproportionate response it is that of Hamas.

  74. Berna Alis says:

    I don’t believe the whole world hates Isreal….and it should be stated that this is an opinion….I am thoroughly disgusted with Israel and Palestine equally….but I do not hate…..:-))

  75. Tzvi Ben -Gedalyahu, would you mind to leave Israel for Gaza? You can become a radical Muslim, Allah will take care of you.

  76. Tzvi Ben -Gedalyahu, would you mind to leave Israel for Gaza? You can become a radical Muslim, Allah will take care of you.

  77. A very true statement – “The only thing disproportionate is the world’s hatred of Israel!” !!

  78. A very true statement – “The only thing disproportionate is the world’s hatred of Israel!” !!

  79. Ali Shah says:

    After reading the comments of jews community i conclude there is no human in israel!!

  80. Tracy Graham says:

    Ignore the western media and do what you need to do to survive

  81. Tracy Graham says:

    Ignore the western media and do what you need to do to survive

  82. Tracy Graham says:

    Ignore the western media and do what you need to do to survive

  83. Beverly Bass says:

    No humans in Hamas, you mean…are you nuts? Hamas is killing its own people; Israel is warning ahead of time & still providing water 7 electricity…that’s not ‘human’? Maybe you should get educated instead of brainwashed in hatred.

  84. Beverly Bass says:

    No humans in Hamas, you mean…are you nuts? Hamas is killing its own people; Israel is warning ahead of time & still providing water 7 electricity…that’s not ‘human’? Maybe you should get educated instead of brainwashed in hatred.

  85. Beverly Bass says:

    No humans in Hamas, you mean…are you nuts? Hamas is killing its own people; Israel is warning ahead of time & still providing water 7 electricity…that’s not ‘human’? Maybe you should get educated instead of brainwashed in hatred.

  86. Beverly Bass says:

    Why are you disgusted with Israel? What about Hamas? A bit naive of you, to say the least.

  87. Beverly Bass says:

    Why are you disgusted with Israel? What about Hamas? A bit naive of you, to say the least.

  88. Beverly Bass says:

    Why are you disgusted with Israel? What about Hamas? A bit naive of you, to say the least.

  89. John Hanson says:

    Most of this planet is evil so stand your ground Israel, God is with you………

  90. John Hanson says:

    Most of this planet is evil so stand your ground Israel, God is with you………

  91. John Hanson says:

    Most of this planet is evil so stand your ground Israel, God is with you………

  92. Berna Alis says:

    I stand on my comment; people of any denomination who kill children are not of God…..it is not naive …it is the love of humanity ..we are all of God…Read my post on Timeline and you will find it to be yourself who is not only naive but truly ignorant of the commandments of God….

  93. Berna Alis says:

    I stand on my comment; people of any denomination who kill children are not of God…..it is not naive …it is the love of humanity ..we are all of God…Read my post on Timeline and you will find it to be yourself who is not only naive but truly ignorant of the commandments of God….

  94. Berna Alis says:

    I stand on my comment; people of any denomination who kill children are not of God…..it is not naive …it is the love of humanity ..we are all of God…Read my post on Timeline and you will find it to be yourself who is not only naive but truly ignorant of the commandments of God….

  95. Israel is Jewish land and has been for thousands of years before the Ottoman empire had arabs illegally moving into Israel. G-D bless Israel.

  96. Israel is Jewish land and has been for thousands of years before the Ottoman empire had arabs illegally moving into Israel. G-D bless Israel.

  97. Israel is Jewish land and has been for thousands of years before the Ottoman empire had arabs illegally moving into Israel. G-D bless Israel.

  98. Berna Alis says:

    Education is the magic word for you too Beverly Bass….you’re seriously lacking dear….

  99. Berna Alis says:

    Education is the magic word for you too Beverly Bass….you’re seriously lacking dear….

  100. Berna Alis says:

    Education is the magic word for you too Beverly Bass….you’re seriously lacking dear….

  101. Pete Dinglas says:

    No… this is more humane than any Western debacles for decades.

  102. So much hate in the world, so much hate in the Arab world. Have you no shame. You allow your children to be put in harms way for a terrorist organization. So you must hate your children as well!

  103. So much hate in the world, so much hate in the Arab world. Have you no shame. You allow your children to be put in harms way for a terrorist organization. So you must hate your children as well!

  104. God protect Israel,and peace be unto Israel the Nation of our Lord

  105. Tan Un Ping says:

    We love you Israel,be brave your G-ds chosen people. AM YISRAEL CHAI !!!

  106. Tan Un Ping says:

    We love you Israel,be brave your G-ds chosen people. AM YISRAEL CHAI !!!

  107. And Kenya too is for Israel, may God protect Israel and peace reign in Jerusalem the City of our Lord Jesus Christ

  108. Holy Nation of Israel by Almighthy God ‘s Will ! The Choseen Nation from all Nations !

  109. Holy Nation of Israel by Almighthy God ‘s Will ! The Choseen Nation from all Nations !

  110. Not enough do more flatten gaza

  111. Mu hammad may you be infesred by a thousand flees

  112. Which is good? Peace or war, Hamas elects war.lsrael must be proect her citizens from Hamas attacks. Please listen supporters of Hamas, there is no holy war. do not cheat your self. Oky

  113. Why aren’t Obama and United Nations calling for restraint when Hamas say they are going to drive Israel into sea. Is it because they know that it’s empty rhetoric because they can’t do it?

  114. Edinson Mota says:

    GO IDF .God bless Israel in name Jesus

  115. Edinson Mota says:

    GO IDF .God bless Israel in name Jesus

  116. They Appear to have the Intellect of my 12 year old Great Nephew! “That’s Not Fare!”

  117. worid hates u but God loves u

  118. Love you Israel!! God be with you!

  119. Agha Faizan it’s obvious you are only familiar with the history that you have been fed well 100 years ago there where a mass of immigration of arabs from all over arabia to Palestine because the jews came and started to work the land and build Palestine that before was empty of people only nomands bedouins where here and there,they came as there was work available where there was non in arab lands.Than they have been told by they mullah that must kill the jews according to Koran typical arab kill the hand that feeds you and they still doing it,they murdered jews in Palestine took over they possessions and paid and bought by jews land long before new legal Israel existed and they continue to do it, Mark Twain was here and he described Palestine exactly the way it was and still would be if not for jews.

  120. Carolin but than Israel would have to feed and support the lazy Palestinians in Gaza with large families as they ustu now living on aid.

  121. Muhammad ass you are and yours are not human and don’t behave like a human than you have nothing to say, as for dogs, well you can learn a lot of humanity from dogs, so dont compere.

  122. Ali Well ali you should know seeing you are not a human you self so you think everybody is like you??? hehehe

  123. Ruth Picking says:

    The apple of God’s eye

  124. Berna Alis as for education, what education? the one you are getting in the Mosque? yes the education you are getting is magic, it’s a fantasy a figment of yours mulla imagination, as for us we have the real education based on visual proof to what ha Beverly informed you it’s not our fault that you and mohammed and others still ride the magic carped hehehe..

  125. hehehe muhammad it’s a old song and boring have heard it for 65 years and so far Allah is on the Jewish side so who he loves after all, when you continue to suffer and Israel wins and get more land each time??? give up give peace a chance and that Allah will hear you.

  126. if someone comes to your door and says he wants to kill you, do you ask the police to send one officer or as many as possible?

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
IDF Chief Rabbi Rafi Peretz delivers lecture.
IDF Chief Rabbi: Nothing is Holy to Muslims on Temple Mount except Al Aqsa
Latest Indepth Stories
Greiff-112814-Levaya

My son is seventeen; he didn’t want to talk about what happened, or give any details of the Rosh Yeshiva’s words of chizuk.

Protesters in Ferguson, Missouri

All involved in the Ferguson debate should learn the laws pertinent to non-Jews: the Noahide Laws.

Charley Levine

Prominent Jewish leaders acknowledged that their predecessors had mistreated the Bergson Group.

Cravatts-Richard--new

Abbas has been adding new layers of rhetoric to his tactical campaign to de-Judaize Jerusalem

The Jew’s crime is his presence.

Hamas’s love for death tried to have as many Palestinian civilians killed as possible

Israel recognizes the fabrication called a Palestinian nation; So what do we want from the Swedes?

Arab attacking Jews in the land date back a century, long before Israel was created or in control.

Creativity without clarity is not sufficient for writing. I am eternally thankful to Hashem for his gift to me.

Golden presents a compelling saga of poor but determined immigrants who fled pogroms and harsh conditions in their homelands for a better life in a land of opportunity.

It seems to us that while the Jewish entitlement to the land of Israel transcends the Holocaust, the Jewish experience during that tragic time is the most solid of foundations for these “national rights.”

Too many self-styled civil rights activists seemed determined to force, by their relentless pressure, an indictment regardless of what an investigation might turn up.

Unfortunately, at present, the rabbinate does not play a positive role in preventing abuse.

Egypt’s al-Sisi is in an expansionist mood. He wants Israel’s permission to take over Judea and Samaria.

More Articles from Tzvi Ben-Gedalyahu
IDF Chief Rabbi Rafi Peretz delivers lecture.

“Ninety percent of them [Arabs] don’t know what is written in the Kuran.”

Soldiers start asking questions after Arab sniper narrowly misses killing Jewish motorist on Highway 60, south of Jerusalem.

“Lone wolves” trying to murder Jews are popping up too frequently.

Liberal Jews are for tolerance until they also have to be tolerant.

A pre-Thanksgiving speech for Americans. Obama, are you listening?

“You’ve been hacked by the Syrian Electronic Army.”

Murderers have upgraded their weapons from rocks and firebombs to guns.

Maybe he thought those white hoods are prayer shawls although they are closer to being burkas.

For every terrorist cell Israel announces it has captured, there are many more kept under wraps.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/breaking-news/israel-guilty-of-disproportionate-attacks/2014/07/14/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: