web analytics
September 30, 2014 / 6 Tishri, 5775
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post
Meir Panim with Soldiers 5774 Roundup: Year of Relief and Service for Israel’s Needy

Meir Panim implements programs that serve Israel’s neediest populations with respect and dignity. Meir Panim also coordinated care packages for families in the South during the Gaza War.



Misplaced Hysteria Over Israel’s ‘Land Appropriation’: No Appropriation Possible

Hysteria over 'land appropriation" by Israel made headlines around the world. But Israel did nothing of the sort.
Eugene Kontorovich

Legal scholar Eugene Kontorovich
Photo Credit: YouTube

In a very important article on Commentary’s online site, legal scholar Eugene Kontorovich takes on those who immediately began bloviating about Israel’s “land appropriation” or “land grab” when rumors spread that Israel was about to make some change in the status of a certain tract of land in the Gush Etzion region.

The United States and the United Nations, of course, both condemned Israel for “appropriating” the land, as did untold numbers of commentators, journalists and anti-Israel activists.

There were even some who place themselves on the pro-Israel side of the ledger who condemned the move. None of these critics bothered to determine whether Israel had done anything approaching what it was for which the Jewish state was being blasted.

As Kontorovich explains, what Israel did was declare specific open, uncultivated areas near what is known as the “Green Line” as state land. Doing so did not constitute an “appropriation” of land that belongs to Palestinian Arabs, and it would not result in an expansion of those dreaded Israeli “settlements.”

Why?

Because, as the legal scholar explains, Israel’s determination that the land in question is state land is simply a “factual, administrative finding that does not change the ownership of land.”

Much of the land in the  region southeast of Jerusalem has no private owners. Defining that land as state land requires the determination, “based on extensive investigation,” that the land does not have a private owner.

An “appropriation,” on the other hand, involves taking something that is someone else’s.

A determination that land is “state land” is a factual finding made by administrators and it does not change the ownership of land.

Perhaps even more importantly, “Israel’s designation of the land as state land can be challenged administratively and judicially, as Palestinian claimants often do, and sometimes prevail,” Kontorovich explains further.

In other words, nothing has been taken from anyone, or given to anyone. The “state land” determination does not create any new facts on the ground or change ownership. So back off Obama, Tzipi Livni, the New York Times and all the others who  jumped on the bandwagon without bothering to find out if what they were complaining about is true.

So, the next time you hear that Israel is “appropriating” “Palestinian land,” please check out the legal determination made and make sure you know what are the accurate terms for the action (if any) taking place.

About the Author: Lori Lowenthal Marcus is the US correspondent for The Jewish Press. She is a recovered lawyer who previously practiced First Amendment law and taught in Philadelphia-area graduate and law schools.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

14 Responses to “Misplaced Hysteria Over Israel’s ‘Land Appropriation’: No Appropriation Possible”

  1. hysteria is not the truth

  2. noone reallly cares isis is chopping heads hello! it isnt 1997

  3. Shaylee Rose says:

    Israel can’t appropriate any “palistinian land” because there is no palestine and G-d gave all that land to the Jews anyway. people are just idiots.

  4. By “world” you mean ****ing morons like Obama and Cameron

  5. Let Israel have Surya and Jordan for the sake of peace in Middle east.

  6. Let Israel have Surya and Jordan for the sake of peace in Middle east.

  7. UN Security Council Committee vote on draft (A/C.4/68/L.17).

    Extract: “Reaffirms that the Israeli settlements in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and in the occupied Syrian Golan are illegal and an obstacle to peace and economic and social development…”

  8. You don't think like a commoner:

    http://www.thinklikeacommoner.com/

    You don't understand what the commons is:

    http://wealthofthecommons.org/contents

  9. Chaiya Eitan says:

    Bookmark this in order to respond to Twitter/FB comments.

  10. Of course is Land of no body, cause you dont want Palestine be a country. ****ers.

  11. Walter Schnickaumsquable Schaff says:

    It was published that way by politicians to lend creadence to the Hamas owned Palistanian group to enforce the belief that because they defend themselves against Palistanian rockets they are evil and even steal land.
    .

  12. Siuyin Ho says:

    This land is not even 'state land' – rather, it is land belonging to the TRADITIONAL CUSTODIANSHIP OF ISRAEL! So, on these grounds – no appropriation by Israel is possible as it is just not logical that traditional owners could ever 'appropriate' land belonging to them. The side who is trying to say that Israel 'appropriated' the land is wrong just as much as the side who is trying to monopolize the situation with the equally falicious argument that the land is 'state land' is wrong.

  13. Ahsan Shariq says:

    Siuyin Ho According to your occupation, you are somehow related to or sympathize with the First Nations cause. I don't understand how you can take the side of an oppressor. If you're indeed sympathetic with the First Nations cause or have witnessed the trauma firsthand, you should know better than to side with colonialists who will stop at nothing to exploit the defenseless. At least the First Nations could put up an armed struggle!

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
Arab terrorists at the traffic circle in Ras al-Amoud May 2011
Breaking: Children Evacuated as Arabs Attack JM Neighborhood of Maaleh HaZeitim
Latest News Stories
Anti-Semites have a message for Jews in the Diaspora, but some people just don't understand it.

Jews are becoming as safe in France as they are in Iraq, Yemen and Syria.

Arab terrorists at the traffic circle in Ras al-Amoud May 2011

Children were rushed to bomb shelters in the Jerusalem neighborhood when Arabs began throwing explosives at the neighborhood and near the school.

Leonard Nimoy and Tar Trek's Jewish stars, William Shatner.

Volkswagen tries to cleanse its Nazi-linked past.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu headed for a much deserved lunch in Midtown Manhattan with Sheldon Adelson, at Fresco by Scotto, accompanied by 30 security guards. Bibi had the veal chop.

Rabbi David Kushner’s Ford Explorer was torched next to the Rodef Sholom Synagogue in Atlantic City on the first day of Rosh Hashanah.

How can Netanyahu say that Iran, which hangs innocents, is like ISIS, which beheads them?

More than two dozen Jews under heavy police escort moved into six more homes purchased by a Jewish investment company in Silwan Valley, including the City of David complex, in eastern Jerusalem Monday night. A group of Arabs hurled firecrackers and stones at police in a failed attempt to enter one of the buildings, and […]

ZIM may not call on the Port of Oakland again, certainly not until the ILWU 10 has a contract and guarantees to unload ZIM ships. Other shipping companies wary of the port’s unreliability may also consider the same.

Dozens of Jewish graves and gravestones on the Mount of Olives were desecrated during Rosh HaShanna.

An intruder actually made it to the East Room of the White House earlier this month, much farther than previously reported.

The following is the speech delivered by PM Netanyahu at the United Nations General Assembly on September 29, 2014:

The new Jewish Temple will offer millions of pilgrims underground parking, according to a new plan that just received the endorsement of hundreds of supporters who put their money where their faith is.

Subject to government approval, EL AL will place its “LY” code on select JetBlue flights to and from JFK and Newark, which will presumably expand the options for EL AL customers throughout the United States.

The Oklahoman called it a bizarre coincidence. On Friday, a second man was arrested for threatening to behead a coworker.

ISIS, Hamas, Hezbollah and Iran all share a fanatic ideology, Israeli PM Netanyahu warned the UN General Assembly on Monday. No freedom or tolerance.

More Articles from Lori Lowenthal Marcus
PLO executive committee member Saeb Erekat, pictured in Jerusalem on Dec. 30, 2010.

PLO member and PA spokesperson Saeb Erekat ridiculed state dept. spokesperson for Abbas criticism

John Kerry (L) with new Afghan President Ashraf Ghani (R) who took the oath of office on Sept. 29, 2014.

Suicide bombing reported as new president of Afghanistan sworn in.

Israeli car pelted with rocks as it traveled on the road near Tekoa.

Thousands of people protested outside of the Metropolitan Opera for staging an anti-Semitic opera.

ISIS urged all Muslims to kill all non-Muslims, and referred to Kerry as an ‘uncircumcised old Geezer.’

British Muslims launch social media campaign against ISIS, called #NotInMyName.

Canada will strip citizenship from those who travel abroad to join ISIS or other terrorist groups.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/breaking-news/misplaced-hysteria-over-israels-land-appropriation-no-appropriation-possible/2014/09/05/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: