web analytics
November 22, 2014 / 29 Heshvan, 5775
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post
IDC Herzliya Campus A Day on Campus

To mark IDC Herzliya’s 20th anniversary, we spent a day following Prof. Uriel Reichman, IDC’s founder and president, and Jonathan Davis, VP for External Relations, around its delightful campus.



Rabbi Efrati: Dead Druze Soldier, Halachically, Not our ‘Brother’


The funeral for Majdi Halabi in the town of Daliyat al-Karmel.

The funeral for Majdi Halabi in the town of Daliyat al-Karmel.
Photo Credit: Avishag Shaar-Yashuv/Flash90

During the Friday funeral for Druze IDF soldier Majdi Halabi, Rabbi Professor Daniel Hershkowitz called Majdi Halabi “our brother.”

On the popular National-Religious site Serugim, a halachic question was posed to Rabbi Baruch Efrati, Rabbi of the Zayit Raanan shul in the town of Efrat, regarding the use of the term “brother” in reference to a non-Jew.

Rabbi Efrati responded that the Druze and Circassians (both are minority ethnic groups living in Israel) have chosen to share their destiny with the state of Israel. In return, Israel owes them a covenant of blood, which we do not violate it. Israel must be committed to their safety and welfare.

But the question was formulated in halachic terms, as to whether or not Jewish law permitted referring to them specifically as brothers, and according to Rabbi Efrati, the gemorah in tractate Sotah (41:) takes exception to using the word “brother” when referring to a non-Jew. The gemorah brings the case of King Agripas, who shed tears when he read the verse prohibiting making a non-Jew king of Israel. The sages then cried out to him: You are our brother, about which Rabbi Nathan said it was the cause for their annihilation, as flattery was substituted for the law.

So it would seem preferable not to use that term about the late Majdi Halabi.

Rabbi Efrati then expanded on the answer and said that since the Druze and Circassians are monotheists living in Israel and loyal to Israel, they have the halachic status of ‘Ger Toshav,’ a monotheistic resident, which might then allow the use of the “brother” reference, but again he concludes, based on an opinion of the Maharal of Prague, that the use of “Brother” would still be inappropriate.

Rabbi Efrati nevertheless concludes that Majdi Halabi died a ‘Holy Martyr,’ since he was serving in the IDF when he died and can be counted among the ‘Righteous of the Nations,’ and he is included in the “Av Harachamim” prayer in synagogue, and God will surely avenge his death.

But, while we are obligated to treat them with love, peace and friendship, the designation of “Brother” is not halachically prescribed, as he is not a Jew.

About the Author: JewishPress.com brings you the latest in Jewish news from around the world. Stay up to date by following up on Facebook and Twitter. Do you have something noteworthy to report? Submit your news story to us here.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

7 Responses to “Rabbi Efrati: Dead Druze Soldier, Halachically, Not our ‘Brother’”

  1. Anonymous says:

    That's a terrible headline. Much as you probably don't like it, many people read only the headlines. And this line, "Dead Druze soldier not our "brother" " is going to bring out all sorts of negative reactions to Rabbis, to Jews, and to Israel. The article explains & makes it clear that the soldier(obm) is held in high esteem, but the headline implies the opposite.

  2. I agree with chavazl as I did just that, but decided to read the article and found it didn't say that at all and in fact honoured this soldier. I think this heading should be removed.

  3. JoAnn Morris says:

    I felt the same way and was upset by the heading. But I do not have a problem with calling all people "brother." G-d did not tell us to view others differently just because their beliefs are different from ours. Shalom my brothers.

  4. Charlie Hall says:

    I also was offended when I read the title…and then I read the article. The title implies that Rabbi Efrati does not appreciate the sacrifices made by non-Jewish citizens of Israel…and after reading the article, I realized that nothing could be further from the truth! The title REALLY needs to be changed.

  5. Toviah Moldwin says:

    There's a reason why Rabbi Natan in that story is a da'at yachid. Sometimes it's necessary (for PR purposes if nothing else) to be a little loose with the technical halacha and halachic terminology when the situation calls for it. The end of the story with Kamtza and Bar Kamtza, with Zecharya ben Avkulos, is a similar situation.

    I'm not saying that Rabbi Efrati did anything wrong, but with journalism being what it is these days, it pays to be very careful what you say in public forums. Unfortunately, some of us (including myself) have had to learn that lesson the hard way…

  6. Yossie Bloch says:

    The Torah scroll was handed to King Agrippa, who read it standing. The sages praised him for this. When he read (Deut. 17:15) “You may not put a foreigner over you as king,” his eyes ran with tears, but they said to him, “Don’t fear, Agrippa, you are our brother, you are our brother! (Mishna, Sota 7:8)

  7. Jeff Eyges says:

    This is the sort of question with which the bearded wonders choose to occupy themselves. A better one would be, "How do we rid our subculture of the sinat chinam that has come to characterize it so pervasively?"

    But that, of course, would require introspection.

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
Colleagues of the hanged Arab bus driver whose death continues to be referred to as murder despite autopsy finding of suicide. These are Arab drivers of Egged buses, claiming they suffer discrimination by Israelis.
Arab Pathologist Singing New Tune: Murder (By Jews) Not Suicide
Latest News Stories
Jonathan Pollard Protest in 2011

Bnei Akiva religious youth members joined forces with far left Meretz youth group members on July 4, 2011, to protest in front of the US Consulate in Israel, calling for the release of Jonathan Pollard. That was years ago, and as of today, Pollard has now spent 30 years in jail. Enough is enough.

Paul Goldenberg

The task force will aim at keeping Americans from joining ISIS and other radical Muslim murder gangs.

Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh (L) and Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan.

The cell that planned to kill Lieberman was only of several planning to kill PA official and Israelisץ

Colleagues of the hanged Arab bus driver whose death continues to be referred to as murder despite autopsy finding of suicide. These are Arab drivers of Egged buses, claiming they suffer discrimination by Israelis.

Arab pathologist who originally agreed with the findings of Arab bus driver’s autopsy showing suicide, now disagrees.

Secret Service officers arrested a woman with a gun while she was walking along the White House fence around 8:30 p.m. (EST) Thursday at the same time President Barack Obama was addressing the country on the issue of immigration. The woman was identified as April Lenhart, 23, from Michigan. She was wearing a holster and […]

And we can already hear Obama and Kerry telling him not to upset Allah and thank God on the Temple Mount.

The 388 bus line from BeerSheva to Arad was attacked by rock throwing Arabs near Arad.

The IDF foiled a plot by a Hamas terror cell to fire an RPG rocket at the vehicle of Foreign Minister MK Avigdor Lieberman.

Three Palestinian Authority terrorists linked with Hamas planned to murder Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman with a rocket-propelled grenade (RPG) attack on his vehicle near his eastern Gush Etzion home, the Israel Security Agency (Shin Bet) revealed Thursday night. It did not say exactly when it uncovered the plot but revealed that the assassination plan was […]

The Israel Law Center wins a landmark decision against the Palestinian Authority (PA) on behalf of 11 families of victims of terror.

Young Jewish women and a family come under attack from Arab elementary students hurling rocks in the Golan Heights.

Israel has agreed to cooperate with a UN board of inquiry appointed by Ban Ki-moon, probing UNRWA events in Gaza this summer.

A U.S. parole board has turned down a request for release by former Israeli agent Jonathan Pollard, now in his 30th year in prison.

Dmitri Diliani, a spokesperson for Fatah in Jerusalem and a member of the Fatah Revolutionary Council, had taken issue with Klein’s characterization of recent violence in Jerusalem as being instigated by the Palestinians.

Hundreds of Ethiopian Jews take part in a prayer of the Sigd holiday on the Armon Hanatziv Promenade overlooking Jerusalem on November 20, 2014. The prayer is performed by Ethiopian Jews every year to celebrate their community’s connection and commitment to Israel. About 80,000 Ethiopian Jews live in Israel, many of them came in massive […]

More Articles from Jewish Press News Briefs
Another gun-toting American walking next to the White House has been arrested.

Secret Service officers arrested a woman with a gun while she was walking along the White House fence around 8:30 p.m. (EST) Thursday at the same time President Barack Obama was addressing the country on the issue of immigration. The woman was identified as April Lenhart, 23, from Michigan. She was wearing a holster and […]

The 388 bus line from BeerSheva to Arad was attacked by rock throwing Arabs near Arad.

The IDF foiled a plot by a Hamas terror cell to fire an RPG rocket at the vehicle of Foreign Minister MK Avigdor Lieberman.

But perhaps the thought of racism will make Arabs speak out against murderers.

To clear up a misunderstanding, you cannot apply for your gun license on the plane and receive it with your Teudat Zehut when you land.

The army believes that the Gazans are testing their rockets in order to increase their rocket launching capabilities.

The state has decided it will not release the bodies of the two terrorists from the Har Nof Massacre.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/breaking-news/rabbi-efrati-dead-druze-soldier-not-our-brother/2012/10/14/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: