web analytics
March 31, 2015 / 11 Nisan, 5775
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post


Winnipeg Rabbis Split on Bill Favoring Gay-Straight Clubs

By: JTA

Two leading Orthodox rabbis in Winnipeg are split over part of a bill, proposed last December, which would require any school that receives provincial funding to allow students to create a gay-straight alliance club.

Fearing that Christian schools will be forced to accept such clubs, many Christian leaders in Manitoba have opposed the bill. But in the case of the province’s Jewish community, the two leading Orthodox rabbis have landed on opposite sides of the debate.

“The Torah rejects homosexuality,” Rabbi Avraham Altein, the longtime head of Chabad Lubavitch in Winnipeg, told the Canadian Jewish News. “Religious schools should not be forced to accept a gay rights group.”

But while Altein has written a letter to Manitoba Premier Greg Selinger protesting the bill and taken to the airwaves to make his views heard, Winnipeg’s other prominent Orthodox rabbi has taken a much different approach.

Rabbi Ari Ellis, who leads Winnipeg’s largest Orthodox congregation, told the news agency that he originally planned not to get involved in the debate on the bill until he heard Altein claiming that the bill stood in opposition to Orthodox Judaism.

“As an Orthodox rabbi and a Jewish educator, it is my belief that a gay-straight alliance could be a welcome institution in our schools and communities,” Ellis told the newspaper.

Gray Academy of Jewish Education, the only K-12 Jewish private school in Winnipeg, has had a gay-straight alliance for several years, according to head of school Rory Paul.

About the Author:


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

5 Responses to “Winnipeg Rabbis Split on Bill Favoring Gay-Straight Clubs”

  1. While an Orthodox Rabbi in Canada may have a valid Orthodox Jewish view from a.
    Halchic viewpoint, I think it is still a bad idea for them to adopt this in Manitoba.

    Certainly, these groups should be allowed in the public schools, and in any religious.
    school that accepts them. But for the Chabad School, and the Catholic and other.
    schools it becomes an imposition of religious matters.

    It is also true that Tax exemption is a major issue here also, but while well meaning, this type of legislation will probably have very negative unintended consequences.

    Not only religious institutions will be harmed, but also the fight for basic rights outside Canada, such as employment non discrimination is likely to suffer as this type of law will be held up as a reason not to extend any equal rights.

  2. Canada is not a society where religious freedom and liberty are sacred. America's placing G-d as the foundation of life is foreign to the Canadian/parliamentary system. Pirke Avot clearly tells us that undue intimacy with government is to be avoided, and for good reason. Oppressive regimes always attack religious freedom; Nazi Germany, Communist Russia, and Catholic and Czarist Europe, collectively, the worst anti-semitic regimes known to man, attacked religious liberty of Jews and those not in subservience to the state regime. The assault on religious Jews in "progressive" socialist regimes continues: crackdowns on circumcision and shechita in Scandinavia, Holland, and Germany, and no free speech/ criminalizing opposition to homosexuality and a lack of free speech in the UK, Canada, and other places is a sad reality.

  3. Canada is not a society where religious freedom and liberty are sacred. America's placing G-d as the foundation of life is foreign to the Canadian/parliamentary system. Pirke Avot clearly tells us that undue intimacy with government is to be avoided, and for good reason. Oppressive regimes always attack religious freedom; Nazi Germany, Communist Russia, and Catholic and Czarist Europe, collectively, the worst anti-semitic regimes known to man, attacked religious liberty of Jews and those not in subservience to the state regime. The assault on religious Jews in "progressive" socialist regimes continues: crackdowns on circumcision and shechita in Scandinavia, Holland, and Germany, and no free speech/ criminalizing opposition to homosexuality and a lack of free speech in the UK, Canada, and other places is a sad reality.

  4. Charlie Hall says:

    Wrong. Canada's Constitution protects religious freedom. And several provinces even provide government funding to religious schools.

  5. The constitution does, but efforts such as this show that there is inevitable conflict between what certain parochial groups deem appropriate for themselves and the social realities we'd like to see come to fruition. I think GSA's are useful; Haredim like the Habad rabbi here don't. Gov't financing of religious schools is only useful, IMHO, when religious schools fulfill that which is positive about public schools: the ability for the school to serve as a filter for securing public health concerns, and a means for advancing progressive values, which Haredi schools don't agree with (I saw an article which discussed how Satmar schools are fighting efforts to ensure children eat green vegetables as part of federal school-lunch funding, indicating that even public health concerns are amiss in Haredi schools. GSA's, to my mind, are important for public health, since they alleviate bullying, help reduce anxiety and depression, and create a healthier environment for all).

Comments are closed.

Current Top Story
Israel's favorite circus opens its 20th session Tuesday.
Knesset Opens the Tent to its 20th Circus
Latest News Stories
This is the photo of an Israeli Air Force attack plane shown with Fars New's Agency report that the IAF joined Saudi jest to bomb Yemen.

The Iranian regime is hard up for propaganda, but maybe it is prophesying the future.

Border Police officers arrest Arab rioter on Land Day riot at Damascus Gate in Jerusalem on Monday.

The Arabs rolled burning tires and three rocks at soldiers at the central Gaza security fence.

The Histadrut national labor union and the Federation of Israeli Employers have agreed to raise the minimum wage to 5,300 shekels ($1,334) by 2017, approximately half the average salary in Israel. The employers and the union previously agreed to a three-stage hike in the minimum wage. The latest agreement adds a fourth stage whole pegging […]

Israel's favorite circus opens its 20th session Tuesday.

The clowns are back in town while ringmaster Netanyahu tries to tame the beasts.

A Reuters poll shows that America is increasingly polarized, especially about President Obama.

Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu continued to lash out at a possible “bad deal” with Iran Monday and said, “The agreement being formulated in Lausanne sends a message that there is no price for aggression and on the contrary – that Iran’s aggression is to be rewarded.” Netanyahu said in a statement: The moderate and responsible […]

Release of a gag order reveals that the Israeli citizen and a friend traveled to Syria last year.

Lausanne has become the center stage of act that would put the world’s best novelist or Broadway producer to shame.

Inspections of Iranian nuclear sites won’t uncover possible nuclear activity in North Korea, or even China.

Colel Chabad and IFCJ have made sure thousands of Israelis will celebrate Passover with good food this year.

Former Secy of State Hillary Clinton says she wants to see US-Israeli relations on a “constructive footing” and Israel negotiating with the PA.

A rocket launched from Gaza landed in the Sinai, in the Egyptian half of the town of Rafiach (Rafah).

Rami Levi’s operating and net profit suffered from a 12% increase in the costs of selling, marketing, general and administrative expenses.

Matzah baking isn’t all just hard work. Sometimes it can be fun too.

Today on the Hebrew calendar is the 10th of Nisan – the day the People of Israel crossed into their new Land.

Former Prime Minister Ehud Olmert found guilty of fraud and breach of trust in a retrial in the ‘Talansky Affair.’

More Articles from JTA

More than 20 cars and buildings in a Jewish community in north London were vandalized with swastikas. The Nazi symbol was drawn on approximately 27 cars in the Osbaldeston Road area of Stoke Newington on Sunday night, The Daily Mail reported. An unnamed 32-year-old man was arrested in connection with the vandalism Tuesday. The neighborhood […]

New York State Assemblyman Dov Hikind called on the Jewish community to attend the funeral of an assassinated New York police officer. “The brave men and women of the NYPD risk their lives every day to protect us. We value them and stand with them,” Hikind, a Democrat who represents Brooklyn, said in a statement […]

“Move Jew” scrawled on a Philadelphia home and slurs written on a synagogue and 10 garages in Chicago.

The Nazis nearly destroyed the 17th synagogue.

Cuba has “the largest pool of untapped baseball talent in the world, and Major League Baseball may tap and leave Cuba dry.

Argentina’s president Christina Fernandez has accepted an official Jewish godson for the first time in the country’s history to help counter legend of death to a seventh son. She described in seven tweets her meeting with her new godson, Yair Tawil, a member of a Chabad-Lubavitch family. He was adopted as a godson under a […]

A fundraising campaign started quietly by two first graders two years ago to help find a cure for a rare genetic disease just passed the $1 million mark.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/breaking-news/winnipeg-rabbis-split-on-bill-favoring-gay-straight-clubs/2013/04/18/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: