web analytics
April 26, 2015 / 7 Iyar, 5775
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post


High Court: Obeying the Law Not Enough to Establish Jewish Ownership in Judea and Samaria


Retired Chief Justice Dorit Beinisch continues to preside over her unfisnished cases

Retired Chief Justice Dorit Beinisch continues to preside over her unfisnished cases
Photo Credit: Miriam Alster/Flash90

The Israeli High Court of Justice ruled late Tuesday night that a Jewish inhabitant of a tract of land near the community of Kedumim in Samaria can no longer use the existing legal framework as the basis for his ownership of the land.

The High Court accepted the petition brought by three Palestinians – which was filed by Yesh Din (an anti-settlement non-profit organization) and later joined by the State Prosecutor’s Office, stating that Michael Lesens must evacuate the tract within a month, and ordering the Civil Administration of Judea and Samaria to oversee and enforce his eviction. Lesens was also ordered to pay the Palestinians NIS 20,000 in compensation.

The petitioners claimed that Lesens planted crops, installed an irrigation system, and fenced in the tract against the orders of the Civil Administration. Lesens, for his part, cited Section 20 of the Ottoman Land Law to argue that because he and others had cultivated the land for more than 10 years, the statute of limitations had expired, and claims against his assumption of ownership could no longer be asserted.

But the bench – comprised of Supreme Court President Dorit Beinisch (who, though retired, continues to preside over cases that were initiated prior to her retirement), Edna Arbel, and Miriam Naor – stated that Lesens had not proven to the court that he had cultivated the land for over 10 years, and even if he had, he would still be required to demonstrate that he had “honestly taken” possession of the land in question.

It is precisely this part of the decision that has left-wing organizations cheering and nationalists fuming – as the court appeared to set a new precedent by creating an additional evidentiary hurdle to asserting ownership, and -in effect- mandating that one could no longer obtain ownership of land in Judea and Samaria under the prevailing law.

Aside from its demonstrable departure from the current law on the books, the new court-ordered requirement is somewhat dubious, as it will likely be difficult for Jews claiming ownership to provide proof that they acquired the land using honest means; especially considering the subjective nature of the requirement and the often-hostile relations between Jews and Palestinians in Judea and Samaria.

The practical ramification of the ruling is that it will allow the Civil Administration to order the eviction and evacuation of Jewish inhabitants from hundreds of thousands of dunams in Judea and Samaria.

Parliamentary Adviser to National Union MK Jacob Katz “Katzele” Jeremy Man Saltan told the Jewish Press that many nationalist MKs are concerned that “the Supreme Court is trying to change the meaning of the Ottoman Law itself (the old Ottoman Empire law from which the Israeli legal system has evolved), instead of asking the Israeli legislator to pass its own version.”

“The law is very clear,” Saltan added, “and people are really shocked that the Supreme Court has gone from changing Israeli laws that don’t meet their standards as they relate to Basic Laws, to changing the Ottoman laws outright.”

About the Author: Solomon Burke is a regular contributor to JewishPress.com


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

No Responses to “High Court: Obeying the Law Not Enough to Establish Jewish Ownership in Judea and Samaria”

Comments are closed.

Current Top Story
Car - A-Tor
Updated: Three Injured in Jerusalem Terror Attack, Ambulances and Mayor’s Car also Attacked
Latest News Stories

Several Israelis suffered minor injuries in Saturday’s devastating earthquake in Nepal that killed approximately 1,500 people, but approximately 250 Israelis are not accounted for, according to the Foreign Ministry. Communications systems have been disabled by the earthquake, which measured 7.9 on the Richter scale and is the latest in a series of disasters that have […]

Naftali Bennett and Prime Minister Netanyahu.

Bayit Yehudi settles for three Cabinet posts. Shas to head Religious Affairs with Bayit Yehudi as Deputy.

Traffic to Maaleh Adumim

The road from Jerusalem to Ma’aleh Adumim is closed to traffic due to Arab stone-throwing.

The officer of a Hareidi IDF unit was in Mea Shearim to visit two of his soldiers whose families have social or financial problems.

A soldier was stabbed, and a second soldier was nearly stabbed in separate attacks on Shabbat.

Three police have been injured in Jerusalem after a car ran into them. The three were walking on the sidewalk when the car slammed into them. The vehicular attack happened on the “Cohen’s Path” near Beit Orot on the Mount of Olives. One is moderately injured with pelvic injuries, and the other two are lightly […]

The airstrip, 10 miles from the Syrian border, could be used for UAV missions against Syrian rebels. Israel also is in range.

Vying for dominance in the WZO election, are movements within our nation which seek to undermine and subvert Orthodox Judaism.

Shira Klein was seriously injured in the April 15th Jerusalem terror attack that killed Shalom Yochai Sherki.

Arab media said several bases with long-range missiles were attacked on Saturday and last Wednesday.

Israel is the 11th happiest nation among 156 countries in the annual World Happiness Report for a second year. USA ranks 15.

New York’s MTA plans to vote on a change to its rules it hopes would allow it to exclude the “Killing Jews” anti-jihad ad campaign.

Biden gleefully announced two of his three Catholic children married Jews – not thrilling his Jewish audience.

In Jerusalem, the bells from 18 churches in the Old City of Jerusalem rang 100 times on Thursday evening, April 23, to remember the Armenian Genocide.

The IDF has come up with an 81-second video showing 67 years of Israeli land, sea and ground soldiers in action.

More Articles from Solomon Burke
Cell phone

The Israel Defense Forces on Sunday began a week-long drill of a text-message warning system that sends alerts to cellphones about imminent missile attacks in particular areas. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu: “All of the threats that are currently being directed against the Israeli home front pale against a particular threat, different in scope, different in substance, and therefore I reiterate that Iran cannot be allowed to have nuclear weapons.”

Egyptian demonstrators protesting at the Israeli embassy in Cairo, 15 May 2011.

The Islamic movement to which newly-elected Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi belongs, released a statement on Monday claiming the Sinai border attack that left 16 Egyptian security officers dead “could be attributed to the Mossad,” according to Egyptian daily Al-Masry Al-Youm.

Egypt deploys helicopter gunships to the Sinai peninsula after President Mohamed Mursi directed the military to take “complete control” of the Sinai. Israel Defense Minister Ehud barak: “I hope that this will be a wakeup call for Egypt regarding the necessity to be sharp and efficient on their side.”

The ad states: “In any war between the civilized man and the savage, support the civilized man. Support Israel. Defeat Jihad.” The MTA refused to run it.

The wall will be fronted with 60 white cross “that symbolize the 60 million little baby boys and girls have been murdered since 1973 in America alone.”

In a briefing before the Knesset’s Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, Maj.-Gen. Aviv Kochavi said that the election of the Muslim Brotherhood’s Mohamed Morsi as President of Egypt has brought political Islam to the forefront of politics in the Arab world, but predicted that the Egyptian military would continue to serve as a strong restraint. As a result, he doubted that Egypt would be allowed to drift into Iran’s orbit.

Baseless Hatred: What It Is and What You Can Do About It, a new book by Dr. Rene Levy, tackles a problem that has plagued the Jewish people from very early on in their history; the destructive aspects of which have been responsible for some of their greatest historical calamities and continue to threaten the unity of the Jewish people today.

Caterpillar issued a stinging rebuke of the accusations, and it was revealed that the Palestinian Authority recently bought Caterpillar equipment.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/israel/high-court-conformance-with-existing-law-not-enough-to-establish-jewish-ownership-of-land-in-judea-and-samaria/2012/03/22/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: