web analytics
April 1, 2015 / 12 Nisan, 5775
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post


Israeli Media: 2 US Jewish Groups Attack Yaalon’s Comments; True?

How did Haaretz and YNet both quote a month-old press release criticizing Ya'alon's comments made last week?
Minister of Defense Moshe Yaalon (R) with U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry in Jerusalem.

Minister of Defense Moshe Yaalon (R) with U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry in Jerusalem.
Photo Credit: Matty Stern/US Embassy/Flash90

Two American Jewish groups closely associated with the Democratic party’s positions allegedly issued scathing statements about Israel’s Minister of Defense Moshe Ya’alon’s comments critical of U.S. foreign policy, delivered at Tel Aviv University last week.

But did those groups issue those statements? Or did the Israeli media simply claim they did, and everyone left it at that?

The two groups that were reported by both Haaretz and YNet as condemning Ya’alon, are the National Jewish Democratic Council and the Israel Policy Forum. That those two groups would attack an Israeli leader for having criticized this U.S. administration is hardly surprising.

The NJDC, after all, is the Jewish wing of the Democratic party, just as the Republican Jewish Coalition is for the Republican party. And the Israel Policy Forum is widely regarded as the “old man’s J Street,” or as one of the precursors to the current young-ish bucks who seek to dislodge mainstream American Jews from what people of that bent consider the grips of the American Israel Public Affairs Council.

So when articles in Thursday’s Haaretz and YNet contained extensive quotes from the two U.S. administration-leaning Jewish groups slamming Ya’alon for comments he made at a Tel Aviv University address last week, few were surprised.

At that address, Ya’alon said the U.S. has shown “weakness” in various arenas around the world, and that its Middle East allies are disappointed. He also reiterated a prior statement, that Israel would have to go it alone against Iran and cannot depend on the U.S. to lead on that front.

ISRAEL POLICY FORUM PRESS RELEASE QUOTED IS A MONTH OLD

The articles in the two Israeli media allegedly quoting the American Jewish groups are very similar. Both include the same quotes from the Israel Policy Forum. The quotes include:

• “The Israeli Policy Forum, a pro-peace group, said in a statement that it “condemns recent statements by Ya’alon that insulted the Obama administration and harshly criticized American foreign policy in the Middle East and around the world.”

•”Ya’alon is compromising US-Israeli relations. His obstructionist outbursts simply support a view that Israel is not negotiating in good faith and better serves its critics and those opposed to a lasting peace.”

Both also included this statement, including the double negative:

•”We believe that Ya’alon’s criticisms of President Obama’s diplomatic efforts with Iran were unwarranted and not unconstructive [sic]. His statements demonstrate a pattern of behavior which is not appropriate for the proper conduct of Israel’s diplomacy.”

To those statements, YNet added that the IPF  “condemns recent statements by Ya’alon that insulted the Obama administration and harshly criticized American foreign policy in the Middle East and around the world,” and “IPF welcomes Minister Ya’alon’s late apology and sincerely hopes he will return to the important process of negotiating an agreement with the Palestinians that will insure Israel’s future as a secure and Jewish democratic state.”

The problem is, all of this language is from a press release issued by the IPF on Feb. 21, and was not in response to Ya’alon’s latest comments. Oddly, the two articles quoting the earlier press releases appear on the IPF website in the “IPF in the News” section. The IPF’s latest press release, according to its website, is from March 12, and is about another matter entirely. So the IPF site contains the misquotes of its own press releases in the section bragging about how it is quoted in the media.

All of this is not to say that the IPF has changed directions and applauds Ya’alon’s frank assessments of America’s foreign policy. But doubling the number of Jewish American groups which criticized Ya’alon’s (from one to two) remarks is worth noting. Except there is also a problem with the quotes from the other American Jewish group.

NATIONAL JEWISH DEMOCRATIC COUNCIL’S STATEMENT NOT ON ITS SITE

The other American Jewish group which was reported to have blasted Ya’alon for his remarks this week is one that is explicitly aligned with the Democratic party, the National Jewish Democratic Council.

The head of that group, Rabbi Jack Moline, according to Haaretz, said that Ya’alon “crossed a line with these absurd and over-the-top attacks against Israel’s strongest ally. His remarks are simply inappropriate for someone of Ya’alon’s stature, and we condemn these counterproductive and damaging statements.”

The NJDC statement also allegedly rejects “any intimation that there is a lack of support from the United States or President Obama. Despite his tepid apology, we expect better from Ya’alon in the future.”

Oddly, this “statement” does not appear on the NJDC website section which contains the group’s NJDC press releases. Not only that, but there is no evidence that Rabbi Moline made the quoted statements anywhere other than in the YNet and Haaretz articles, or sites quoting or reproducing those two articles.

Yet Haaretz re-cycled the month-old IPF press release and the otherwise invisible NJDC statement as evidence of the “extent of Americans rage with Ya’alon” as shown by “unusual public statements made by two Jewish groups with close ties to the Obama administration who blasted the Israeli defense minister.”

UNNAMED SENIOR OFFICIAL QUOTED

There is still another similarity between the Haaretz and YNet articles. Each mention statements made Wednesday night from an unnamed “senior administration official.”

According to Haaretz, the senior official said Ya’alon had not offered a sufficient apology for his “offensive and highly disappointing comments, which do not reflect the depth of our security cooperation and the enduring relationship between the United States and Israel.”

YNet quoted an unnamed senior official as having said Wednesday night, that Ya’alon is “determined to undermine US-Israel relations.”

It is possible an NJDC statement will turn up that contains the exact language quoted by both Haaretz and YNet. But there really is no good explanation for using quotes condemning Ya’alon’s comments last week, from a press release issued a month ago.

About the Author: Lori Lowenthal Marcus is the US correspondent for The Jewish Press. She is a recovered lawyer who previously practiced First Amendment law and taught in Philadelphia-area graduate and law schools. You can reach her by email: Lori@JewishPressOnline.com


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

26 Responses to “Israeli Media: 2 US Jewish Groups Attack Yaalon’s Comments; True?”

  1. Kenneth Blum says:

    Clearly a coordinated smear campaign.

  2. John DeLancy says:

    I know our media has “issues”, but I’m sad to see Israel’s does also.

  3. Ya’alon and Gantz speak the truth, so these so called Jewish groups should sit down and shut up for once!

  4. This Jewish groups ARE CRAZY !…..

  5. Anonymous says:

    These miserable entities worked overtime to put a pro-Muslim Brotherhood, socialist, anti-constitution party in the White House, Shameful. Now they want to censor Israel legitimate disappointment in the America the democrats are destroying. These are deranged assimilated, un-jews who have no right to breathe in Israel's direction, let alone speak under the banner of 'Jewish' organization. Shameful.

  6. the truth is above diplomacy, well said Ya’alom!

  7. the truth is above diplomacy, well said Ya’alom!

  8. Jean Perles says:

    THERE IS ONLY ONE JERUSALEM = THE CAPITAL OF THE JEWS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! GO TO HELL ABBAS YOU AND YOUR ENTIRE PALESTINIAN AUTHORITY !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! AMEN !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  9. HE TOLD THE TRUTH. Obama is weak. The U.S. has become the laughing stock of the world. RABBI DR. BERNHARD ROSENBERG

  10. Paul Weiss says:

    Ya’alon was right- he is a hero and a man of honor.

  11. Paul Weiss says:

    Ya’alon was right- he is a hero and a man of honor.

  12. Why is it wrong to tell the truth

  13. We need to attack the Jewish groups who attacks Yaalon. Enough is enough.

  14. יעלון תיתנצל כבר דביל!!!

  15. בן אדם שלא שולט ב-פה שלו איזה מכה כמה אפס אתה יכול להיות.

  16. Anonymous says:

    Interesting how the same kinds of people who regularly deplore the "bullying of the Jewish Lobby" don't seem concerned with publicly doing their own bullying. When did freedom of speech die for them?

  17. These are the same type of Jews who led fellow Jews to the gas chambers and who fed their lifeless bodies afterwards to the furnaces~
    And….They will answer for this, and those other betrayals they have assigned themselves to…

  18. Judy Shapiro says:

    These 2 entities are ANTI a strong and secure ISRAEL and safety for the JEWISH people. They are the miserable self-loathing descendants of Delano's (FDR) Court JEWs and people like rabbi stephen wise. The only one who spoke out was Morganthau while the others were mute as 6 million JEWISH innocents, including 1.5 million children, were savagely murdered and burned to death. They are more pro SON-OF-ISLAM obama and the Democrat party. In fact the former director of NJDC, one ira forman, is on obama's payroll currently as 'liasson' to the JEWs. They do NOT prioritize ISRAEL or JEWISH continuity.

  19. AS A FORMER DEMOCRAT I WISH OUR FELLOW JEWISH DEMOCRATS WILL WAKE UP AND SMELL THE COFFEE!!! IT IS A SHAMEFUL THING FOR ANY JEW TO BE ALLIED WITH A PRESIDENT WHO IS ANTI-SEMITIC AND ANTI-ISRAEL. AS I'VE SAID FOR A LONG TIME, IF YASIR ARAFAT WERE RUNNING FOR OFFICE IN THE U.S. IN THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY THE AMERICAN JEWISH DEMOCRATS WOULD VOTE FOR HIM.

  20. Leon Chattah says:

    Most disgracefully true! Jewish leadership has for a long time been coop red by extreme liberal political stances consistently critical of Israel and supportive of Antisemitic positions of the Democratic Party.

  21. Carlos Font says:

    All comments are very interesting, especially the one by Judy Shapiro.I'm old enough to remember Mr. Morgenthau. It seems to me that a lot of these "peace-at-any cost" people have one thing in common, "cowardice". We had them during the Revolutionary War and VietNam. They ran up to Canada. Keep it up, Mr Ya'alon!

  22. Anonymous says:

    Kerry can make pejorative comments about Israel. He can threaten Israel with a European boycott, however, Boogie is not allowed to speak the truth.

  23. Please Lord,protect Your children from the judgement they are bringing on our Nation.I J N,Amen

  24. I have always been suprized that any American Jew can be a member of the Democratic Party. Are they anti-Semite?

Comments are closed.

Current Top Story
Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi.
Obama Stops Punishing Egypt for Dumping Muslim Brotherhood Prez
Latest News Stories
Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi.

Obama finally stops punishing Egypt for overthrowing the Muslim Brotherhood’s Morsi

Hezbollah  terror group shows off its arsenal in Lebanon.

The IDF will have hard choices to make in the next war with Hezbollah.

Chaim Topol as Tevye the Milkman

Chaim Topol, has been awarded the Israel Prize for lifetime achievement.

20th Knesset Opening Session

The Knesset opening session was buzzing with new faces, as 39 new Members of Knesset joined their veteran colleagues in the swearing in ceremony.

The Temple Institute renacted the entire Pesach sacrifice ceremony.

“On days like today we want these children to feel the joy that any normal child experiences on their bar mitzvah.”

A family. 7 Children. An indescribable tragedy. How do they go on? How do we react? And what lessons are we supposed to learn?

More than 40 refugees were killed in a Saudi-led air strike while PA office accuses Israel crime by building homes.

The military implicitly admits to having improperly allowed a missionary group to indoctrinate soldiers.

Talks are likely to extend beyond Obama’s self-imposed deadline that he had said he won’t change.

The Iranian regime is hard up for propaganda, but maybe it is prophesying the future.

The Arabs rolled burning tires and three rocks at soldiers at the central Gaza security fence.

The Histadrut national labor union and the Federation of Israeli Employers have agreed to raise the minimum wage to 5,300 shekels ($1,334) by 2017, approximately half the average salary in Israel. The employers and the union previously agreed to a three-stage hike in the minimum wage. The latest agreement adds a fourth stage whole pegging […]

The clowns are back in town while ringmaster Netanyahu tries to tame the beasts.

A Reuters poll shows that America is increasingly polarized, especially about President Obama.

Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu continued to lash out at a possible “bad deal” with Iran Monday and said, “The agreement being formulated in Lausanne sends a message that there is no price for aggression and on the contrary – that Iran’s aggression is to be rewarded.” Netanyahu said in a statement: The moderate and responsible […]

More Articles from Lori Lowenthal Marcus
Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi.

Obama finally stops punishing Egypt for overthrowing the Muslim Brotherhood’s Morsi

Iran's Deputy Foreign Minister Abbas Araqchi

Iran suddenly refuses to transfer its already enriched uranium, despite prior agreement.

Congress is ‘fed up’ with being left in the dark on the Iran negotiations

Saudi Arabia began airstrikes on neighboring Yemen which has been taken over by Iranian-backed Houthi rebels.

Obama says Bibi has to prove he supports a “two-state solution.”

Obama’s Chief of Staff chides Netanyahu at the J Street Conference for refusing to embrace fantasy as reality.

A Cruz presidency as antidote to Obama: repeal Obamacare, dismantle the IRS, strong support for Israel.

The anti-Bibi campaign’s quiet change in tax status both came too late and constitutes an admission of wrongdoing.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/israeli-media-2-us-jewish-groups-attack-yaalons-comments-true/2014/03/23/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: