web analytics
July 22, 2014 / 24 Tammuz, 5774
Israel at War: Operation Protective Edge
 
 
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post
IDC Advocacy Room IDC Fights War on Another Front

Student Union opens ‘hasbara’ room in effort to fill public diplomacy vacuum.



JCPA: ‘We’re The Voice of American Jews,’ But Many Beg to Differ

The JCPA went to congress urging the U.S. to restart the "peace talks." It also claims to be the the representative voice of the organized Jewish community. Both ideas are wrong-headed according to many who spoke with The Jewish Press.
JCPA.jpg

As we conclude the somber observance of Tish B’Av, the time when so many tragedies that have befallen the Jewish people are recalled, it is perhaps not irrelevant that U.S. secretary of state John Kerry has returned to the Middle East.

Official reports claim Kerry has no plans to visit Israel, but, as Tzvi Ben Gedalyahu reported in The Jewish Press, Kerry met with Palestinian Authority leader Mahmoud Abbas while in Jordan.  It turns out he is also meeting with various Arab leaders who, according to al Jazeera, Kerry believes “are essential to his push to get Israelis and Palestinians to resume peace talks.”  That’s right.  Arab leaders to push – who? Who else, but Israel, to restart the “peace talks.”

Yes, although the entire Middle East is in turmoil, Egypt has just gone through a second revolution, nearly a100,000 have died in Syria’s ongoing civil war, one into which Lebanon is increasingly being drawn, Turkey is nearing the boiling point, Iraq continues to unravel and Iran is approaching nuclear weapons capability, leave it to a group of professional Jewish professionals to sashay into D.C. and tell the relevant congressional committees that now is the time for Kerry to kickstart the Arab-Israeli “peace talks.”  And that’s what happened, just before Kerry left for the Middle East.

The Jewish group making the possibly worst-timed suggestion ever is the Jewish Council for Public Affairs (JCPA).

According to its website, the JCPA has a tripartite mission: first, “to safeguard the rights of Jews here and around the world”; second, “to dedicate ourselves to the safety and security of the state of Israel”; and third, “to protect, preserve and promote a just American society, one that is democratic and pluralistic, one that furthers harmonious interreligious, inter ethnic [sic] interracial and other intergroup relations.”

From their mission, you might think that the safety and security of Jews and the Jewish state would be the primary focus of JCPA’s activities.  But you might be wrong, as a quick look at their website makes clear.  The JCPA’s focus is on liberal domestic issues. Israel and Judaism play a minor role.

JCPA CLAIMS TO REPRESENT THE ORGANIZED JEWISH COMMUNITY

Nonetheless, the JCPA can prioritize as it wishes and make whatever suggestions it wants to members of congress.  But when the JCPA leaps over its goal to be something and starts proclaiming it is something, that is when people begin to bristle.

You see, on the JCPA Facebook page, and on its Twitter homepage, it states, with no qualifiers, that “the JCPA is the representative voice of the organized Jewish community.”

That’s news to a whole lot of American Jews who shared their response with The Jewish Press.

Because when the JCPA decided to meet with the House and the Senate foreign relations committees, asserting that the American Jewish community wants Kerry to focus on restarting the peace talks, that claim may have been heard as if it had far more weight than warranted.

Let’s put aside for the moment that when the JCPA went to congress to make its claims, it was double-dating with the American Task Force on Palestine.  That’s something they do a lot.  Again, whatever JCPA does is its own business.

But The Jewish Press asked a broad geographical cross-section of American Jews who are knowledgeable about the Middle East in general and Israel in particular, whether, as the JCPA asserts, it is the “representative voice of the organized Jewish community,” and if it spoke representing them when it went to congress urging the restart of the “peace talks” at this time.

In a word, no.

People in California, Chicago, Florida, Washington, D.C., and New York were asked to comment.  Rabbis, architects, businesspeople, financial wizards, intelligence analysts, and Jewish communal leaders were asked to comment.  They all said no, the JCPA does not represent them.

“They don’t represent me,” said Jeff Ballabon, the president of a New York consulting firm and the founder of the Coordinating Council on Jerusalem, a consortium of two dozen national pro-Israel groups.

“Israel has stated very clearly: there are to be no preconditions for starting the peace talks, so I have to wonder, why are these groups putting pressure on Israel?  I don’t see how any American Jew who cares about Israel’s safety and security would be pushing this now,” Ballabon said.

About the Author: Lori Lowenthal Marcus is the US correspondent for The Jewish Press. She is a recovered lawyer who previously practiced First Amendment law and taught in Philadelphia-area graduate and law schools.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

Please use the Facebook Tab below to leave your comment:

13 Responses to “JCPA: ‘We’re The Voice of American Jews,’ But Many Beg to Differ”

  1. Stuart Kaufman says:

    These bastards' status as Jewish leaders is both self-proclaimed and Imaginary.

  2. Ch Hoffman says:

    claiming to speak for all the Jews of America seems to be a common theme among ideologues from all points on the political and religious spectrum.

    it may even have occurred once or twice in a certain reactionary right-wing religious paper from Brooklyn.

  3. Alex Langer says:

    They claim to represent the ORGANIZED Jewish Community, not individuals and certainly not every Jew. There's a big difference.

  4. Alan Kardon says:

    Please explain what is the "ORGANIZED JEWISH COMMUNITY"?

  5. Martha Gore says:

    Another organization that represents themselves, not most American Jews.

  6. Alan Kardon says:

    I went to their website and wrote a note to explain what is the organized Jewish Community. Awaiting their reply.

  7. Tim Upham says:

    It is both tragic and sickening, that I support the two-state solution. But I have had so many American Jews call me an "Anti-Semitic Muslim Nazi" for doing do. Nazism was militarily defeated, but neither Israel nor the Arabs will be.

  8. William T. Langley says:

    JCPA is nothing more than a bunch of Libtards who IN NO WAY SHAPE OR FORM speak for American Jews!

  9. Alex Langer says:

    The JCPA is an umbrella organization representing consensus positions drawn from local community relations councils (i.e. JCRC's and CRC's).

  10. Anonymous says:

    JCPA does speak for a segment of the Jewish community, those with a 16th century ghetto mentality, who live on their knees and survive on the kindness of gentiles. Israel was resettled in contradiction to that mentality. No wonder the craven Jews are lukewarm in support of it and favor sacrificing its rights to curry favor with the anti-Semites.

  11. Cody Flecker says:

    Nazism was hardly defeated militarily. The organized Nazi militias are alive and well. Just ask Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson for their views on "Hymie Town Jews and Israel" These two Nazis would love to see Israel defeated and extinguished once and for all.

  12. Tim Upham says:

    Cody Flecker I have never seen either Al Sharpton or Jesse Jackson goose stepping in leather boots, and saluting a picture of Hitler. Jesse Jackson apologized for his inappropriate "Hymie Town" remark, and has spoken out strongly against Holocaust denial.

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Loading Facebook Comments ...
Loading Disqus Comments ...
Current Top Story
Military funeral in Israel
IDF Names Missing Soldier As Sgt. Oron Shaul
Latest News Stories

Six IDF soldiers wounded in Gaza have showed significant improvement at Soroka Hospital in Beer Sheva, Israel Radio reported. Three soldiers have been downgraded from “serious” condition to “moderate,” and three additional soldiers are now listed as “lightly injured.” One hundred fourteen soldiers are currently hospitalised as the result of the fighting.

Israeli docs operate on patients. Not quite the same 'operations' at Gaza hospital

Leading US paper interviews Hamas leader, shocked to ‘discover’ interview takes place in civilian hospital.

IDF officials brief Prime Minister Netanyahu on July 9, 2014. The prime minister visited wounded IDF soldiers Tuesau

PM meets wounded soldiers at Ashkelon hospital, tells foreign diplomats they have moral obligation to support Israel.

As of this writing, Code Red rocket alerts were sounded in the following locations Tuesday: 16:00 Bnei Shimon, Merhavim 15:59  Beer Sheva, Hatzerim, Nevatim, Segev Shalom 15;41  Shaar Hanegev, Yad Mordechai, Netiv Ha’asarah 15:30 Gaza Belt region 14:00 Zikim,Carmiya 13:51  Nahal Oz, Alumim 12:28 Ramat Hanegev 11:05 Ashdod, Nitzanim,local settlements 9:33 Shaar Hanegev 9:11 Shaar Hanegev, Ashdod, local settlements   […]

Ashkelon Mayor Itamar Shimoni said Tuesday that the funeral of Jordan Ben-Simon, a lone IDF soldier killed in Gaza yesterday, would be limited to 300 attendees due to the threat of rocket attacks.  Following the outpouring of support for lone soldiers yesterday, when more than 20,000 people created a mass funeral for lone soldier Sean Carmeli, […]

Teenage member of MK Zoabi’s clan making name for self as pre-eminent Arab supporter of Israel.

Army finally forced to admit soldier is missing; efforts continue to identify seventh body from Sunday night attack.

Israel activists take the streets of New York on Sunday. For some reason, no rocks or Molotov cocktails were thrown at police.

Israel needs an ally in talks over a premature cease fire with Hamas terrorists intent on wiping out the Jewish State.

IDF soldier Shiloh Hadad is the lone survivor of the Golani 13, fierce Israeli warriors who saved two kibbutzim from a massacre on Monday.

One soldier’s body is MIA, as IDF names remaining Golani soldiers killed in Shejaiya

The IDF is determined to destroy as many tunnels as possible, eliminating this imminent threat to the citizens of Israel. 23 terror tunnels have been uncovered by IDF forces since July 17th.

IDF operations move forward as more tunnels and rockets are found and destroyed…

Turkey is attempting to be seen as the protectorate for the Palestinian Arabs.

Members of congress should experience Israelis’ lives. Bomb Shelter Museum will be in D.C. July 22.

More Articles from Lori Lowenthal Marcus
Turkey's Prime Minister Erdogan

Turkey is attempting to be seen as the protectorate for the Palestinian Arabs.

Artists 4 Israel have created a mobile Bomb Shelter Museum.

Members of congress should experience Israelis’ lives. Bomb Shelter Museum will be in D.C. July 22.

Protesters became violent in several anti-Israel/pro-terror rallies in Europe over the weekend.

Not an altogether terrible day for Israel at the UN, given there were no riots or demands that Israel surrender unilaterally.

CNN reporter believes she was justified in referring to Sderot Israelis as “scum.”

CNN journalist refers to some Israelis as “scum,” then deletes tweet.

Musicians scheduled to perform in Israel have begun to cancel their dates due to the violence.

The US State Department press briefings often end up being ‘Palestinian’ advocacy sessions.

    Latest Poll

    Israel's Iron Dome Anti-Missile System:





    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/jcpa-were-the-voice-of-american-jews-many-beg-to-differ/2013/07/17/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: