web analytics
November 24, 2014 / 2 Kislev, 5775
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post
IDC Herzliya Campus A Day on Campus

To mark IDC Herzliya’s 20th anniversary, we spent a day following Prof. Uriel Reichman, IDC’s founder and president, and Jonathan Davis, VP for External Relations, around its delightful campus.



JCPA: ‘We’re The Voice of American Jews,’ But Many Beg to Differ

The JCPA went to congress urging the U.S. to restart the "peace talks." It also claims to be the the representative voice of the organized Jewish community. Both ideas are wrong-headed according to many who spoke with The Jewish Press.
JCPA.jpg

Carol Greenwald, treasurer of Citizens Opposed to Propaganda Masquerading as Art, a pro-Israel voice in the Washington, D.C. area, told The Jewish Press that “the JCPA’s claim is a sham.  They don’t represent the Jewish community, they are a bunch of self-appointed leftists.”

“Win-win? Nah, it’s they take, we give,” Greenwald said, responding to a claim by JCPA’s spokesperson Ben Suarato, that The JCPA and ATFP were “making the case together and trying to represent the win-win aspect of negotiations.”

How about over in California?

Vic Rosenthal is the treasurer of the Jewish Federation of Central California. His response to the JCPA’s claim, he told The Jewish Press: “I don’t know how they can call themselves ‘the representative voice of the organized American Jewish community.’ They certainly didn’t ask me, or any of the other board members of our local Federation. Many of us feel strongly that forcing Israel to sit down with the PLO, which doesn’t have the ability to deliver peace even if it wanted to, at a time of maximum instability in the region, is worse than a waste of time — it’s dangerous.

And Doris Wise Montrose lives in Los Angeles, where she heads the seven year old, 30,000 strong organization, Children of Jewish Holocaust Survivors, was emphatic: “The JCPA most definitely does not represent me or my organization. The JCPA represents only those Jewish organizations whose leaders cling to the politically correct delusion that Israel will achieve ‘peace through appeasement’ with enemies who have vowed to destroy it.  The position of the JCPA and other like-minded organizations only serve to weaken Israel and put the lives of Israeli citizens in danger.”

In an email from a Chicago suburb, Peggy Shapiro, the Mid-West coordinator for StandWithUs, also rejected the idea that the JCPA represents her views.  She wanted to know: “Why are some obsessed with believing that a recalcitrant Palestinian Authority and the terror-government Hamas will suddenly find peace with Israel a viable option?  Neither government has given evidence to support such a belief. Yet the JCPA is making another push to push the U.S. to push Israel into another round of talks.”

Shapiro also pointed out that the Middle East beyond Israel is roiling with violence.

“Who focus on Israel and the Palestinians at this moment in history?  Egypt is on fire, Syrians are being slaughtered in the thousands, Jordan is shaky, and Lebanon is run by Iran’s terror proxies – Hezbollah.  It is delusional to think that peace with Israel is the key and that once (if only) the Palestinians and Israelis arrive at an agreement, the Sunnis and Shias will kiss and make up and all the Muslim world will be at peace?

“I understand the JCPA’s desire for peace. I share it. Yet anyone who believes such wishful thinking is denying some harsh realities on the ground,” Shapiro concluded.

David Steinmann is a New Yorker who scoffed at the JCPA’s claim.

“JCPA neither represents me or, as far as I know, any meaningful proportion of the organized American Jewish community.  They may well represent American Jews who are neither knowledgeable about these matters or blind to the extreme dangers to Israel which the current two-state proposal entails,” Steinman explained, and then went on to articulate some of the dangers in the proposals the JCPA was urging the U.S. government to push:

the proposed two-state solution would simply  follow in a long line of Israeli concessions which have provided not a single reciprocal gesture from the Palestinians who have instead, continuously increased their demands on Israel in order to even begin to speak about speaking. And, finally, but by no means less important, the proposed Palestinian state would put all of Israel’s major population centers in the center of Palestinian bulls-eyes. Planes landing at Ben Gurion airport, for example, could be shot down with little difficulty from land now proposed as a part of a Palestinian state.

The danger of the plan at the basis of the “peace talks” the JCPA is pushing was used by many respondents to explain how out of touch the JCPA is with any but like-minded peace process pushers, and therefore is not a legitimate representative voice of American Jewry.

About the Author: Lori Lowenthal Marcus is the US correspondent for The Jewish Press. She is a recovered lawyer who previously practiced First Amendment law and taught in Philadelphia-area graduate and law schools.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

13 Responses to “JCPA: ‘We’re The Voice of American Jews,’ But Many Beg to Differ”

  1. Stuart Kaufman says:

    These bastards' status as Jewish leaders is both self-proclaimed and Imaginary.

  2. Ch Hoffman says:

    claiming to speak for all the Jews of America seems to be a common theme among ideologues from all points on the political and religious spectrum.

    it may even have occurred once or twice in a certain reactionary right-wing religious paper from Brooklyn.

  3. Alex Langer says:

    They claim to represent the ORGANIZED Jewish Community, not individuals and certainly not every Jew. There's a big difference.

  4. Alan Kardon says:

    Please explain what is the "ORGANIZED JEWISH COMMUNITY"?

  5. Martha Gore says:

    Another organization that represents themselves, not most American Jews.

  6. Alan Kardon says:

    I went to their website and wrote a note to explain what is the organized Jewish Community. Awaiting their reply.

  7. Tim Upham says:

    It is both tragic and sickening, that I support the two-state solution. But I have had so many American Jews call me an "Anti-Semitic Muslim Nazi" for doing do. Nazism was militarily defeated, but neither Israel nor the Arabs will be.

  8. William T. Langley says:

    JCPA is nothing more than a bunch of Libtards who IN NO WAY SHAPE OR FORM speak for American Jews!

  9. Alex Langer says:

    The JCPA is an umbrella organization representing consensus positions drawn from local community relations councils (i.e. JCRC's and CRC's).

  10. Anonymous says:

    JCPA does speak for a segment of the Jewish community, those with a 16th century ghetto mentality, who live on their knees and survive on the kindness of gentiles. Israel was resettled in contradiction to that mentality. No wonder the craven Jews are lukewarm in support of it and favor sacrificing its rights to curry favor with the anti-Semites.

  11. Cody Flecker says:

    Nazism was hardly defeated militarily. The organized Nazi militias are alive and well. Just ask Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson for their views on "Hymie Town Jews and Israel" These two Nazis would love to see Israel defeated and extinguished once and for all.

  12. Tim Upham says:

    Cody Flecker I have never seen either Al Sharpton or Jesse Jackson goose stepping in leather boots, and saluting a picture of Hitler. Jesse Jackson apologized for his inappropriate "Hymie Town" remark, and has spoken out strongly against Holocaust denial.

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
France Jew in a French synagogue talks about rising anti-Semitism.
Israel to Ease Absorption, Employment for Immigrants from France
Latest News Stories
Israeli police shoot tear gas to disperse Arab rioters throwing rocks in Isawiya, October 2014. (archive)

Security leaders re-activate a special unit in Israel as Arab rioters injure four police officers in Jerusalem.

Rabbi David Lau visits Temple Mount activist and assassination target Rabbi Yehuda Glick at Shaarei Tzedek Hospital.

The doctors completed their surgery and accomplished what they set out to repair.

France Jew in a French synagogue talks about rising anti-Semitism.

Israel’s cabinet decides to clear obstacles for employment of immigrating professionals.

Iman in Har Nof

Sheikh Samir Aasi says “I Was Attacked Because Of What I Stand For. These Extremists Don’t Want Relations Between Religions”

Former Washington DC Mayor Marion Barry died early Sunday at age 78.

A Tennessee watchdog group says textbooks in the state’s schools are teaching children to hate Israel and Jews.

In New Zealand a Jewish toddler wearing a yarmulka is attacked; the adults consider teaching their young to hide their identity.

If there were such a thing as “diplomatic police,” Abbas would have been arrested long ago for crossing red lines.

Both the town and the tower were destroyed in a violent fashion. A layer of ash shows they were burnt.

Son of Isaac Bashevis Singer, Israeli author Israel Zalman, dead at 85.

They were harmless men simply looking for “song birds.” Uh-huh.

US law states anyone who “Incited terrorist activity with intent to cause serious bodily harm or death” should be barred from entry.

The police knew the PA Arabs were sleeping in the cemetery, they just couldn’t figure out where…

The US is so used to believing lies that it can hardly distinguish them from the truth.

One of the most effective weapons of an enemy is to destroy the opponent’s economy, and Jews are cooperating.

More Articles from Lori Lowenthal Marcus
Israel Zamir, author and son of Isaac Bashevis Singer, is dead at 85.

Son of Isaac Bashevis Singer, Israeli author Israel Zalman, dead at 85.

US Secretary of State John Kerry with German Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier before P5+1 talks. Nov. 22, 2014.

Is the West about to provide Iran with a major concession in order to reach an “historic” (but empty) deal?

Arab pathologist who originally agreed with the findings of Arab bus driver’s autopsy showing suicide, now disagrees.

US can’t understand why the UAE is calling terrorist groups terrorist groups.

The NYPD has increased security for NYC synagogues in the wake of the Har Nof massacre.

Israel’s UN Ambassador called on entire UNSC to confront the reality of the Palestinian Arab barbarity.

U.S. Amb. to Israel Dan Shapiro harshly condemned the terrorist attack at the synagogue in Har Nof.

EU leaks latest noxious bag of dirty tricks to inflict on Israeli politicians and sovereignty

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/jcpa-were-the-voice-of-american-jews-many-beg-to-differ/2013/07/17/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: