web analytics
July 28, 2015 / 12 Av, 5775
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post


Kerry Names Oslo-Defender Indyk to Direct Peace Talks

Every US “peace process” mediator has failed. Martin Indyk is next in line. He has said Israel must cede the Temple Mount and the PA must give up the “right of return.” If he succeeds, expect war.
Former U.S. ambassador to Israel Martin Indyk

Martin Indyk, former U.S. ambassador to Israel an ex-Obama Middle East envoy.
Photo Credit: Miriam Alster / Flash 90

U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry, after a week of denials, is naming former U.S. Ambassador to Israel Martin Indyk to direct and maneuver the direct talks between the Palestinian Authority and Israel, whose negotiator are meeting officially Monday night for the first time in three years.

American officials, leaked the expected appointment on the basis of anonymity, one more carefully orchestrated step in a process that has been manipulated with “white lies” to make sure that the talk will resume.

Indyk’s qualifications are similar to those of every other American Middle East “expert” who has failed to force the Palestinian Authority and Israel to accept the American dream of a peace agreement.

Indyk, who thinks the Oslo Accords were the best thing since Abraham Lincoln went to a play, played a major part in the 2000 Camp David peace talks that fell apart.

As Bill Clinton’s Ambassador to Israel, he openly embraced Palestinian Authority demands, such as Israel’s ceding the Temple Mount, The only major Arab demand he rejected was the idea of flooding Israel with 5 million foreign Arabs whom the United Nations has decided belong in Israel.

Abbas once admitted that the demand is ridiculous, but enthused by years of Israel’s “goodwill” capitulation and the international apathy towards the PA’s refusal to live up to its own commitments, he has made the wrongly-termed “right of return” an absolute requirement. If and when he wins everything else from Israel, including  the Temple Mount, a PA army and almost all of Judea and Samaria, he can win the Nobel peace Prize by making the “grand concession” of giving up the “flood Israel with Arabs’ tactic.

Indyk, born in Britain and educated in Australia, said in an Israeli newspaper interview nearly two years ago that the Oslo Accords were good for the Palestinian Authority and Israel. He did not mention the post-Oslo period, in which thousands of Israelis were and still are killed and wounded by PA terrorists.

Of course, he also has praised the Palestinian Authority for reducing terror, without crediting the “Apartheid Wall, an apt description when realizing that the security fence really does create Apartheid between normal human beings and suicide terrorists.

Indyk also wrote in his 2009 book “Innocent Abroad, “It was not reasonable to expect that Arafat, or any Arab leader for that matter, would agree to an end-of-conflict agreement that left sovereignty over the Haram al-Sharif [the Temple Mount] in Israeli hands forever.”

So it is clear that  that Indyk is negotiating for chairman Mahmoud Abbas on that issue.

He wrote in The New York Times in 2010, “Does President Abbas, already a weakened figure, have the courage to defend the necessary concessions to his people, particularly when it comes to conceding the ‘right of return’ to Israel? Does Prime Minister Netanyahu have the determination to withdraw from at least 95 percent of the West Bank and to accept a Palestinian capital in Arab East Jerusalem? “

Besides his insistence that the failure of Oslo are less important than the fact the Yasser Arafat and Yitzchak Rabin signed them, Indyk’s record on the Middle East is graced with viewpoints that, like those of his predecessors, have proven to be dead wrong.

He played a major part in the 2000 Camp David peace talks that fell apart.

Indyk also wrote in another op-ed in The New York Times in 2010, “Today, nothing could better help Obama to isolate Iran than for Netanyahu to offer to cede the Golan, as four other Israeli prime ministers have, in exchange for peace with Syria, which serves as the conduit for Tehran’s troublemaking in the Arab-Israeli arena.”

If Netanyahu had followed Indyk’s advice, it is questionable whether Israel would exist today, and, of course that is exactly what most Arab countries see as the key to peace in the Middle East. If Netanyahu had followed his wisdom, it is just as likely that the United States would be at war with Iran today.

Indyk also was 100 percent wrong when he said in 2009 that Salaam Fayyad was “the only game in town” as prime minister of the Palestinian Authority. Fayyad vowed to build up PA institutions so they could support state. Fayyad now is out of the picture, partly because Abbas and his Fatah henchmen could not stomach Fayyad’s attempts to overcome the institutionalized corruption, the very stuff that precludes the idea of a stable nation.

One black mark against Indyk from the Palestinian Authority side is that he is Jewish.

Indyk wrote in his book, “The fact that I had begun my Washington career eleven years earlier working at the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC, often referred to as ‘the Israel lobby’)  only reinforced the image in much of the Arab world and among pro-Arab Americans that Clinton’s policy had been taken over by a Jewish cabal.

“Behind that stereotyping lay the reality that our Jewish identities generated a deep desire in all of us to make peace since we all believed that Israel’s security depended  on ending the conflict with its Arab neighbors and that American interests would be well served by doing so.”

Indyk forgot to mention that he is a director of the left-wing New Israel Fund, which does everything it can to dilute the Jewish identity in Israel  and promotes getting Jews out of Judea and Samaria.

The trap for Indyk , and Kerry, and for Israeli negotiator Tzipi Livni, and for everyone else involved in the “process’ is that their personal need to succeed makes it a foregone conclusion that Israel is going to have to concede on everything except the forced immigration of foreign Arabs. He wrote in his book that he feels a “personal responsibility” for the failures of the peace process.

In order to reach their goal, U.S. mediators look at the facts with blinders and pre-conceived notions, such as defending Oslo.

The Zionist Organization of American noted last week, after it was clear that Indyk would take over the direct talks, that in 2007, he told a Congressional sub-committee that Abbas “has met all of the requirements, including removing, once he became president, ending the incitement of Israel in the Palestinian media and beginning the process of dealing with the demonization of Israel in Palestinian curricula. “

The ZOA added, “Unfortunately, Indyk’s claims were — and remain to this day —  at variance with the reality of continuing demonization of Israel in the PA media, mosques, schools and youth camps. Only the month before making these false, laudatory statements about Abbas, Abbas told a Fatah rally that, ‘We have a legitimate right to direct our guns against Israeli occupation … Our rifles, all our rifles, are directed against The Occupation.’ “Moreover, since making those remarks, Abbas has publicly lauded Jew-killing terrorists like the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine’s George Habash and Hamas’ Shekih Ahmed Yassin; personally sheltered wanted terrorists in his Ramallah presidential compound, including Khaled Shawish, wanted by Israel for the murder of 19 Israelis; and personally congratulated the ghoulish terrorist Samir Kuntar upon his release by Israel, for which Abbas’ Fatah also  organized celebrations.”

About the Author: Tzvi Ben Gedalyahu is a graduate in journalism and economics from The George Washington University. He has worked as a cub reporter in rural Virginia and as senior copy editor for major Canadian metropolitan dailies. Tzvi wrote for Arutz Sheva for several years before joining the Jewish Press.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

9 Responses to “Kerry Names Oslo-Defender Indyk to Direct Peace Talks”

  1. Benjamin Fox says:

    Is there any common sense left in the world? Maybe left wasn't a good word at this time?

  2. Anonymous says:

    Let's all pray to Hashem to save us from the plots of our enemies just as He saved us from Bilaam the rasha and many other Israel and Jew haters.

  3. iNDYK in yiddish is a TURKEY an appropriate description of Martin. A good friend of the Palestinians and self doubter of the Jews.

  4. I was doing some thinking the other day about this whole Palestinian – Israel situation and I think I came up with a simple but effective plan. When the Prime Minister or whoever from Israel shows up for "peace talks," they should have a legal, binding, document prepared, handing over Israel to the Palestinians. What is great about this idea is everyone will be happy with it. The Obama administration gets to advance his pro Arab agenda. The Palestinians will finally have a place to call their own, and Netanyahu, Peres, and others will have the opportunity to bask in the glory of public opinion, that's what is most important to them. Then we can finally stop having these endless "peace talks." Also, there will be no need to discuss a two state solution because there will be only one state left. As a bonus, I would not stop at releasing one hundred and four Palestinian terrorists, why not go for broke and release them all. The Israeli government can provide them with weapons and strategy to kill as many Israelis as they can before the Palestinians take over. If Israel is so intent on killing themselves, my plan will do the job. Now that I am thinking about it, why wait, they could start releasing every terrorist now. It will take time for the Israeli government to properly equip them with the weapons, strategy, and financial backing. This way the terrorists can get started. There is no need to travel all the way to Washington, they could do it right where they are and set up a deadline for the Palestinians to take over. I don't know why I didn't think of this sooner.

  5. Odette Jones says:

    Kerry needs a Bible . Then he would know he has got it completely wrong . Pathetic man . To think he can stop the plans of the LORD . Shalom Brother

  6. 5 million arabs being flooded into Israel is a revelation to me, which shows I was not following the peace talks closely enough at the time – as stated Israel would no longer be in existence. I understand L. Kauderer's comment only too well, Israel stop selling yourself down the river. Disagree, freeze these pointless talks, in my opinion Israel's is better off going to war, knocking 60,000 rockets targeted on Southern Israel, as a gesture to the people of Israel, every terrorist no matter how long imprisoned be executed, since this is the law – death penalty for treason against Israel and her people. All these acts of terrorism were carried out on Israeli soil therefore Israeli law should have prevailed and to hell with the so called palestinians. They are aping the ancient right of the Judaic peoples to return to their homeland. AL AQSA is NOT respected by arabs it is just another excuse for putting up the middle finger to Israel. Obama is not President of Israel or PM. Obama and the US are simply protecting their OIL imports the fg arabs know it and are using the west to destroy Israel. War is the only solution to this crisis with arabs, OIL and the US.

  7. I hope BN is shrewder than his opponents, there has to be a loop hole, pray he finds it. I'm here in Europe fuming at not only the drip Ashton in Egypt who absolutely do not want the MB running the show. Iran and Saudi are equally controlling the US it is damn OIL again. Take out the oil fields as Saddam did back in the '90's, his first target Kuwait, and of course the US came running how could she keep her electorate quiet if they couldn't run their gaz guzzling cars, there'd be a civil war in the States.

  8. Anonymous says:

    Without a Jewish Temple on Moriah there can be no deal. Ezekiel records the blueprint of that Temple and it will be next to the Dome of the rock…

  9. Franc Baneli says:

    G-D judges us for trying to divide His land and people. There are alot of Notzrim here in the US sickened by our meddling over the last 30 years. We pray for your peace and safety. G-D will show his strength through his Son at the 11th hour.

Comments are closed.

Current Top Story
Rocks hurled by rioting Arabs on the Temple Mount.
MK Ahmed Tibi Tells Police to Expel Jews from Temple Mount
Latest News Stories
Young Israelis enjoy a picnic at the Armon HaNatziv Promenade overlooking  the city of Jerusalem. (archive)

Local Israel Police have arrested seven Jerusalem Arabs in connection with recent attacks on Jews.

Rocks hurled by rioting Arabs on the Temple Mount.

Half of all Israeli Arab MKs ascended the Temple Mount to protest “police brutality,” expelling Jews along the way.

Muslim man speaking with a group of women at the Dome of the Rock mosque on the Temple Mount.

Temple Mount activist Rabbi Yehuda Glick strongly condemns Tuesday’s visit by Israeli Arab MKs to the ancient site.

The picture speaks for itself.

The police acted out of “zero tolerance.” Arabs screaming “slaughter Jews” were not arrested.

The Secretary is visiting Egypt, but stopping off in Israel would only give ammunition to Congressmen opposing the nuclear deal with Iran.

The remand of three other suspects has been extended and the Attorney General’s office announced that it would file an indictment against two of them.

Both civilian and military assistance is being delayed, and Hamas is having a tough time dealing with it.

Rumsfeld tweeted on Monday: “Releasing spy Jonathan Pollard doesn’t make the #IranDeal any less of a disaster for Israel & the free world.”

High Court ordered the “illegal” building to be torn down. Bayit Yehudi MK threatens to tear down coalition government.

Aliyah is up 11% compared to 2014; More than 20,000 French Jews have arrived in Israel over the past five years.

The Russians and the Syrians also discussed cooperation with Chinese companies to increase oil and gas digging in Syrian fields which are safe from rebel attacks.

The purpose of the expedition is to bring Jewish traditions to Jews who are far from the culture.

A Magen David Adom ambulance was attacked Monday night as it traveled in the Hebron Hills.

French far-right politician Jean-Marie Le Pen has been indicted over his remarks about gas chambers.

US Pres. Obama exults, “I am the first Kenyan-American to become president of the US.”

More Articles from Tzvi Ben-Gedalyahu
The picture speaks for itself.

The police acted out of “zero tolerance.” Arabs screaming “slaughter Jews” were not arrested.

death to america

The Secretary is visiting Egypt, but stopping off in Israel would only give ammunition to Congressmen opposing the nuclear deal with Iran.

High Court ordered the “illegal” building to be torn down. Bayit Yehudi MK threatens to tear down coalition government.

Israel’s giant generic firm will withdraw its troublesome bid for Mylan.

Acting Health Minister Yaakov Litzman says it will be supervised like any other drug that is considered a narcotic.

Jackie Mason now is at least the second Jew backing Trump, but in 2011 he called him a “professional liar” and a “sick man.”

A new Arab claim on Susiya is based on an alleged 1881 document and claiming “we were here first.”

President Obama has not responded to the tweets.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/kerry-to-name-oslo-defender-indyk-to-direct-peace-talks/2013/07/29/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: