web analytics
April 19, 2014 / 19 Nisan, 5774
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post
Spa 1.2 Combining Modern Living in Traditional Jerusalem

A unique and prestigious residential project in now being built in Mekor Haim Street in Jerusalem.



MK Who Excluded Reform Jews from Judaism Was ‘Misunderstood’

An Israel Knesset Member got a whack on his tongue for angering the Diaspora.
An orthodox Jewish man argues with a reform Jewish woman wearing a prayer shawl at the Kotel.

An orthodox Jewish man argues with a reform Jewish woman wearing a prayer shawl at the Kotel.
Photo Credit: Nati Shohat/Flash90

Share Button

Reform Jews really are not another religion after all, says Likuid-Beiteinu Knesset Member David Rotem, who claimed on Thursday that his reported remark to the contrary was “misunderstood.

There is no video available to see and hear what MK Rotem, an Orthodox Jew, really said at the Knesset Constitution, Law and Justice Committee that he heads.

He was quoted on Wednesday as having stated, ““The Reform movement is not Jewish … they are another religion,” during a discussion on a bill concerning adoption.

Such comments are par for the course in Israel, where the remark was duly noted as another moment of entertainment for the Israel public between soccer games. The Reform Movement in Israel, of course, was furious, but most secular Israelis have too much respect for Jewish tradition than to consider the Reform idea anything more than a curiosity, if not one of those strange concoctions that could succeed only in the United States and , lest we forget, pre-Nazi Germany.

“I have never said belonging to the Reform Movement makes anyone less Jewish,” Rotem wrote on Facebook Thursday. “While as an Orthodox Jew, I have theological differences with the Reform Movement’s perspective, I maintain the greatest respect for all Jews, regardless of their denomination and background. I apologize for any misunderstanding and all offense generated by the content of my comments yesterday.”

His quick apology was smart, much smarter than his faux pas. Many if not most  Reform Jews indeed are Jews by any definition of the term. But a disturbing number of Reform Jews are far from Jewish under Jewish law, and some of them are even “rabbis.”

The whole question of whether a Reform Jew, or any other person, is  a Jew or not brings into focus the entire problem with the reform Movement, parts of whose theology often appear to be not a stream of Judaism but a stream apart from Judaism.

Like the Biblical Korach, it has decided that their leaders whom they call rabbis can decide just as well as Orthodox Jews who is a Jew and what is Jewish law. It is somewhat like a natural health therapist calling himself a doctor. Why study medicine for six years, and why study Torah for many more years,” when you can take a shortcut through McDonald’s, eat a cheeseburger on the way to Yom Kippur prayers, and call the congregants Jewish because they like being called that?

Regardless of the theological problems with Reform Judaism, Rotem made a big mistake by saying that fellow Jews belong to another religion just because they are Reform.

“I hope that this clarification can generate the necessary debate on how to further unify the Jewish People, both in Israel and the Diaspora, around our shared vital interests and concerns, rather than limiting it to the differences that exist among us,” Rotem added on Facebook.

Israeli politicians like Rotem who are Israeli from top to bottom have no knowledge of the Diaspora. They don’t realize that Jews outside the country, especially in the United States, may be armchair Zionists  if not armchair Jews, but that doesn’t mean they should be shunned as “non-Jews.

The Anti-Defamation League (ADL) called Rotem’s comments, although he later said they were misunderstood, “inappropriate, offensive and unjustified.”

Abraham H. Foxman, ADL National Director, wrote MK Rotem, “We are deeply disturbed by reports of comments attributed to you about the Reform movement ‘not being Jewish.’ Such views are inappropriate, offensive and unjustified. The suggestion that Jews throughout the world who identify with the Reform movement are somehow not a part of the Jewish people is an unacceptable characterization of a proud, highly engaged and committed group of Jews.

“Among many U.S. non-Orthodox Jews, rejectionist rhetoric of this kind fosters divisiveness and feelings of alienation towards elements of Israeli society. As someone who has long been engaged in the issue of Jewish identify, we are surprised and saddened that you expressed these views. For the sake of Jewish unity and in the spirit of the pluralistic ideals of our beloved Israel, we call on you to retract your comments and issue a quick and unequivocal apology for your statements.”

Rotem has apologized, and whether he actually said what was reported makes no difference. The damage was done on two fronts.

He wrongly wrote tens of thousands of Jews out of the pale and he also missed an opportunity to characterize the Reform Movement as one whose roots in the United States are strongly pro-American and blatantly anti-Zionist and which claims an increasingly larger following by redefining the term “Jew.”

Share Button

About the Author: Tzvi Ben Gedalyahu is a graduate in journalism and economics from The George Washington University. He has worked as a cub reporter in rural Virginia and as senior copy editor for major Canadian metropolitan dailies. Tzvi wrote for Arutz Sheva for several years before joining the Jewish Press.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

Leave a comment (Select your commenting platform)

11 Responses to “MK Who Excluded Reform Jews from Judaism Was ‘Misunderstood’”

  1. David Blatt says:

    Clearly Reichsfuhrer Himmler would have divested of Mr. Rotem of his ridiculous assessment that Reform Jews aren’t really Jewish.

  2. Alan Kardon says:

    I am a Reformed Jew. I did not know I have to report to Knesset Member David Rotem. Who died and made him the supreme authority?

  3. Apology accepted. Do not discount brothers and sisters whose soul is Jewish. Orthodox will not accept us if we cannot prove our lineage. This is wrong and divisive as stated in the above article. For those Haredi who think they are too grand to lay down their lives for Israel in my opinion for what it is worth are most unlikely Jews. Israel was given to us to atone for the great crime against all Jews in WWII. This was by no means the only persecution but it was the worst. Many of us were lost partly out of fear for admitting to our Jewish identity. All we had was our name. Many of are grandchildren and great children or orthodox ancestors and cannot trace beyond 1939. Those Orthodox lucky enough to escape Holocaust be grateful and show tolerance and kindness to your brothers and sisters.

  4. Stuart Kaufman says:

    He was right!

  5. Gerald Sussman says:

    It's time for the Orthodox community to realize that they are not the only Jews out there. When Orthodox Rabbis make Psak Halachah they should think about how it effects those outside of their own community which is what the great Rabbis of the past did. The Reform do not help matters either, they do things such as patrilinial descent and then expect that everyone will accept them. Both Orthodox and Reform should think about how what they do effect the other.

  6. Rotem is correct. Reform Judaism is not Judaism, if for no other reason than their basic tenet is that the Torah is not the Word of Hashem given at Sinai. They believe that it was written by humans,and Judaism is a cafeteria in which you can pick and choose what you wish to believe in and practice. The word "mitzvah" is translated as "good deed," not as a commandment from Hashem to the Jewish People to be followed for all time. Many Reform congregations brag that there are more non-Jews who are members and are intermarried with Jews than there are Jews as members. And that's even given their warped definition that someone with a Jewish father and non-Jewish mother is Jewish. No apology was necessary. There are many halachically-Jewish Jews who call themselves "Reform" or "Conservative" or "Reconstructionist," just as there are halachically-Jewish Jews who call themselves "Christian," "Buddhist," etc. That doesn't mean that what they're practicing is valid or true. We need Mashiach now!

  7. Gary Harper says:

    As a Goy, I read something interesting the other day. Long, long ago, those who rejected the many forms of idolatry and accepted that there was only one God were counted as being among the Jews. How did it get to this point, where the children of Israel all argue over who is a true child of their fathers? I see God as far more forgiving and merciful. But then, I am a Goy, an outsider. Perhaps Israel's blood is in me; perhaps not. My perspective is that politics gets in the way of the whole nation's rapprochement with God far too often. If Israel is not accepting of its own diversity, what hope is there for the Kingdom to come right now? It is obvious that the nation apart has remained so for generations. You will never be assimilated, so do not fear that. So with that in mind, I get back to my original question. Is that which is always being argued over found within the original words of the five Books? And did not all of your greatest heroes sometimes do otherwise than what the Word requires? Moses, Jacob, Abram, David, Solomon, Saul, Sampson come to mind. You also have Rahab, Balaam, and others to consider. The different Jewish sects not getting along is both puzzling and problematic to me. I cannot understand it. But, I am a Goy on the outside…it is fascinating, that you remind me so much of the Christian denominations, in your arguments with one another. How can the Kingdom ever come, when all on earth cannot even get along with their own? God knows the heart and soul of a man or woman, and that is all that really counts in the end. If I could trace my lineage back to Moses, Jacob, Abram, David, Solomon, Saul, Sampson, Rahab, Balaam, Elisha, Isaiah, Daniel, or Jeremiah, what would be accomplished? Is not the convert counted as an equal among you, as commanded by God Himself in the desert? There is much I do not understand about the Jews and Christians both, that appears to be counterproductive to God's purpose. This also holds for the children of Ishmael.

  8. Gail Nestel says:

    This speaks not to one Rabbi's comments but to the control orthodoxy maintains on Israeli society and religious policy. Yeshiva boys in the military?…No! The Israeli state must remain a secular state with level of practice and choice of Rabbi for marriage and Mitzvot a personal one.

  9. Gail Nestel says:

    PS…Your characterization of Reform Jewry as anti-Zionist is grossly overstated! check the statistics…and the last time I checked Halacha, the only thing that defines a Jewish child is a Jewish mother…or conversion, again by a Rabbi of one's choice.

  10. It is time to reform judaism, the same are now doing the Catholic Church, it is a shame that between jews are racists, jews are racists to christians saying to them "goyem or shikse", this has to end, that is why there are anti-semits.

  11. Blue Beyond says:

    You've misunderstood. Those that are Jews according to Halachah remain Jews. It's a club you can't quit. But their religious practices are not Jewish. They are Judaism's "Unitarians" if you will on their way to loss of the culture entirely.

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Loading Facebook Comments ...
Loading Disqus Comments ...
Current Top Story
FBI Wanted poster for Osama bin Laden
Pakistan Library Renamed to Honor bin Laden
Latest News Stories
FBI Wanted poster for Osama bin Laden

Many Pakistanis consider bin Laden a “hero of Islam.”

Two major obstacles have kept Israel from joining the program: Allegations by U.S. officials that Israel has discriminated against Arab- and Muslim-Americans seeking entry, and a proliferation of young Israelis traveling to the United States as tourists and then working illegally.

A Lebanese man who was arrested in Thailand on suspicion of belonging to Hezbollah admitted to targeting Israelis, Thai media reported.

On Friday afternoon, Syrian fighter jets hit opposition/rebel targets and villages on the Syrian side of the Ramat HaGolan (Golan Heights), in the Quneitra region. Large pillars of smoke are seen rising from struck areas. Quneitra is the site of an official crossing between Syria and Israel on the Golan. IAF jets were sent out […]

As Rabbi Stav said, “You’re free to think what you want. But do you want me to recognize Chelsea Clinton’s child as a Jew?”

Chimpanzees and Orangutans eat Matza, unleavened bread traditionally eaten during the Passover holiday, at the Ramat Gan Safari on Thursday, April 17, 2014. I hope they can digest it. On Passover no leavened bread (Chametz) is allowed in Jewish possession, and that includes food we feed our animals.

Following intelligence reports of further expected Arab rioting and violence on the Temple Mount today, the police have placed restrictions on Muslim entry to the Jewish holy site, according to a report on Arutz-7. Entry will be limited to Muslims over the age of 50, and women, also they must be Israeli citizens or residency […]

PA President Abbas’s refusal to publicly condemn the terror attack that killed Baruch Mizrachi is putting a damper on the parade.

The Shas political party, founded and run by the late Rav Ovadia Yosef, has a appointed a new spiritual leader, according to a Galei Tzahal report. The rabbi chosen to replace Harav Ovadia and be the new president of the party’s Council of Torah Sages is Rabbi Shalom Cohen. Aryeh Deri is the political leader […]

In 1941, the Jews of Kiev received a similar leaflet. When they showed up the next day, more than 34,000 were murdered.

Teen stabbed in South Florida high school.

The Kotel Plaza, the stairs, the Kotel entrance, the roads, everything was packed for Birkat Cohanim – the Priestly Blessing of the People – now imagine if this had been held on top of Har HaBayit, the Temple Mount!

Four Israeli citizens were hurt Thursday in a road terror attack near Tekoa in Gush Etzion.

Israel Police closed access to the Temple Mount to Jews and other non-Muslims on Thursday due to Arab violence.

Jews in Donetsk, Ukraine this week were ordered to “register” themselves and their assets.

U.S. Special Envoy to the Middle East Martin Indyk is on his way back to the region to revive talks between Israel and the Palestinian Authority.

More Articles from Tzvi Ben-Gedalyahu
Police manhandle a youth in expulsion from the Hebron Peace house in December 2008.

The government’s approval of Jews moving into the Hebron building marks a return to a bit of political normalcy.

Israel is preparing a program to help absorb an increasing number of Jews making aliyah.

There is nothing like a good round of anti-Semitism to sober up Jews to move to Israel.

Card-carrying Israeli citizens in a totally Arab city in the western Galilee already are preparing celebrations for what they expect will be the return of their “heroes” who killed Israelis in terrorist attacks. The United States is trying to work out a deal with Israel to allow freeing several Arab terrorists with Israeli citizenship in […]

The BDS movement has done us a favor by showing the world they are idiots over the Scarlett-SodaStream duet.

Yesha leader have a problem condemning violence if it carried out “for the cause.”

The Sheldon Adelson Family Foundation has contributed $16.4 million to the Israel Lunar Project to build the world smallest spacecraft that SpaceIL hopes to land on the moon. The donation is nearly half of the project’s budget, estimated at $36 million. SpaceIL is an Israeli non-profit founded at the end of 2010 by three young […]

It might be best to say the Traveler’s Prayer on the airplane before putting on tefillin.

It won’t happen so soon, but it is only a matter of time until Jewish in Efrat finally can be like Jews in Tel Aviv.

    Latest Poll

    Now that Kerry's "Peace Talks" are apparently over, are you...?







    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/mk-who-excluded-reform-jews-from-judaism-was-misunderstood/2014/02/06/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: