web analytics
June 3, 2015 / 16 Sivan, 5775
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post


HALLELUJAH?

Netanyahu Approves Egalitarian Section at Western Wall

The women win a battle, but the question is, “Do they want a war they might lose?” Netanyahu approves Sharansky’s plan for women to pray like men in an “egalitarian” section at the Western Wall.
The WOW group pray at the Kotel, but Jordan objects.

The WOW group pray at the Kotel, but Jordan objects.
Photo Credit: WOW

Women finally have the official nod to pray with a tallis, read from a Torah scroll and do more or less as they wish in a new “egalitarian” section to be enlarged at the southern end of the Western Wall, Haaretz reported Monday.

The newspaper said that Prime Minister Netanyahu told Jewish Agency chairman Natan Sharansky, who formulated the proposal, to draw up a timetable for establishing an egalitarian section at the Western Wall, popularly known by the Hebrew term “Kotel.” Sharansky is to meet with Office of the Prime Minister director Tzvi Hauser and with National Security Advisor Yaakov Amidror, who is orthodox, to move the proposal off the drawing boards.

The decision ostensibly undermines the authority of the orthodox Rabbinate at the Western Wall, where there is a men’s and women’s section but no permission for women to pray in a non-traditional way.

However, the “victory” of the “Women of the Wall”, led primarily by American immigrants belonging to the Reform movement, is not necessarily the opening shot to challenge orthodox Judaism as the authority in Israel.

Indeed, it may be the last shot as well as the first.

The Prime Minister reportedly was encouraged by the massive support from American Jews for the women’s demands at the Western Wall, the most popular religious site for Jews visiting Israel.

The sight of policemen arresting women for the crime of disturbing public order by wearing a tallis or trying to carry a Torah scroll to the Western Wall was too much for American Jews, offended by the apparent affront to the pluralistic understanding of “equality.”

Buoyed by massive coverage in the American media, led by The New York Times, the Diaspora shouted from the rooftops, although not from the women’s sections of synagogues. The shouting was no match for the austere face of the orthodox Rabbinate, which often does everything it can to distance Jews who don’t do as they say.

The Haaretz report that the adoption of the plan “would wrest exclusive control of prayer at the wall from the Orthodox” may be wishful thinking for the newspaper, known for its bitter opposition to anything that smacks of religious authority if it is by orthodox Jewry.

If the women think that the Sharansky plan sets the stage for the Reform movement to challenge the orthodox rabbinate, they may have to say a lot of prayers to fulfill their wishes.

As much as the American Jewish committee thinks it influences what happens in Israel, one important factor in Netanyahu’s decision is that most of the Israeli public could care less one way or the other about the issue.

Most Israelis are not orthodox but most also are steeped in tradition and Middle East culture. They consider many American customs a bit odd, if not weird. Westernization is fine at the malls, and if women want to pray like men, fine.

The right of women to wear a tallis and read from a Torah scroll in their own egalitarian space does not mean that Israelis won’t stay quiet if the Reform movement wages a war on the entire orthodox establishment.

As secular as Israelis appear to be to Americans, scantily or oddly-dressed women often are seen in Israel reciting Psalms while traveling on buses or waiting at the bus stop.

Secular Israelis have a common cause with non-Orthodox Americans on the issues of civil marriages and divorces, but they will not necessarily be in a hurry to support a direct challenge to the orthodox rabbinate, which is a crucial part of modern Israeli culture.

The fact is that the Women of the Wall’s “victory” confines them to a special area, away from the popular Western Wall area. True equality, in their view, would be able to pray exactly where everyone else prays.

In effect, they may have lost the war by winning the battle.

About the Author: Tzvi Ben Gedalyahu is a graduate in journalism and economics from The George Washington University. He has worked as a cub reporter in rural Virginia and as senior copy editor for major Canadian metropolitan dailies. Tzvi wrote for Arutz Sheva for several years before joining the Jewish Press.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

8 Responses to “Netanyahu Approves Egalitarian Section at Western Wall”

  1. Samuel Ramos says:

    Good! About time!

  2. Samuel Ramos says:

    Good! About time!

  3. Anonymous says:

    Years back the Israeli Supreme Court studied the issue of religious customs at the Western Wall and ruled that the Western Wall Plaza was shouold follow Minhag Jerusalem, which is orthodox, and that the section of the Western Wall known as Robinson's Arch should be set aside for Women of the Wall and other non-Orthodox services. Natan Sharansky and Netanyahu are merely reaffirming the Supreme Court ruling..

  4. I'm British and I Love this article with passion.

  5. Nachama Rifka says:

    This doesn't surprise me, especially seeing as there are no charadim in goverment. This state is a jokeee.

  6. Ahron Ebert says:

    WOW have no problem with going up to The Temple Mount. Let them go further than The Wall and pray on The Temple Mount. The only reason Orthodox do not go closer is because they believe it is porhibited to go further than The Wall.

  7. Dan Silagi says:

    Wishful thinking on your part, Tzvi.

Comments are closed.

Current Top Story
Anti-Semitic vandals snapped together white plastic tiles to form a giant swastika on the football field of El Camino High School in San Francisco.
Giant Swastika Spread On San Francisco HS Football Field
Latest News Stories
money

This all-or-nothing multi-organization online fundraising event has raised more than $2.5M. All donations are quadrupled.

Karnit Flug and Moshe Kachlon

Finance Minister Moshe Kachlon and Bank of Israel Governor Karnit Flug met today to discuss Israeli banking.

Anti-Semitic vandals snapped together white plastic tiles to form a giant swastika on the football field of El Camino High School in San Francisco.

A huge white swastika is spread on the football field at a San Francisco high school after graduation ceremonies.

Rochelle Shoretz

I’ve had such a rich and meaningful life. Of course I wish I had more time.

Unity Day was developed by the parents of Eyal Ifrach, Gil-ad Shaer and Naftali Fraenkel z”l and their foundation, The Memorial Foundation for the Three Boys, together with Jerusalem Mayor Nir Barkat and GESHER.

The President’s remarks indicate that his “back” for Israel is shrinking.

It appears that the American government leaked the captivity after failing to gain freedom for the hostages.

He also criticized Britain for boycotting Israel’s defense expo; British diplomat claims UK “committed” to trade links with Israel.

The Times reported its stockpile of nuclear fuel increased by 20 percent.

Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu called US Vice President Joe Biden Tuesday night and expressed condolences on behalf of himself, his wife Sara and the people of Israel on the passing of Beau Biden this past Saturday. The Prime Minister told Biden that he recalled the pride with which the latter – during their 20 years […]

The Senate voted 62-37 Tuesday night to pass a House bill that resumes clauses in the Patriot Ac t that expired Sunday night and left the NSA without power to collect phone data of suspected terrorists. The bill revises the Patriot Act and ends the freedom of the NSA to collect data on everyone, even […]

President Barack Obama on Tuesday awarded two posthumous Medals of Honor to Jewish and black World War I veterans who likely did not receive the awards due to discrimination at the time. The medals were given to Jewish Army Sergeant William Shemin and black Army Private Henry Williams. “No one who serves our country should […]

An FBI agent and Boston Police officer shot and killed a 26-year-old terror suspect as he repeatedly lunged at them with a large knife.

Obama says no military solution to Iran problem while his advisers trash Bibi for the bad blood.

FIFA President Sepp Blatter resigns from his post amid a massive corruption scandal just four days after being elected to a fifth term.

PM Netanyahu warns Israelis the rising risks of Iranian proxy attacks are “piling up,” as the US hurtles towards a “bad deal” with Tehran.

More Articles from Tzvi Ben-Gedalyahu
Ilana Dayan interviews President Obama in the White House.

The President’s remarks indicate that his “back” for Israel is shrinking.

Iranian-backed Houthis in Sanaa, Yemen.

It appears that the American government leaked the captivity after failing to gain freedom for the hostages.

He also criticized Britain for boycotting Israel’s defense expo; British diplomat claims UK “committed” to trade links with Israel.

The Times reported its stockpile of nuclear fuel increased by 20 percent.

After he dropped the FIFA ball, now he wants to make a bigger fool out of himself.

He either was killed by Hamas or blew himself up.

Foreign Ministry nerds are wrongly calling the boycott an aftermath of the FIFA nonsense.

Sirens are to blast throughout Israel in two minutes, at 11:05 to be exact. They are part of the annual national defense exercise. If there is real trouble, additional sirens will blast. A replay will take place tonight at 7:05.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/netanyahu-approves-egalitarian-section-at-western-wall/2013/04/22/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: