web analytics
April 21, 2015 / 2 Iyar, 5775
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post


NY Officials Claim Chasidic Dress Code Violates Human Rights

When is a dress code legal and when it is a violation of human rights? That seems to depend on whether you are a Chasidic Jewish shop owner in New York.
Williamsburg storefront sign bans immodest attire.

Williamsburg storefront sign bans immodest attire.
Photo Credit: CBS News screenshot

New York City’s Commission on Human Rights has served notice on owners of seven Chasidic stores in Williamsburg that posting a sign that does not allow service to women with “low-cut necklines” is a violation of their human rights.

But what about all the “no shorts, no shoes, no service” signs that are a favorite among the snob crowd?

That’s okay because it is a dress code, the commission general counsel Cliff Mulqueen explained to the Jewish Week.

And prohibiting low-cut necklines is not a dress code?

Of course not, he reasons. That is a religious decree, and telling someone they have “to abide by certain rules of the Jewish faith crosses the line into [establishing] a protected class,” according to his logic.

God says that the Jews are the Chosen People, but now New York rules we are the “protected class.” Maybe human rights officials also think that the designation of a Chosen People denies human rights to others.

Regardless, a restaurant presumably can post a sign telling patrons not to enter with immodest dress without worrying about a human rights violation, but if an orthodox Jew, especially a Chasidic Jew, puts out a sign like that, he is in trouble.

The New York Post pointed out that no one really is refused service in a Chasidic-owned store because of his religion or gender. A Christian, a Muslim a Buddhist and even an atheist could enter, so long as he or she obeys the sign stating, “No Shorts, No Barefoot, No Sleeveless, No Low Cut Necklines Allowed in the Store.”

The commission last summer told the newspaper that the signs are legal, but now seven stores have been cited for violating human rights. A top law firm, Kirkland & Ellis, is representing the shop owners on a voluntary basis.

What would the city say if a snotty WASP country club were to post a sign, “No shtreimels?

It probably would say nothing because, after all, that is only a dress code.

About the Author: Tzvi Ben Gedalyahu is a graduate in journalism and economics from The George Washington University. He has worked as a cub reporter in rural Virginia and as senior copy editor for major Canadian metropolitan dailies. Tzvi wrote for Arutz Sheva for several years before joining the Jewish Press.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

16 Responses to “NY Officials Claim Chasidic Dress Code Violates Human Rights”

  1. Issy Rondel says:

    WELL, WE DO HAVE A FEW CRAZY’S ALSO, LIKE THAT ABOVE. WTF, have they forgotten what happened 75 years ago.

  2. I think that any store owner should have that right and I think if a Hotel lobby, Restaurant or Casino can insist on certain go’s and no go’s then so can a more observant store owner. If I as a patron do not like it, then I am sure NY offers enough other stores to buy from. This is just another way of lashing out at Jews. I am so tired of using all sorts of excuses in order to do that! At least have the courage to be open about your antisemitism!

  3. John Keytack says:

    What??? So now, the lunatics are running the asylum! The observant people have rights, too!

  4. Arie's Pragmatic Politics says:

    And yet stores owned by orthodox Muslims can have a cover up and bhyrqa requirement. But no surprise since bloomie's comments at a mosque that "we are all muslims today".

  5. I don't understand how women's rights are being violated, as they're not required to shop there. If they don't like the restrictions, they can simply go elsewhere.

  6. Susan Cohen says:

    How is it women's right that are restricted any mo9re than men's rights?

  7. name names of who is on this so-called "commission".

  8. Dan Silagi says:

    The Chassidim can dress however they like; nobody's stopping them. But there's a big problem when they start dictating to others how they should dress; stores are places of public accomadation. Let's cut the BS here; the reason for these "rules" are to keep goyim and non-observant Jews out. One day, my wife and I will enter one of these stores; dressed as one would normally dress on a hot summer day. Let these a-holes try to kick us out.

  9. Lee Graham says:

    dan, you are a troublemaker, nothing more! a restaurant can mandate ANY ATTIRE that they want, specifically so the patrons all look like the management wants. i can't imagine any business wanting to count you a customer. I'm sure you have a gorgeous hairy chest, may i suggest that you share it with (only) your wife!

  10. Joels Davidi says:

    In this current heat wave, maybe they ARE on to something…

  11. Dan Silagi says:

    Well Lee, you're right about my being a troublemaker. As were Rosa Parks, Jackie Robinson, and Martin Luther King, among many others. This is not about going into a store barechested; it's about wearing normal warm-weather attire in a Hasidic neighborhood, where the inhabitants demand women wear burkhas, or similar attire.

    I don't have a particularly hairy chest, Lee. But I do have a 48" chest (and a 36" waist), with rather well-developed pectoral muscles (I'm a bodybuilder).

    And no, a restaurant cannot mandate its customers to look as management desires, nor can any other business. I don't like how Haredim dress, especially the men. But I'd welcome them into my place of business as I would anyone else. If I put up a sign barring tzitzas I'd get my butt sued, and rightfully so.

    I bet you think that the Haredi bus lines have the right to make women sit on one side of the bus and men on the other. They don't, and that's also the law.

  12. Dan Silagi says:

    WHAT current heat wave? It's 53 degrees (Fahrenheit) out!

  13. Yechiel Baum says:

    In all Arab countries their is a modesty dress code that shows their respect to their religion and the owners of the stores. You cannot tell store owners who they cannot invite into their stores. Moreover, people realize what these retailers are selling so obviously the liberals would not find anything there that they would buy and wear unless they are there to annoy others which is also a chilul Hashem.

  14. I was in Crwon Heights on Lag Bomer. There were non-Jewish Asians and Blacks in the restaurant and they were dressed conservatively and being served. Dan YOU BE WRONG ABOUT "RULES"… Money is Money. Now what they were doing there….very crowded day

  15. Kateri Blackwing says:

    this is not Israel this is the United States how dare they do that that is why I hate them so.

Comments are closed.

Current Top Story
Rav Aharon Lichtenstein
Republished: My Rebbe Rav Aharon Lichtenstein Is Awarded the Israel Prize 2014
Latest News Stories
Amb. Thomas Pickering testified before the  House Armed Services Committee,  about Iran's nuclear program on June 19, 2014.

Forget about Israel, doesn’t Brandeis care about Iran’s abysmal human rights record?

The aircraft carrier USS Theodore Roosevelt is steaming towards the Yemeni coast to intercept Iranian ships believed to be supplying the Houthi rebels. April 20, 2015.

As Iran may be re-supplying the Houthis, US warships steam towards Yemen.

A Jewish man with a Russian accent stabbed an Arab worker Monday in Herzliya, next to Tel Aviv, while yelling “Death to Arabs,” police said. The attacker confessed that he intentionally targeted an Arab. The victim suffered light wounds in his shoulder, was treated on the scene and hospitalized. The assailant is a resident of […]

Russian S-300 surface-to-air missile systems deployed in a military exercise.

if Iran tries to move a Russian s-300 antimissile system to Syria or Hezbollah in Lebanon, Israel will make sure it doesn’t get there.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu expressed his sorrow over the passing of Rabbi Aharon Lichtenstein Monday. “Rabbi Lichtenstein’s knowledge found expression in his literary works. He served generations of students,” said the Prime Minister. He added, “When I gave him the Israel Prize a year ago, I saw before my eyes a great rabbi, teacher and […]

“Sexual violence in conflict has become a weapon of choice because it is cheap, silent and effective.”

Saudi Arabia has posted an alert of a possible terror attack on Aramco’s oil facilities and malls in the capital of Riyadh, Bloomberg News reported Monday morning. “We have informed security forces to be on alert and to take any necessary security procedures [against] a possible terrorist attack attempt,” spokesman General Mansour al-Turki told the […]

President Reuven Rivlin granted Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu two more weeks Monday morning to form a new government coalition after negotiations with different t parties have not produced a positive result. Rivlin really had no other choice. He would like to see a national unity government with the Likud and the Zionist Union, the euphemism […]

He followed and spread the teachings of his late father-in-law, Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik.

An Egyptian court has sentenced an Egyptian man and two Israeli citizens to life in prison for allegedly spying for Israel. The Israeli citizens were sentenced in absentia, and are unlikely to travel to Egypt to serve their sentences. The Egyptian man, Salama Muhammed Saliman, was convicted of giving the two Israelis information regarding both […]

Netanyahu met with children of parents who lost their lives in service to the State of Israel.

Bennett drew his red line on Twitter, but don’t worry. There is a Jewish solution.

Former chief Rome Rabbi Elio Toaff died on Sunday the age of 99, two weeks before what was supposed to be his 100th birthday. He served as chief rabbi of the city for 51 years until 2002 after having served as the chief rabbi of Venice. Rabbi Toaf once prayed with Pope John Paul II, […]

The Egyptian army has destroyed 185 smuggling and terror tunnels under the border between Egypt and Gaza since February, according to the country’s military spokesman. Sixty-nine of them were destroyed in the past three weeks. One of them was more than a mile long and 10 feet deep and was used for smuggling weapons and […]

Israeli workers making a flags of Israel at the Berman’s Flags and Embroidery factory in Jerusalem on April 19, 2015, prior to the Israel 67th Independence day.

More Articles from Tzvi Ben-Gedalyahu
Russian S-300 surface-to-air missile systems deployed in a military exercise.

if Iran tries to move a Russian s-300 antimissile system to Syria or Hezbollah in Lebanon, Israel will make sure it doesn’t get there.

Ron Prosor, Israel's Ambassador to the United Nations.

“Sexual violence in conflict has become a weapon of choice because it is cheap, silent and effective.”

Bennett drew his red line on Twitter, but don’t worry. There is a Jewish solution.

Obama figures he can deal with Iran by letting it humiliate him.

The West grants the right to vote. Islamists want to take it away. Will they tell US Muslims not to vote?

It is going to be a very windy Independence Day. Snow will fall on the upper slopes of the Hermon.

The lives of Gaza residents under Hamas go from miserable to even more miserable.

Is Afghanistan becoming another country that US has made safe for the Islamic State?

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/ny-officials-claim-chasidic-dress-code-violates-human-rights/2013/04/29/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: