web analytics
January 27, 2015 / 7 Shevat, 5775
 
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post


Defending the Human Rights of Everyone (except Israelis)

Pro-Violence Against Israeli Civilians No Bar to Human Rights Award

In other words, to those who believe the worst lies about Israel -- think Jenin massacre, Mohammed al Dura -- visions of which are so often the internal movies constantly looping behind the eyelids of people who talk about "occupation," Israelis really kind of get what they deserve, don't you think?
Mona Seif, left, is one of the finalists for the Martin Ennals Human Rights Defenders Award, known as the "Nobel Prize for Human Rights."

Mona Seif, left, is one of the finalists for the Martin Ennals Human Rights Defenders Award, known as the "Nobel Prize for Human Rights."
Photo Credit: Lori Lowenthal Marcus

On Tuesday, October 8, the 2013 Martin Ennals Human Rights Defender Award was presented in Geneva, Switzerland to someone other than an Egyptian woman who repeatedly vilified and glorified violence against Israel.

Yes, things are so bad it is newsworthy when a promoter of human rights abuses against the Jewish state was not voted by the leading global human rights organizations as the top human rights defender in 2013.

But although Egyptian social media activist Mona Seif was not chosen as this year’s award recipient, it is barely less astounding that she was chosen as a nominee, and then again as one of the three finalists for what is known as the “Nobel Prize for Human Rights” in spite of her very public advocacy of terrorist and wanton destruction against the Jewish State.

Friday morning and then again on Monday, the day before the award was presented, The Jewish Press spoke with the (non-voting) chair of the Martin Ennals Human Rights Award jury, Hans Thoolen, in an effort to understand how Mona Seif could be considered a credible nominee.

The Jewish Press first covered this story back in May when we learned that  Seif had been nominated for the award because of her social media activism in countering the Mubarak regime’s repressive actions and in mobilizing protesters and supporters of the Egyptian Revolution in Tahrir Square during the winter of 2010 – 11.

But it was her use of that same social media to threaten and to glorify attacks against Israel that led at least some human rights advocates – those who also support the right of the Jewish State to defend itself – to question Seif’s nomination.

True, Seif organized and activated an important Egyptian grassroots organization which opposed former Egyptian President Hosnai Mubarak’s use of military trials for civilians through her masterful use of social media. She tweeted out messages warning of oppressive moves by the former Egyptian government, and helped mobilize protesters and supporters of Tahrir Square’s Egyptian Revolution during the winter of 2010-2011. That takes bravery, especially given the alarmingly violent misogyny in Egypt, particularly amongst the young revolutionaries.

But, as was pointed out when Seif’s nomination was first announced, there is a darker side to her social media activity.  People who think that the Jewish state is entitled to self-defense and security in the face of decades of existential terrorism find that side utterly inconsistent with the fundamental precepts of the Martin Ennals Human Rights Defender Award.

Seif’s Twitter account revealed a propensity to express the most vulgar kind of hatred towards Israel, both in terms of how she expresses herself, “#F[expletive deleted]Israel” being a popular choice, as well as the substance of her messages, which advocate terrorism against the Jewish State and which harshly criticized Human Rights organizations that dared to suggest the terrorist group Hamas should refrain from killing Israeli civilians.

Last week Alana Goodman in the Washington Free Beacon reported that additional messages advocating violence against Jews and Israel had been sent out via Twitter by Seif. Here is a translation from the Arabic of the most egregious:

Palestine is my way, and I am full of determination and will. I will draw my blood in the West Bank, I will fight to my death in Gaza, I will support by people in Bethlehem and I will achieve martyrdom in Jerusalem.

How is it possible that the Martin Ennals Foundation considered holding up to the world as a global role model “defender of human rights” someone who published such a message of murderous hatred and hopes to participate in murder? That was just one of the questions put to Mr. Thoolen.

Some cynics suggested that of course such a double standard exists, killing, torture and demonization is only wrong – in the eyes of the global human rights community – when it is about anyone other than Israelis: Jews from the Jewish state.  We hoped the cynics would not be proven right.

We were wrong.

Thoolen was kind enough to spend a good deal of time explaining why twitter remarks such as the ones sent out by Seif simply could not be the basis for disqualifying a nominee whose bravery on behalf of Egyptian rights qualified her to be nominated.

He made two points.

One, tweets constitute a different level of expression than, say, university talks or published articles, because they are more spontaneous, and therefore should be subject to a lower level of scrutiny.

Second, and this illuminates the darker problem, Thoolen matter of factly, and repeatedly, justified some of Seif’s rhetoric with the chilling words: “the right of resistance under occupation is very much a subject of international dispute.”

In other words, to those who believe the worst lies about Israel — think Jenin massacre, Mohammed al Dura, Gaza as an open air prison, Israelis detaining Arab Palestinians in order to harvest their organs — visions of which are so often the internal movies constantly looping behind the eyelids of people who talk about “occupation,” Israelis really kind of get what they deserve, don’t you think?  And be sure to whisper that with a blended European accent.

Thoolen addressed what he called “an attack” on the “courageous human rights defender” in his blog when concerns were first raised about Seif last May.  He was then critical only about “the vitriolic” UN Watch, which first brought Seif’s hatred of Israel and support for violence to public attention.

But how would he explain the latest tweet, the one about achieving martyrdom in Jerusalem?  Thoolen was comfortable with that one also.  He said the words are not Seif’s own, but are from a song popularized by supporters of an Egyptian soccer team who achieved heroic status as the result of a horrific riot in which tens of Egyptians died, allegedly at the hands of the Egyptian military police.

Thoolen described Seif’s tweeting out the words to the Ultras’ theme song as a kind of  “poetic language” for which she really should not be held accountable.  Glorifying the brutal murder of innocent Jews as the natural expression of anger about Egyptian military oppression is not surprising or unacceptable even for the most public of global human rights experts.

Chair of the jury for the Martin Ennals Human Rights Award Hans Thoolen, left, hands an award to finalist Mona Seif during the Oct. 8, 2013 ceremony in Geneva.

Chair of the jury for the Martin Ennals Human Rights Award Hans Thoolen, left, hands an award to finalist Mona Seif during the Oct. 8, 2013 ceremony in Geneva.

There was one big concession, if one wishes to see it this way, repeatedly hinted at by Thoolen.  This is that after the announcement of this year’s winner, the jury members may then take up the matter of whether its internal procedures need to be adjusted to take into consideration whether and how to weigh comments made by an award contender when using social media.

But how big a concession is that when obviously the jury considers social media activity?  After all, that’s how Seif was nominated in the first place.

There were two other finalists for the 2013 Martin Ennals Human Rights Defender Award.

The Joint Mobile Group was created by Igor Kalyapin to reduce the risk of sending investigators on short missions into Chechnya to document Human Rights abuses including disappearances, torture in custody and extra-judicial executions.  The other finalist, Mario Joseph, is considered one of Haiti’s most important human rights lawyers. Joseph has worked on some of the most important cases in Haiti, including the current case against the former dictator Jean-Claude “Baby Doc” Duvalier.

The panel of human rights organizations which selected Seif as an appropriate nominee are among the top ten human rights organizations in the world, including Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, Human Rights First, World Organization Against Torture, International Commission of Jurists and the International Service for Human Rights.

The winner of this year’s award is the Joint Mobile Group, created and represented by Igor Kalyapin. But Seif’s very public approval of violence and terrorism against Israel was not even a consideration about whether the human rights community should hold her up as a global model of human rights advocacy.

About the Author: Lori Lowenthal Marcus is the US correspondent for The Jewish Press. She is a recovered lawyer who previously practiced First Amendment law and taught in Philadelphia-area graduate and law schools.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

5 Responses to “Pro-Violence Against Israeli Civilians No Bar to Human Rights Award”

  1. It's good that this reporter doesn't acknowledge the fact, but I fear that the explanation for this insanity is in the book of Numbers, Chapter 23 verse 9: הן ֵעם לֹּבדד ישכן ובגוים לא יתחשב "Lo, it is a people that shall dwell alone, and shall not be reckoned among the nations." That, plus we show up the rest of the world so much that they just can't stand it, or us.
    So advocating the murder of Jews is never going to be an obstacle to receiving an award as a great humanitarian. I wish it were otherwise, but it just ain't.

  2. Before we condemn Mubarak, let's remember who he was fighting against. Although the media liked to portray the up risers of the "Arab Spring," as freedom fighters what they were the same people who voted to put the Islamist terrorist group, the Muslim Brotherhood in power. Some of these people that Mubarak arrested could have had terrorist ties. Here in America, there is a similar debate. The Democrats think terrorists should be tried in a civilian court and the Republicans believe terrorists should be tried in a military court because terrorism is a crime against the state. Generally, if terrorists are tried in a military court, their punishment is more severe. So I don't have a problem with Mubarak cracking down on these people. If we fast forward to today, we see that when the Muslim Brotherhood was in power in Egypt, they went over to Gaza and voiced support for Hamas's continuing murder campaign against Israel. Now that the Egyptian military is in authority and is closely aligned with Mubarak, they have aggressively fought terrorists, bombed underground weapon supply tunnels, and turned back Palestinians seeking refuge from "occupation" meaning Israel. In regards to Saif, I am not surprised that she was a nominee, even though she espoused hatred and violence against Israel. Anti Semitism is rampant right now and this plays right into the hands of the anti Israel rhetoric that is so prevalent today.

  3. seif should not get so overwrought over Jews. she could get a massive stroke. hopefully.

  4. Yechiel Baum says:

    soon The Hitler family will win it too since sief set the precedent as did wldheim

  5. Stuart Wragg says:

    Bizzare how people can actually buy into her insane mentality.

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
New York City in  the much-ballyhooed 'Snowstorm Juno'.
NYC All Prepped Up But ‘No Snow Go, Mayor DeBlasio’
Latest News Stories
israel polls

The united Arab list is enough to shift the balance of power.

New York City in  the much-ballyhooed 'Snowstorm Juno'.

It was supposed to be the “historic snowstorm of the past half-century.” But in NYC it just didn’t happen that way.

U.S. Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, released by Taliban in exchange for 5 Gitmo prisoners

Reports are swirling that U.S. Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl will be charged with desertion. Bergdahl walked out of his army base in Afghanistan in 2009 without permission, and was later captured by the Taliban and held as a prisoner for five years. In a highly-publicized and widely-criticized move, the U.S. exchanged five prisoners held at Guantanamo last […]

David Landau

The former editor-in-chief of Haaretz passed away at age 67 in Jerusalem.

The two rockets fired from Syria that exploded in Israel’s Golan Heights at 1 PM today signifies a new peak in tensions being felt in Israel’s northern borders.

BBC: “Our one big question this morning: Is the time coming to lay the Holocaust to rest?”

Visitors are invited to return to Mount Hermon Ski Resort after a double rocket attack sent officials to evacuate hundreds of people earlier in the day.

As usual, there is a big gap between what Arab countries promise and what they deliver.

An IDF soldier at the Yad Vashem Holocaust Memorial museum in Jerusalem. Tuesday, January 27th is International Holocaust Remembrance Day. On January 27, 1945 the Auschwitz-Birkenau concentration camp was liberated by Soviet forces.

The “Ugly Israeli” has taken its form in six idiot thugs who beat a Druze student, who served in the IDF, because he was speaking Arabic. A Jerusalem court was told the gang of Jews attacked the music student at the Central Bus Station in Jerusalem. The victim, identified as Tommy Hasson, served in the […]

President Obama is sending Jack Lew, the first Orthodox Jewish Treasury Secretary to the commemoration. Secretary Lew will be leading a delegation of State Department officials and Auschwitz survivors.

Two missiles exploded in the northern Golan Heights Tuesday afternoon, and the IDF has returned artillery fire into Syrian territory. The army is trying to determine where the missiles landed. It is not known if the missiles were misfired or were aimed at Israel. Unconfirmed reports said four rockets were launched at Israel. Sirens sounded […]

If two inches of snow is enough to shut down New York, what happens when two feet fall?

The Israeli economy is on the way to becoming owned by foreigners.

Israel’s president met in NY with the parents of lone soldiers who died during Operation Protective Edge

Facebook, Instagram and other social media platforms have fallen off the Internet worldwide.

More Articles from Lori Lowenthal Marcus
U.S. Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, released by Taliban in exchange for 5 Gitmo prisoners

Reports are swirling that U.S. Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl will be charged with desertion. Bergdahl walked out of his army base in Afghanistan in 2009 without permission, and was later captured by the Taliban and held as a prisoner for five years. In a highly-publicized and widely-criticized move, the U.S. exchanged five prisoners held at Guantanamo last […]

Ari Ne'eman, founder of Autistic Self-Advocacy Network, recipient of the Ruderman Award for Inclusion, 2015.

Ari Ne’eman, a pioneer in autism self-advocacy, awarded the Ruderman Prize in Inclusion.

French far-rightist politician Jean-Marie Le Pen suffered a facial injury.

Israeli President Ruvy Rivlin met in New York with former U.S. Secretary of State Henry Kissinger.

Iran allegedly is plotting to assassinate the sons of the current and former Israeli prime ministers.

In the Alberta province of Canada, a synagogue was defaced with huge block letters scrawled on its walls: ‘Leave Canada’

Fatah is calling on Palestinian Arabs to protests against Israel on Jan. 26, and to boycott Israeli products

Seven Americans have volunteered to each take 100 lashes in place of Saudi blogger Raif Badawi.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/pro-violence-against-israeli-civilians-no-bar-to-human-rights-award/2013/10/08/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: