web analytics
October 20, 2014 / 26 Tishri, 5775
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post
Meir Panim with Soldiers 5774 Roundup: Year of Relief and Service for Israel’s Needy

Meir Panim implements programs that serve Israel’s neediest populations with respect and dignity. Meir Panim also coordinated care packages for families in the South during the Gaza War.



Home » News & Views » US » NY »

Rabbi Broyde Admits To Using Fake Internet Persona, Takes Leave From RCA


Rabbi Michael Broyde

Rabbi Michael Broyde

Rabbi Michael Broyde, a leading Modern Orthodox rabbi and dayan, admitted to using a fake persona to join a rival rabbinic organization and herald his own work in scholarly journals.

Since the revelation, Rabbi Broyde has requested a leave of absence from the Rabbinical Council of America (RCA), where he was a member, and from its affiliated rabbinical court, the Beth Din of America, where he was a rabbinical court judge.

A lengthy article on The Jewish Channel last Friday detailed how Rabbi Broyde – who once was said to be on the short list of candidates to become the next chief rabbi of the United Kingdom – used the name “Rabbi Herschel Goldwasser” to join the International Rabbinic Fellowship (IRF), an Orthodox rabbinic organization considered to the left of the RCA; herald his own scholarship; and correspond with other rabbis.

Shortly after the report appeared, Rabbi Broyde, who is also a professor of law at Emory University, wrote in an e-mail to the IRF: “I realize that being an IRF member through a pseudonym was inappropriate. I am sorry. Please understand that no malice was intended and my participation was not intended to interfere with the growth or success of the IRF.”

In his apology letter, Rabbi Brodye claimed that the fakery ended three or four years ago and that recent posts under the Goldwasser pseudonym were authored by someone else.

In the e-mail, Rabbi Broyde said he and a friend, whom Rabbi Broyde does not name, used the pseudonym Goldwasser. Rabbi Broyde even used the fake persona to argue with himself on discussion boards.

Rabbi Broyde issued a public apology on the popular blog site Hirhurim, where he has been a frequent guest contributor. In it he admitted that he had erred in using the fake name to join a professional organization, an action for which he said he was “truly and genuinely sorry.” But on the wider use of a pseudonym, Rabbi Broyde wrote that he did not find it particularly harmful, noting that writing under an assumed name has a long history in Jewish discourse.

He concluded the post: “I publicly express here my apologies to those who were deceived by my pseudonymous writing.”

The online reaction has been mixed. Many of Rabbi Broyde’s detractors have pointed out that a dayan cannot serve if he has a credibility gap, and Rabbi Broyde’s actions have given him a big one.

One anonymous commenter to Rabbi Broyde’s article on Hirhurim wrote, “This article is not a real apology. You did something stupid and got caught, time to stop using lawyer language and start being honest.”

Another, going by the handle “Not impressed” wrote, “How is anyone impressed with this apology. This is non-apology apology at its worst.”

Rabbi Eliyahu Fink, rabbi of the Pacific Jewish Center in Los Angeles, wrote a lengthy post on his blog, finkorswim.com. In an e-mail to The Jewish Press, he stressed that he was not defending Rabbi Broyde, whom he called one of his heroes in his post, but simply “providing perspective.”

In the post he wrote, “It’s not so bad, but it’s bad. It’s bad because rabbis need credibility. Creating alter egos is a credibility issue. It gives others the sense that one cannot be honest and truthful or real in their professional life. A public figure pretending he is someone else shows a character flaw because it means that we are not able to stand behind our statements. But when the fake account is used to bolster one’s real life work, the issue becomes worse. It’s a way of falsely propping up one’s ideas. Sure, it should not matter how many people agree with someone when deciding the merits of one’s argument, but the reality is that people are drawn to ideas that have approval. For that, one could say that Rabbi Broyde perpetuated a fraud on the endearing public. It is akin to falsifying earnings reports to boost a stock price.

“On the other hand, it’s not so bad because no one was really harmed. Nothing really changed. It doesn’t really matter if he was posting things as himself or an anonymous pseudonym. It feels wrong, but no one has really been hurt here. In fact, many great rabbinic works have been written anonymously or pseudonymously.”

Rabbi Jonathan Rosenblatt, senior rabbi of the Riverdale Jewish Center, told The Jewish Press, “Rabbi Broyde possesses an extraordinary combination of talents and has made monumental contributions already, even if he never wrote another word. My hope is that we will find a way to access those gifts again for the good of Klal Yisrael.

“I do not believe he is an evil man; he did some misguided and hurtful things, but there is great goodness in his character. I don’t believe that the Almighty sent his gifts into the world and did not intend for us to find a way to use them.”

The IRF issued a statement, which said, in part, “As a prominent dayan of the BDA, rabbi and posek, Rabbi Broyde’s actions are all the more saddening and shocking. Honesty and yashrut [integrity] must be the hallmarks of all Jews and especially who occupy positions of leadership in the community.”

Rabbi Broyde also privately e-mailed Rabbi Shmuly Yanklowitz, founder and president of the organization Uri L’Tzedek and also a member of IRF.

In it, Rabbi Broyde said, “I am hoping and praying that our community will give me a chance to continue in some of the productive roles that I have had. I hope that there is still a capacity to forgive me for my mistakes.

“I recognize that this was a terrible ethical mistake and I have to accept all responsibility for it and ask for mechilah from everyone whom I hurt in this.

“A foundation of what we do as rabbis is build trust and I do understand that the trust has been broken, but I ask again for mechilah and the opportunity to rebuild that trust.

“Of course, I have learned from this and would never ever do anything like this again. Speaking about my own internal teshuva process is very hard for me but I am deeply reflective in some ways about my life and in my teshuva process; I hope that everyone understands that.”

(Jewish Press staff and JTA)

About the Author:


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

2 Responses to “Rabbi Broyde Admits To Using Fake Internet Persona, Takes Leave From RCA”

  1. Heshy Rosenwasser says:

    I'm glad he chose gold instead of roses, because his pseudonym is way to close to my real name for comfort.

  2. Heshy Rosenwasser says:

    … and what's really creeping me out is that he was a year ahead of me at the Hebrew Academy of Long Beach, and maybe on some subconscious level he did recall my name when coming up with his fake persona.

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
Aerial view of Yemenite Village of HaShiloach, Old City of Jerusalem and Mt. of Olives.
Jews to Double Presence in Old Yemenite Village of Shiloach, Silwan
Latest News Stories
Aerial view of Yemenite Village of HaShiloach, Old City of Jerusalem and Mt. of Olives.

Jews once thrived in the Shiloach area of old Jerusalem, known also as Silwan. Arabs and British came and drove them out. Now, they have returned.

Yitzchak Shamir Road

Prime Minister Netanyahu (L) congratulates Minister Yair Shamir (M) as President Ruby Rivlin and Jerusalem Mayor Nir Barkat look on (in the background), as Jerusalem’s new Road 9 is named after former Prime Minister Yitzchak Shamir, Israel’s 7th prime minister, who passed away in 2012. Yair Shamir, who looks very much like is father (and […]

Ismail Haniyeh, highest ranking Hamas member in Gaza, pictured Nov. 25, 2012.

#BDSFail as daughter of Hamas leader is treated in Israeli hospital.

Abbas was denounced by the SWC for trying to disassociate Jews from their holy sites and inciting violence against them.

The Jerusalem Intifada continues on…

A clear majority of Jewish Israelis oppose a Palestinian state, once they’re told the details of what it means.

Hamas has continued to test-fire its homemade rockets, firing them into the Mediterranean and into the Sinai desert in Egypt, where it has spotters. It is possible that the sirens this morning were tripped by such test launches.

The General Security Services (Shabak) of the State of Israel believes that more Israeli Muslims are preparing to join ISIS.

Israeli forces take part in a mass Ebola identification training exercise at Sheba Medical Center in Ramat Gan on October 17, 2014. Officials and employees from the Population Immigration and Border Authority, airlines, the Magen David Adom emergency medical services, the Health Ministry and the police participated in the drill, aimed at identifying travelers who […]

It’s raining today in Jerusalem, the first major rain storm of the new year.

Giuliani to keynote Klinghoffer opera’s opening night press conference and protest rally

At least 5 swastikas were discovered painted on the Temple Mount.

It is hard to believe, but Egypt is now dependent on Israel for gas instead of the other way around.

The checkpoint near Jenin was closed after the IDF thought a person passing through was a suicide bomber.

Barzilai hospital searched for its resident doctor-turned-terrorist after he disappeared and discovered that he changed professions.

More Articles from Combined News Services
Roots in ISIS: Police stand guard at Jewish school in Brussels following attack that left four dead.

Nemmouche became a radical jihadist while serving a sentence in France in 2009 for armed robbery, TF1 reported.

Pope Francis prays at the Western Wall accompanied by the Kotel Rav, Rabbi Shmuel Rabinovitz.

“Never again, Lord, never again,” the pope implored. “Here we are, Lord, shamed by what man, created in your own image and likeness, was capable of doing.”

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Abbas must choose between peace with Israel or Hamas.

“We stand at the gate of hell on earth,” MK Yariv Levin (Likud-Beiteinu) said. “The visit by a delegation of the parliament of an independent and strong Jewish state, together with survivors who were here, symbolizes Israel’s total commitment to the protection of the Jewish people.

Former Israeli prime minister Ariel Sharon was laid to rest Monday at his family’s ranch in southern Israel following a state funeral that drew international dignitaries – Vice President Biden represented the U.S. – and scores of Israeli officials.

“Today is a day of joy to our people, our families and our hero prisoners who’ve achieved freedom,” Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas declared Monday night as he personally greeted 18 terrorists released by Israel.

“They wanted ransom. They dropped him off in international waters in the Pacific, and now he is in an undisclosed location. But still a lot is unclear, and I’m still waiting to talk to my father.”

Israel’s peace talks with the Palestinians remain mostly shrouded in secrecy, but one thing is certain: The Palestinian prisoner release that paved the way for their resumption is increasing tensions in Israel’s governing coalition.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/us-news/ny/rabbi-broyde-admits-trabbi-broyde-admits-to-using-pseudonym-takes-leave-from-rca/2013/04/17/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: