web analytics
March 3, 2015 / 12 Adar , 5775
At a Glance
Sections
Sponsored Post


The Rebbe Looms Large

book-my-rebbe

My Rebbe (Maggid, 250 pages), the title of Rabbi Adin Steinsaltz’s new book, is an accurate description of the book’s subject matter. Unlike Samuel Heilman’s The Rebbe and Joseph Telushkin’s upcoming book Rebbe, much of Steinsaltz’s work is based on his own personal experiences, perceptions and interactions with the Lubavitcher Rebbe and the Chabad movement.

Steinsaltz, himself a great Talmudic sage, has been hailed by Time magazine as a “once-in-a-millennium scholar.” His new book covers a wide variety of topics including some of the fundamental beliefs of the Chabad chassid. Steinsaltz provides a brief history of Chabad and a biography of the Rebbe’s life and goes on to address the major events and controversies surrounding the Rebbe’s persona.

I was a little disappointed with some of the historical aspects of the book, specifically where he talks about the Rebbe’s early life in Paris and Berlin. There are no details of that phase of the Rebbe’s life that haven’t already been written about elsewhere. But more importantly, some of the information is inaccurate. Although Steinsaltz clearly recognizes that it is problematic to rely solely on internal testimony and sources, when he discusses this chapter of the Rebbe’s life he seems to have done just that.

“Paris and Berlin,” he writes, “were the centers of sophistication and advanced culture in those years. Rabbi Yosef Yitzchak wanted Menachem-Mendel to understand the wider world. The sixth Rebbe may have felt that a grasp of Western culture would help his son-in-law play a more public role within Chabad. As Jews were moving out of the Shtetl and acclimating themselves to city life, Rabbi Yosef Yitzchak saw that secular culture could equip Menachem Mendel to deal with this new breed of Jew. If Chabad was going to speak to the broader world, it would need leaders who could speak its language….

“Yet, during the years in Berlin and Paris, Menachem Mendel had no plans to become a leader within the Chabad movement. As close as he and his father in law were, there was a push-pull between them. As the sixth Rebbe was encouraging engagement with the Jewish community, the younger man sought to preserve his privacy.”

The differences between Menachem Mendel and Yosef Yitzchak were much greater than the above excerpt suggests. It is the accepted wisdom among those who were present at the time that the previous Rebbe opposed Menachem Mendel’s pursuit of secular studies in Berlin and Paris. There is ample testimony to prove that. Steinsaltz seems to jump to the contrary conclusion, yet it is unclear how he gets there. Perhaps this error reflects Steinsaltz’s personal dilemma, his own push-pull between these two worlds – his commitment to rabbinic studies and observant Judaism yet his deep love for culture, academia and scholarship. Steinsaltz acknowledged, in Newsweek in 1980, that he is “caught between two worlds” – the secular world of the West and the traditional Jewish world. “My duty,” he said, “is to combine the two.”

Later on in My Rebbe Steinsaltz writes that “loners like the Rebbe may be surrounded by others and even maintain lifelong friendships. Still, they do not seem to need many close friends to share confidences or to depend upon. They have a clear purpose, a consuming aim, an intense focus on work to be accomplished…. He had few if any intellectual peers.”

While this does seem to be an accurate description of the Rebbe, it is interesting that others have described Steinsaltz in similar terms. Here, too, I wonder whom Steinsaltz is really describing.

It is puzzling that Steinsaltz wrote that the Rebbe told someone that his work at the Brooklyn Navy Yard was “his way to thank the country that had saved him and to help with the war effort.” Besides the fact that the source of this quote is unreliable, this story is usually told by people who feel the need to defend the Rebbe’s choice of employment. There is no need to justify the Rebbe’s work at the Navy Yard. He did what needed to be done to make an honest living and support his wife.

About the Author: Rabbi Yaacov Behrman founded and currently serves as the executive director of The Jewish Future Alliance, an advocacy group. Behrman, a New York political activist and the former director of media relations for Chabad Lubavitch world headquarters, was ordained by the former Chief Rabbi of Israel, Rav Mordechai Eliyahu, in 2006 and received a master’s degree in Educational Leadership in 2009. The views expressed above are his own.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

No Responses to “The Rebbe Looms Large”

Comments are closed.

Current Top Story
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and many of the Bibicotters
Want to Tell the BibiCotters What You Think? Here’s How You Can.
Latest Sections Stories
Schonfeld-logo1

There is a point that many parenting books miss: children do more for us than we do for them.

Brigitte Gabriel

Brigitte was a nine-year-old girl when Islamic militants launched an assault on a Lebanese military base and destroyed her home.

Respler-022715

The husband needs to make some changes!

Purim is a fantastic time for fantasies, so I hope you won’t mind my fantasizing about how easy life would be if kids would prefer healthy cuisine over sweets. Imagine waking up to the call of “Mommy, when will my oatmeal be ready?”… As you rush to ladle out the hot unsweetened cereal, you rub […]

‘Double Gold’ awarded to 2012 Yarden Heights wine & 2011 Yarden Merlot Kela Single Vineyard.

One should not give the money before Purim morning or after sunset.

The mishloach manos of times gone by were sometimes simple and sometimes elaborate, but the main focus was on the preparation of the delicious food they contained.

One of the earliest special Purims we have on record was celebrated by the Jews of Granada and Shmuel HaNagid, the eleventh-century rav, poet, soldier and statesman, and one of the most influential Jews in Muslim Spain.

Jews, wake up! Stop educating the world and start educating yourselves.

The lessons conform to the sensitivities and needs of the Orthodox community…

The program took on special significance as it marked not only the first anniversary of Rebbetzin Kudan’s levayah but also the 27th yahrzeit of Rebbetzin Chaya Mushka Schneerson, a”h.

It was only in the reign of George III (1760-1820) that Jews became socially acceptable in Britain, and Nathan became music master to Princess Charlotte and musical librarian to King George IV.

It captures the love of the Jewish soul as only Shlomo Hamelech could portray it – and as only Rabbi Miller could explain it.

Erudite and academic, drawing from ancient and modern sources, the book can be discussed at the Shabbos table as well as in kollel.

More Articles from Yaacov Behrman
book-my-rebbe

Steinsaltz has an incredible ability to take lofty concepts and explain them in a way that an average layman can understand.

Rabbi Ezra Schochet

Rabbi Shmuley Boteach’s confrontation with a Lubavitch leader.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/sections/books/book-reviews/the-rebbe-looms-large/2014/05/22/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: