Moshe grabbed the ball from his cousin, Shlomo.
“Hey,” Shlomo said, “give it back.”
“No, I want it!” Moshe answered angrily.
“But, Moshe, I was playing with it. I’ll give you a turn in a minute.”
“I want it now.”
“Okay, you can have it now. But, can I have a turn later?”
“No. I want it all day.”
“Moshe, it’s not fair. I was playing with the ball.”
“Well, too bad.”
“Mommy,” Shlomo called to his mother, “I was playing with the ball and Moshe took it from me. Now, he won’t even let me have a turn.”
Moshe’s mother had been listening to the exchange and was hoping that this time, the boys would work it out among themselves. But, that did not seem to be happening. Slowly, she walked over to Moshe, “Moshe, you need to share the ball with Shlomo. If you don’t then you cannot hold onto it.”
Moshe just glared at his mother.
“Okay, Moshe, please hand me the ball.”
Moshe continued glaring.
“I’m going to take the ball from you now,” his mother said calmly.
After she took the ball and gave it to his cousin, five-year-old Moshe ran after his mother and hit her. His mother was at her wits end. She could put Moshe in time out, but that hadn’t worked before. She could create a positive reinforcement chart, but once in the moment, it was unlikely to help. What were her options in terms of discipline?
Time Out As A Disciplinary Tactic
While there have been negative press surrounding the use of time outs, many psychologists and educators believe that when used correctly, it can be effective and valuable. According to psychologist Daniela Owen at the San Francisco Bay Center for Cognitive Therapy, time outs increases compliance and positive behavior far more than other forms of discipline. Here are some guidelines to use.
- Separate. When negative behavior occurs, the parent should take the child way from the situation and place him or her in a separate area. This area need not be in another room.
- Explain. In as few words as possible, explain what the child did to earn the time out. For instance, Moshe’s mother might say, “No hitting” or “Don’t hit.”
- Set a time. A reasonable amount of time is the child’s age in minutes. For example, if the child is three, time out should be three minutes.
- Don’t attend. Once the child is in time out, the parent should avoid eye contact and not speak to the child. Time out is time out from the parents and the rest of the action happening in the house.
- Embrace. When time out is over, “time in” begins. Parents should hug their child and let him or her feel their love.
- Discuss. Later that evening parents can discuss with the child the events that led up to the time out. This will allow everybody to rationally and calmly evaluate how to better proceed in the future.
Errors While Enforcing Time Out
Little time in. In order for time out to work, there has to be a lot of “time in” in the family. In other words, you need to create a positive and rich environment for children in your home so that the time out is simply a “time out” from all the exciting things that are going on around them. Otherwise, children will choose to misbehave in order to get any attention from their parents.
Lots of threats. Many parents I work with often threaten their children with time out, but do not enforce it. This will undermine the whole idea and empty threats do not breed positive behavior.
Too much talk. When putting children in time out, parents often (because they are so agitated) go through lengthy explanations for the reason. For instance, a parent might say, “Moshe, you are going to time out because you grabbed the ball and you wouldn’t listen to Mommy and then you hit Mommy. You have to have time out when you do things like that.”
When a child is in the midst of a fit, he will not be able to attend to that kind of speech, plus that defeats the purpose of a “time out” from attention. Therefore, stick to as few words as possible.
No real time out. When children act out while placed in time out, parents often respond to them. If they are yelling, they tell them to be quiet and if they are laughing they tell them to be quiet. Instead, simply ignore their responses as long as they are in time out. Time out should simply be a time out from all responses.
Oppositional Defiant Disorder
There is always the chance that parents are disciplining exactly the way that they should and their children are simply not discontinuing their negative behavior. In some cases, it is worthwhile to look into Oppositional Defiant Disorder (ODD). Children with ODD, sometimes called “explosive,” erupt in outbursts or verbal or physical aggression, which includes kicking, screaming, or tantrums, when certain things don’t go their way. They are inflexible and have extremely low tolerance for frustration. They are very difficult to live with. Things can really get ugly.
According to Dr. Ross Greene, the author of Explosive Children, “These children have wonderful qualities and tremendous potential. Yet their inflexibility often obscures their more positive traits and causes them and those around them enormous pain. There is no other group of children who are so misunderstood.”
The important thing to consider is that these children can’t help themselves. Just like a child with a reading difficulty cannot help himself. Just like a child who is born with a disability cannot help herself. Explosive children are simply delayed in their ability to process the skills necessary for flexibility and frustration tolerance. They’re not doing it for attention or so that they can get even with you. They’re doing it because they can’t handle conflict or disappointment any other way.
For children who have ODD, Dr. Greene suggests a tactic called Plan B. But, that’s a topic for another article!Rifka Schonfeld
About the Author: An acclaimed educator and social skills specialist, Mrs. Rifka Schonfeld has served the Jewish community for close to thirty years. She founded and directs the widely acclaimed educational program, SOS, servicing all grade levels in secular as well as Hebrew studies. A kriah and reading specialist, she has given dynamic workshops and has set up reading labs in many schools. In addition, she offers evaluations G.E.D. preparation, social skills training and shidduch coaching, focusing on building self-esteem and self-awareness. She can be reached at 718-382-5437 or at firstname.lastname@example.org.
If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.
Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.
If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.