Last week, I started providing feedback on how to visit the sick or chronically ill. I have based these suggestions on interviews with those who are sick and their well-spouses. The first thing I was told was that people should keep their visits short. However, it is important to remember that this suggestion and the ones that follow, are feelings of the people I interviewed and do not apply to everyone in every case. Each situation must be looked at on an individual basis.
If a person has no visitors or is in a nursing home, a longer visit might be much more appropriate than a shorter one. If you have a special talent and/or are a confidant of the sick person, and he specifically wants to talk or ask your help, a short visit may not make sense. As always, these general guidelines, suggested by those I interviewed, must always be adjusted to the needs of the person we wish to help. But, we must remember, it is that person’s needs we are considering, not our own. Take your cue from whom you are visiting, whether silent or verbal, and you will know how long to keep your visit.
The second guideline that was mentioned repeatedly was not to ask personal questions or questions about a trauma that has just occurred. After an operation or even a minor procedure, people can be embarrassed to discuss their condition. Beyond “How are you feeling?” you may be heading into painful waters. Asking about a prognosis, or what the disease will mean for them over time, will probably be something a person does not want to discuss with you. This is especially true if they have just gotten bad news themselves and haven’t had time to digest it. If it is something they want to talk to you about, they will bring up the topic themselves. None of us would ask straight out “So how long do you have to live?” or “Will you ever be able to have children again?” or “Are you going to be able to walk?” Yet, that is exactly what we are doing when we start asking about what they have just gone through.
Menachem had been in a terrible accident. Many of the people in the accident had died. He had been injured, but thank G-d, his injuries would heal. He had difficulty sleeping. The question of why he had survived while others had not plagued him. He could not talk about the horror of the accident without reliving the trauma. Despite this, his visitors kept asking him questions about it. Specific questions. Menachem did not know how to handle the questions. He felt awkward saying he couldn’t speak about it. Besides, just hearing the question took him to a place in his mind, to which he could not go. The question itself did the damage. And, he told me, people kept asking, even after he tried to change the subject.
Those who survive when others have perished, whether from an accident, an illness or any disaster, often have difficulty coping with their survival. What did it mean that G-d had spared them? They often feel an overwhelming sense of responsibility to use their life somewhat differently, but are not sure just how. It does not help to remind them of this.
The people I interviewed in this situation told me that by others asking how they were going to live their lives differently now, or what they felt their responsibility of having survived meant to them, or just reminding them they owed G-d thanks − made them feel terrible. It was not that these thoughts hadn’t occurred to them. In fact, these thoughts rarely left their consciousness. Others bringing it up just made them feel guilty for their survival.
To summarize then, our first two rules of visitation as told to me by patients are: keep the visits short, and don’t ask questions about what they’ve just gone through, beyond a general “How are you doing?” Next week I’ll discuss the third rule, which is to avoid visitation in groups.
You can reach me at email@example.com
Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/sections/magazine/some-guidelines-for-visitation-part-2/2006/12/13/
Scan this QR code to visit this page online: