Have you ever stood dominoes up in a row about an inch apart and then tipped the first one over? It’s fun to watch as the first domino hits the second, the second the third, and in a matter of seconds, each domino is down, having been hit by the one behind it. It is only if someone starts the dominoes falling at the other end of the line, in the opposite direction, that the dominoes stop somewhere in the middle.
It is the same way with things we are led to believe, assumptions we make that we haven’t thought through. Somewhere we have heard something, and accepted it as truth. We pass it on with assurance and, like the dominos, it travels from one person to the next unquestioned.
Silence is assent. Our silence means we agree with what is being said. Whether it is a racist joke, gossip, or just someone’s point of view. If we are silent, the speaker will assume that we agree with him and is encouraged to continue both his belief in what he has said and his appropriateness to spout it as “truth”. Like the dominos, the opinion is passed on from one person to the next. It continues until someone disagrees, presents an opposite view, and makes the speaker reevaluate his assumptions.
This was brought home to me just recently as I heard one of my neighbors complain to another about the noisy celebration across the street that had kept her up all night. The second neighbor listened sympathetically, began agreeing with her, sympathizing with the inconsiderateness, and taking on some of her anger.
Then a third neighbor passed by, joined the conversation and said, “Was there a party? I didn’t hear anything.”
I suddenly realized that I hadn’t heard anything either, and began to wonder what had really happened. Had a very noisy party really taken place? Were the facts faithfully presented? And yet, here we were sympathetic and at least one of us in agreement without any idea of what was real. I was embarrassed, not because I had taken part in the discussion, but because of my silence.
This phenomenon also applies to ideas about how to treat a well spouse. People who have no experience with the situation will tell you how often you should visit your ill spouse, what you should say, how you should act, and pass this information on to other people without experience. This goes on in a domino effect. It is only when someone challenges what is being said that the falling dominos are halted.
Rochel was chatting with a group of women when the conversation turned to someone in their community who was chronically ill and in a nursing facility. All the women felt badly for this person’s situation and one woman stated how unfortunate it was that the well spouse only visited three times a week instead of every day.
The other women readily agreed and like dominoes, each internalized what was the “right” amount of times one should visit a chronically ill spouse in a nursing home.
It wasn’t until Rochel challenged them that the dominoes stopped falling. Rochel told them that her father had been in a nursing home, and how hard it had been for her to visit. She was younger at the time, and did not have pressing responsibilities, but visiting more than twice a week left her depressed to the point of being incapacitated. How much worse it must be, she felt, when it is your spouse in the nursing home and you have a family to care for as well.
Rochel thought that visiting twice or three times a week was wonderful. She didn’t think she would be able to do this in the same situation. Suddenly the dominoes began to fall the other way. The women had gained new insight – insight based on real experience.
They began to see the three visits a week as a positive act instead of a negative one. Now, whenever the topic came up, they supported the spouse, encouraged her to visit only when she felt capable of doing so, and passed that message on to anyone with an opinion on visitation. And so, the dominoes fell the other way, for the good.
We all take part in conversations. We all spout ideas that we feel are correct, though chances are we may never have even thought them through. Perhaps we should challenge these ideas so that the dominoes can stop falling, or perhaps proceed the other way, based on knowledge and information.
Most of all, remember that we don’t need to participate in a conversation to be part of what is going on. Our silence gives agreement and approval to whatever is being said, whether we actually agree or not.
About the Author:
If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.
Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.
If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.