web analytics
July 2, 2015 / 15 Tammuz, 5775
At a Glance
Uncategorized
Sponsored Post


Home » Uncategorized

‘Things Once Taken For Granted Are Now Considered Unacceptable’


Marc B. Shapiro, a Judaic Studies professor at the University of Scranton, is a mine of information and a lightning rod for controversy.

A summa cum laude graduate from Brandeis University and the last person to receive a Ph.D. from the late Harvard Judaic Studies Professor Isadore Twersky (son-in-law of Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik), Shapiro has authored and edited five books and more than 80 articles and book reviews.

His Between the Yeshiva World and Modern Orthodoxy: The Life and Works of Rabbi Jehiel Jacob Weinberg, 1884-1966 and The Limits of Orthodox Theology: Maimonides’ Thirteen Principles Reappraised were both National Jewish Book Award finalists.

The Jewish Press recently spoke with Shapiro about his writings and his views on the Orthodox community.

The Jewish Press: In your opinion, what would Rabbi Weinberg, author of the Seridei Eish and the subject of your first book, think of the Orthodox Jewish community today?

Shapiro: He’d think what a lot of gedolim would think from that generation. They would be very surprised that things they took for granted are now considered unacceptable – that the yeshiva world today in Israel, for example, sees something wrong with earning a living.

I think the frumkeit would surprise them. For example, the turn to glatt kosher as a standard, as well as the number of chumrot. This would surprise them only because part of traditional Judaism is reliance on the gedolim of the past and it’s very unusual for a tradition that regards itself as following the past to reject what previous standards were.

You write that Rabbi Weinberg didn’t support the Agudah. Why was that? First of all, there are two types of Agudah. There used to be such a thing as a German Agudah, Torah im Derech Eretz. That has been totally demolished. But fundamentally, if you think about the post-World War II Agudah, Rabbi Weinberg was a Zionist and they weren’t.

Also, he believed in autonomy. He couldn’t tolerate the use of the cherem and the lack of ability to think for yourself.

Rabbi Weinberg wrote, “For the members of Agudah, every unimportant rabbi who joins them is considered a great gaon.” Can you elaborate? Rabbi Weinberg wrote in his private letters that politics in Agudah circles is what makes you a gadol; it’s not how much Torah you have. They determine that Rav Soloveitchik is not a gadol because he’s not in their circle. Rav Elyashiv was never considered a gadol when he was with the [Israeli government] rabbanut.

You have written that at one point you wanted to write a biography of Rabbi Chaim Hirschenson (a posek and rav in Hoboken, N.J., in the early half of the 20th century). Why do you find him such an interesting character? Rabbi Hirschenson believed there has to be – they didn’t have this term then but it certainly is adequate – a Modern Orthodox approach to halacha. He believed in updating halacha, all within the halachic system.

For example, now it seems almost quaint, but in his day pretty much all the gedolim believed that women couldn’t vote and they all – basically all – believed that women couldn’t be elected. He argued against this.

He showed how the Torah is not opposed to democracy. He spoke about issues of biblical criticism, how to deal with that. His sefer, Malki Bakodesh, deals with all the issues of how to run a country in modern times according to Jewish law. He was the first one to put this on the table. He said we’re going to have a state one day and we’re going to need to run it according to Torah law. Can Torah law work in a modern state and what do we have to do to make it work?

About the Author: Marc Gottlieb is the webmaster for JewishPress.com. Marc has been crafting end-to-end online solutions for all sizes and types of businesses since 1995. You can see more samples of his work at http://www.marcgottlieb.com.   He made aliyah in 2006 with his wife and four children. They live in Gush Etzion with two cats and a hamster.   Marc's political comments are entirely his own and do not reflect the opinions of JewishPress.com.  


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

No Responses to “‘Things Once Taken For Granted Are Now Considered Unacceptable’”

Comments are closed.

Current Top Story
ISIS leads captured Egyptian Copts in death march.
Analysis: ISIS Will Go Down to Defeat in Egypt
Latest Uncategorized Stories

Can adoption agencies limit the placement of children to heterosexual couples only?

A wounded Israeli victim of a drive-by shooting terror attack near Shvut Rachel is brought to the Shaarei Tzedek hospital in Jerusalem.

The father of a critically injured victim of Monday’s road terror attack in Binyamin asks people to pray for his son.

South-Florida-logo

The bat mitzvah celebration was attended by 300 people, including many family members who flew in from out-of-town locations, several from overseas.

El Al plane touches down at Ben Gurion Airport runway.

Italy’s busiest airport is about to slow down to 60 percent capacity, for repairs.

Young man makes Aliyah and enlists in IDF, something his deceased father desperately wanted.

Leading Palestinian faction Fatah firms its ties with Syria’s goverment regime after a 32-year hiatus.

The number of Syrian refugee schoolchildren is going to outstrip the number of Lebanese students, a UN envoy warns.

“But we are working consistently to fight against that,” she said. “We have allies in that effort.”

We have to respect religion. We have to respect people’s freedom of religion; it’s one of the guarantees in our Bill of Rights.

Several thousand Eastern European Jews had escaped Nazi death and Soviet persecution by fleeing to Shanghai, China.

Lauder: ‘Jews demanded no ‘Right of Return’ to Germany or Austria or Poland or any other European country.’

Seeing and hearing the anguish of Gabriel Sassoon, I am reminded of Otto Frank, Anne Frank’s father.

An IDF officer on the Golan Heights was lightly wounded Tuesday evening by gunfire from Syria. The officer, from the Engineering Corp, was hit by shrapnel from where the bullet hit nearby. He was treated on site. The gunfire came from an area controlled by Assad’s troops.

An open miracle occurred before our very eyes… the scheduled demonstration turned into a resounding celebration.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu hammered away at the Iranian nuclear threat at a meeting with visiting Republican Congressmen Robert Pittenger of North Carolina and Dennis A. Ross of Florida Tuesday morning. “The American-Israeli alliance is a powerful one. It’s based on common values, common interests. It’s a bipartisan relationship, Netanyahu said. He added, “We appreciate […]

More Articles from Marc Gottlieb

It is up to our government to ensure that their sacrifices were not made for short-term gains.

Ceasefire

Deja Vu. We will start this ceasefire by ignoring the rockets that continue to fall around us, until once again, we can’t ignore them any longer.

If you look like someone they wouldn’t invite into their home, they won’t invite you into their car.

In the online world of split-second decision making, having the right theme for your website may mean the difference between engaging a customer or losing the sale.

Make your website festive for the holidays with some simple graphic enhancements.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/uncategorized/things-once-taken-for-granted-are-now-considered-unacceptable/2007/04/25/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: