Photo Credit:
Richard Cravatts

As an example of what the insightful commentator Melanie Phillips referred to as a “dialogue of the demented” in her book The World Turned Upside Down, Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas is continuing a long tradition of attempting to de-Judaize Jerusalem by expressing his mendacious notion that, as he put it, “Jerusalem has a special flavor and taste not only in our hearts, but also in the hearts of all Arabs and Muslims and Christians” and “Jerusalem is the eternal capital of the Palestinian state and without it there will be no state.”

The same scholar of history who wrote a doctoral dissertation that questioned the extent and truthfulness of the Holocaust was now making his own historical claim that there had never been a Jewish presence and history in the world’s holiest city.


In recent weeks Abbas has been at it again, adding new layers of rhetoric to his tactical campaign to de-Judaize Jerusalem in general and the Temple Mount in particular. In an October PA TV broadcast, Abbas made the breathtakingly absurd claim that Jews not only had no historic claim to the Temple Mount, but that they also should never even be allowed to have their presence known at that location.

Only in an alternate, Orwellian universe could one group of people on earth – Jews – be enjoined from praying on the single site most holy to their faith, and, moreover, be told their presence there is not only provocative but repugnant and befouls the very ground on which those of another faith – Islam – have staked a triumphalist religious claim.

This attempt to airbrush out a Jewish presence from Jerusalem – in fact, all of historical Palestine – is not a new message for Abbas. In 2000 he expressed similar contempt for the idea that a Jewish Temple had ever existed on the Temple Mount and that, even if it had existed, the offenses committed by Israel against the Palestinians negated any claim Jews might have enjoyed, absent their perfidy.

Judging by the October 30statement by U.S. State Department spokesperson Jen Psaki, forgetting the past is something in which the John Kerry’s office is also complicit. “We’re extremely concerned by escalating tensions across Jerusalem and particularly surrounding the Haram al-Sharif, Temple Mount,” Psaki said, referring to the Temple Mount by its Arab name first and thereby fortifying, and seeming to lend equal weight to, the Palestinians’ spurious claim to spiritual and territorial rights to the site, and to the wider area described now as East Jerusalem.

But in characterizing East Jerusalem – or any part of Jerusalem, for that matter – as territory that Israel “occupies” but over which it enjoys no sovereignty, Abbas and the State Department are misreading, once again, the content and purpose of 1967’s UN Security Council Resolution 242 that suggested Israel’s withdrawal “from territories” (not all territories) it won in the Six-Day War.

Critics of Israeli policy who either willfully misread or deliberately obscure the resolution’s purpose say Israel is in violation of 242 by continuing to occupy the West Bank and Jerusalem, including what is spuriously now referred to as “Arab” East Jerusalem. But the drafters of Resolution 242 were very precise in creating the statute’s language, and they never considered Jerusalem to have been occupied by Israel after the Six-Day War.

The true danger of what Palestinians think about Jerusalem – and, indeed, about all of the Palestine they covet, including Israel itself – was revealed in Yasir Arafat’s own words, expressed back in July 2000 in the newspaper al-Hayat al-Jadida, when he threatened: “They can occupy us by force, because we are weaker now, but in two years, ten years, or one hundred years, there will be someone who will liberate Jerusalem [from them].”


Previous articleJews Have A Long Memory
Next articleThe PR Maven Who Helped Rescue The Bergson Group From Obscurity
Richard L. Cravatts, Ph.D., is president emeritus of Scholars for Peace in the Middle East, and the author of “Dispatches From the Campus War Against Israel and Jews.”


  1. In all seriousness, Abbas can talk until he is blue in the face, and he will still fail to Dr-Judaize Jerusalem. Jerusalem and the people of Judah and David have been inextricably linked for several millennia. No trumped-up thug dressed up in a suit, no matter how persuasive can change that fact even one iota.

  2. “Jerusalem is the eternal capital of the Palestinian state and without it there will be no state.” In this case, I believe that there will never be a "Palastinian State." If they want it at the cost of splitting Jerusalem, and denying that it was the heart of Judaism from the time King David conquered the Jebusite city, then, I believe, the G-d of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob will take Abbas at his word, and no Palastinian State will come into existence.

    The judgement of King Solomon between the two mothers who claimed the same child is relevant here. THE ONE WHO DID NOT WANT TO CUT THE CHILD IN TWO LOVED THE CHILD. The Jewish State is prepared to SHARE Jerusalem with the world, and Tnach declares that Jerusalem will be a light to the nations. HE will ensure that Jerusalem is not divided. Yes, the UN, or the nations united, will come against Jerusalem one day. But they will trigger the wrath of the living G-d. I know whose side I'd rather be on. I look forward to the day of His coming; though I dread the conflict until that date. But Jerusalem does not belong to Man. It is the city of the Living G=d.

  3. We must pray for the Peace of Jerusalem and the safety of the Jews, the People of the Book. Isaiah says "the government shall be upon His shoulders" as any Christian who reads "the Book" will understand what this is all about in these perilous days.

  4. There are 300,000 Arab residents of Jerusalem who are not citizens but receive Israel benefits, and consider themselves Palestinians Arabs. They have been squatting and building and stealing and assaulting for decades, and there is a sharp rise in these assaults as the second and third generation are trained and cultivated to throw rocks and worse at Israeli police and civilians and schools etc. These people need to be trucked over to the Gaza fence and pitched over it.

Comments are closed.

Loading Facebook Comments ...