Due to unavoidable circum-stances at deadline time, the Monitor turns the stage over this week to highlights of HonestReporting.com’s analysis of the early media reaction to the killing by Israel of Hamas founder Sheikh Ahmed Yassin:
MYTH 1: The Yassin strike will escalate the violence.
Nearly all news reports claimed within the first two sentences that the IDF strike is “likely to escalate violence,” and constitutes “an enormous gamble by Sharon” that “risks triggering a dramatic escalation in bloodshed.”
This claim – which belongs on the editorial page, not in the same breath as the actual news report of the event – was so widespread that one almost forgets that it represents only the Palestinian position: The official PA statement characterized the Israeli strike as inviting “more violence and further escalation.”
The absent Israeli position: Though terrorist efforts may increase temporarily, in the long run the elimination of Yassin will upset Hamas’ leadership and violent capabilities, and serve as an essential deterrent to ongoing Palestinian terror. Responsible news reports should either convey both positions, or neither.
MYTH 2: Yassin was an impotent old man
The BBC profiled Yassin as “a frail man who could barely see. His voice was thin and quavering.” The (London) Evening Standard prominently quoted the UK Foreign Secretary, who said “he did not believe that Israel would benefit from the killing of an old man in a wheelchair.” Actually, Yassin was in a wheelchair since age 12, when a sporting accident left him paralyzed. It’s self- evident, therefore, that being wheelchair-bound never hampered Yassin’s ability to orchestrate unprecedented terror – he founded Hamas in 1987 and proved perfectly capable of building the organization to its current strength from a sitting position.
Moreover, Yassin has had enough wherewithal in the recent years to direct dozens of heinous terrorist attacks, leaving Yassin’s hands drenched in Israeli blood.
MYTH 3: Yassin was a “spiritual leader” who deserved immunity.
AFP, like most agencies, described Yassin as “the Islamist movement’s spiritual guide,” which suggests to a western audience that Yassin operated in a peaceful, contemplative realm aside from the violence, and was therefore unfairly targeted by the IDF. BBC went so far to say Yassin was “a powerful inspiration for young Palestinians disillusioned with the collapse of peace hopes.” CNN calls Yassin a spiritual leader (unquoted), but then puts scare quotes around Israel’s reference to him as a “terrorist.”
Actually, Yassin’s brand of “spirituality” is the very ideological and emotional fuel that drives Palestinian (and worldwide Islamic) terrorism, the plague of our age. Yassin continually called for suicide terrorism as a religious obligation, and even said about himself that “the day in which I will die as a shahid [martyr] will be the happiest day of my life.”
MYTH 4: Israel’s strike creates a western threat of Islamic terror.
After Hamas released a statement that threatened radical Islamic retaliation beyond Israel’s borders, AP called this an “unprecedented threat,” triggered by Israel: “For the first time, Hamas also threatened the United States, saying America’s backing of Israel made the assassination possible… In the past, Hamas leaders have insisted their struggle is against Israel and that they would not get involved in causes by militant Muslims in other parts of the world. Today’s statement suggested that Hamas might seek outside help in carrying out revenge attacks, since its capabilities have been limited by Israeli military strikes.”
This is simply untrue – Yassin himself had long called upon world Islamic terrorists to join with Hamas in global jihad. MEMRI reported in March, 2003 that on the Hamas website, “Sheikh Ahmad Yassin called on the Islamic nation “to strike at Western interests everywhere if Iraq is conquered.” ” And just two weeks ago, Hamas announced its commitment to “the global level of the Islamic world” as the reason for its choosing British suicide bombers to murder Israelis at Tel Aviv’s Mike’s Place in 2003.