In one corner, the proponents include advocacy groups such as Agudath Israel of America, the Orthodox Union, Jewish Federation, Coalition for Opportunity in Education, the New York State Catholic Conference, and StudentsFirstNY. From the government side, supporting the measure are Senate Republicans and some Democrats, Assembly Republicans with a significant portion of Assembly Democrats, and Cuomo.
In the other corner, opponents include lobby groups such as the New York State United Teachers, United Federation of Teachers, Reform Jewish Voices, Citizen Action of New York, League of Women Voters, Strong Economy for All, and the union-backed Alliance for Quality Education. Most Senate Democrats and a strong contingent of key Assembly Democrats also oppose any money going for anything other than public education.
“We’re in the days of very tight finances in all different types of schools,” said Senator George Latimer (D – Rye, Westchester County) ranking Democrat on the Senate Education Committee. “I see the need for robust public education and a robust private education. I do not think it’s an either-or situation. The people who choose one or the other I think are selling short the mix that’s out there.”
If this convoluted plan passes, it will be the miracle of the session and everyone will be looking to claim credit for doing his or her part in making this happen – even the opponents. That’s just how the political system works.
For a quick primer about the specifics of the governor’s bill go to: www.investined.org/about-the-bill/.