Photo Credit: Flash90
Meir Ettinger

{Originally posted to the author’s website, Israel Thrives}

Writing in Israel National News, Shlomo Pyotrkovsky tells us:

Be’er Sheva district court judge Yisrael Pablo Axelrod on Sunday rejected the petition to release Meir Ettinger from his administrative detention for several hours on Monday so as to attend the brit milah (circumcision) of his firstborn son.

Ettinger has been held for the past eight months without trial or charges against him on administrative orders, a relic from the British Mandate which has almost exclusively been used against Arab terror suspects.


Meir Ettinger is the grandson of the much despised Meir Kahane… who many Jews confuse with the Devil. Kahane’s Kach Party was, in the late 1980s, deemed a racist political party and the government barred members from running for the Knesset.

Ettinger is what is commonly referred to as a “Hilltop Youth.” That is, he is among the generation of young Israelis who believe strongly for religious reasons in the connection of the Jewish people to our traditional homeland and are willing to risk the unhappiness of the government by settling non-annexed outposts in Judea and Samaria beyond that Holy of Holies, the “green line.”

I am the kind of guy who is often accused of thinking that Israel can do no wrong. In fact, I have plenty of criticisms concerning Israel and the fact that they are holding people in prison without charge is one of them.

I don’t care if the person is an Arab or a Muslim or a Jew or a Rosicrucion, it is a violation of the most fundamental premises of the political Enlightenment for a government to detain anyone for an extended period of time without charges being brought against the person.

This is a little thing that we in the West like to refer to as Habeas Corpus.

There is no right derived from the European liberal tradition more basic than the right to not be thrown into the clink without charges being raised, without access to an attorney of law, and without being allowed to face one’s accuser.

Perhaps I am just biased towards the Constitution of the United States and its fourth amendment within the Bill of Rights that guarantees that the “right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated…”

In other words, it is against the law in the United States to throw anyone in prison without due process and due process requires a trial by jury.

There are certain things that anger me about Israel, such as its policies in regard the Temple Mount, but this issue is something that I can agree upon with the most virulent demonizers of Israel.

It violates basic standards of human decency to hold people without charge for months on end. It is simply wrong and, to the extent that people are held in detention within Israel without access to a fair trial, the practice must end.

It may have been a story around Meir Ettinger that caught my eye, but the fundamental principle of a right of trial by jury needs to be extended to every citizen of the State of Israel no matter what their ideological beliefs.

Pyotrkovsky writes:

Ettinger is being imprisoned in extreme conditions of solitary confinement and is not being allowed any phone calls except to several close family members, even though there has been no evidence or indictment presented against him for any crime.

I would not care if this guy was the grandson of Yassir Arafat, this is unacceptable.


Previous articleA Soldier’s Mother: But I Don’t Want to Go to War
Next articleTerrorist’s Family Builds Villa with Donations after IDF Demolishes their Home
Michael Lumish is a PhD in American history from the Pennsylvania State University and has taught at PSU, San Francisco State University, and the City College of San Francisco. He regularly publishes on the Arab-Israel conflict at his own blog, Israel Thrives ( Lumish is also the founding editor of the scholarly on-line discussion forum H-1960s. He can be contacted at


  1. Who are you to say Kahane is despised, as if to say all of Israel despise him, there are many many followers and whether you despise him or not he said many things that came true. The comparisons to Arafat were disgraceful. Administrative detention is a valid weapon to our enemies but not to our bretheren, by the looks of the article you are severely confused on who is your brethren and who is your enemy. It is precisely your type of thinking that endangers us, you want him free and you want terrorists or their supporters free, no one gets administrative detention without a reason, and they wont tell you exactly what reason. The issue here is it who is a friend.d and who is an enemy. The government that calls Abbas a friend, arrests a soldier that killed a terrorist and tries him as a murderer is an unfit government and we must vote them out. They are a disease to the fighting spirit of our nation, and yes we still have to fight to survive. Ot is the same problem, your ideas, the unfit government, the admistrative detention to those who want to fight the enemy not give them our land and our jobs. You see settlers as subhuman, as equal to the Arafats. Trust me you do more damage to Israel with your ideas than you could fathom. Next time speak for yourself about your own hate of fellow Jews and leave me and the rest of Am Yisrael out of your circle of hate.

  2. The elected officials use of a district judge to usurp power of individual rights is a blatant act of rebellion against the will of the people. Its no wonder that the whole judicial system is in decline including the Supreme Court.

  3. "The reality is that the leaders of Israel are frightened of the reality. Despite deception and deviousness they – because of lack of faith – have no policy and in their hearts is only the hope of muddling through and gaining time until they have finished their sojourn. Then:Apres moi…"
    This is part of a passage written by Meir's Grandfather – with this situation today, I am loath to repeat it but it is with deep disappointment that it should be brought to light as the pitiful act of incarcerating Meir Ettinger must be adding fuel to a world-wide distortion of how Israel and its government play its part in appropriate justice.

  4. We need to raise awareness of Meir Ettinger's situation and get him out of this Administrative detention at once. Whatever it takes to release our brother. In the merit of Rosh Chodesh Nisan lets get started to crying out for our brother whose freedom is being suppressed by the Israeli Government.

Comments are closed.

Loading Facebook Comments ...