The Kotel Hakatan is the “little sister” of the well-known Western Wall, and is reminiscent of the photos and drawings of the way the Kotel looked before 1948. It is located 200 yards further north of the Kotel, and is on the same level as Har HaBayit (the Temple Mount). Since its plaza is much narrower, and the majority of the wall is underground (thereby concealing much of its height), the Small Wall is less impressive than the Western Wall.
The remaining Western Wall of Har HaBayit is intact for its entire length, but almost the entire wall is covered by Mameluke and Ottoman Turkish period housing, which use the wall as support. If one goes into the Kotel Tunnels, one can follow the Western Wall till its north-western corner. The area of the Kotel Hakatan is a tiny, barely-10-meters-long, exposed (i.e., with no houses covering it) section of the retaining Western Wall, within the Muslim Quarter. However, there are Arab homes adjacent to it and it serves, to our great consternation, as a wall of these people’s dwelling places.
There are two small courtyards at the plaza. For generations the elders of Yerushalayim used to come here to recite Tikkun Chatzos. A small enclosed structure there marks the spot in which, a few generations ago, the prophet Eliyahu appeared to one of Yerushalayim’s rabbanim. Others claim that the Divine Presence itself appeared here to Harav Avraham HaLevi Beruchim, a talmid of the Arizal. The structure consequently became a place to daven in. It was later desecrated by Arab residents of the courtyard who used it as a bathroom.
Kotleinu (“Our Wall”), the informal committee run primarily by Old City residents, has been working to promote and improve conditions at the Kotel Hakatan. The condition of the wall is very bad, and Arab children scramble and climb over it all the time
When for the first time in 40 years — in January of 2011 — restoration work was done, it was hoped that improvements would include restoration of the crumbling stones, a new floor, drainage, and wheelchair accessibility. It was thought that a solution, possibly in the form of benches or a mechitzah demarcating a corridor for the Arab residents to pass through, would be set up.
However, all that was done was to add a street sign identifying the location as the Small Wailing Wall, in English and Hebrew, and to remove part of the cluster of useless building-supports from the far end of the plaza. The supports had been there for years and did not allow access to the entire length of the wall. The Arab residents who live in the adjoining building used to throw their garbage in the area under the props. The decades-old scaffolding had been put up to support an arch that was to support the house next to it while it (the arch) was being built. Once the arch was up and dry, the prop was superfluous.
Despite the fact that the props were actually useless for almost 40 years and did not support the building, at least one Arab newspaper condemned their removal and blamed “Jewish extremist worshipers” for an action that was liable to cause the building to collapse.
In 1972, Harav Meir Yehuda Getz, zt”l, the Rav of the Kotel, was in the lower level of the Kotel Hakatan area, as the digging of the Tunnels was taking place. He heard very loud knocking coming from above. To his horror, he found city workers driving beams directly into the Wall in order to support the condemned Arab house that had become unstable, either due to the dig or because of water gathered below it.
Mayor Teddy Kollek had decided that this house had to be saved, no matter what. (This, as opposed to the buildings adjoining the Kotel, which were razed immediately after the Six Day War.) Teddy put the families up in hotels, and the contractors he brought in simply drove a network of props and supports, that resembled a jungle-gym, into the Wall.
There was an outcry throughout the country. Even the Waqf protested this desecration. Thus, the Small Wall was saved. A “funeral” was held for the sacred stones and fragments that had been destroyed in the process of putting up the beams.
Isolated incidents have occurred over the years between those praying at the Kotel Hakatan and the Muslim residents of the courtyard. An apartment in the courtyard, which belonged to a member of a Palestinian terror organization, was confiscated in the 1970s by the Israeli government because of terrorist activity. Another building, on the corner of Chaggai and Shaar Habarzel Street was confiscated at the same time for the same reason. Later, in 1999, the government decided to establish a police station there.