web analytics
October 20, 2014 / 26 Tishri, 5775
At a Glance
InDepth
Sponsored Post
Meir Panim with Soldiers 5774 Roundup: Year of Relief and Service for Israel’s Needy

Meir Panim implements programs that serve Israel’s neediest populations with respect and dignity. Meir Panim also coordinated care packages for families in the South during the Gaza War.



Home » InDepth » Op-Eds »

Religious Women Should Consider the Draft – They Aren’t So Fragile

Israeli female Border Police soldiers lighting Chanukah candles. There is no reason why religious women not consider military service, although they might do better to avoid combat roles in mixed units.

Israeli female Border Police soldiers lighting Chanukah candles. There is no reason why religious women not consider military service, although they might do better to avoid combat roles in mixed units.
Photo Credit: Nati Shohat/FLASH90

“It can’t be right,” my wife told me. “It’s what they recited to us a thousand times in the seminary.”

“But it’s a fact,” I insisted. “There is no Jewish law that compels a grown woman to live either under the rule of her father or her husband. It’s an invention of seminary deans, to convince women not to enlist in the army.”

My wife still refused to believe that her teachers had cheated her. “Go ask Rav Y.,” she requested, “maybe you missed that item in the Shulchan Aruch.”

Rav Y. squirmed, but he had to admit: there is no such law.

There are other halachic arguments against women’s military service, but I don’t buy any of them. My colleague Racheli Malek Buda asked a week ago why the rabbis are stuttering on this issue. So here’s a clear statement: unlike the impression the rabbis may be trying to create, this is an educational rather than halachic issue. The objection to women serving in the army is legitimate, but it’s preferable that a seminary teacher who feels that way would tell his students the truth: there is no halachic prohibition, but I fear that they would be spoiled serving in the army.

Why aren’t teachers expressing themselves this way? Because they’re afraid that if the reasons are educational rather than halachic then there should be a distinction between different women and different army jobs. That’s what they’re worried about, and they shouldn’t be.

I don’t support the attack on the Chief Rabbinate Council for announcing that women are not allowed to enlist. It’s the right of the rabbis to express their opinion. But it would have been proper to explain this view and to clarify that it isn’t based on halacha but rather on an educational perspective. Our sages have taught us that the reason the serpent was able to make Adam and Eve sin was because Adam had exaggerated the prohibition on the tree of knowing good and bad, telling Eve she shouldn’t touch it. Our sages learn from it: “The one who adds detracts” (San. 29a). By providing an exaggerated and dishonest depiction of the severity of a prohibition one may cause sin and contempt to the teachings of the sages.

Many years ago, I came to give a lecture in one of the seminaries, and when I came near the door I heard the teacher speaking about the weekly parsha, concluding with a stunning intellectual slalom: “..and you, too, must live according to the values you’ve learned. For instance, you shouldn’t go into the army.” Beyond the content of reasons brought up by educators, they should also consider the dosage. In many girls’ seminaries the preaching against military service has become the central message of the latter school years. Arent there any other important topics of discussion?

Some who speak against women’s military service mention the problem of including women in combat roles. I tend to agree with them on this point. I also read about the more lenient scales being used to evaluate fighting women (meaning letting them get by with an inferior physical condition), and about the stool they place for them at the foot of the scaling wall, so they’ll manage to go over it. I, too, have wondered if the Syrian commando was also going to put down stools for them. Beyond that, being familiar with the spirit in fighting units, I know mixing men and women in them creates an unhealthy atmosphere.

But how is that related to religious women serving in the IDF? The vast majority of them do not enlist in combat units, but fulfill essential roles to home front units. the number of graduates from religious institutions has been growing steadily, and the National Service just doesn’t have enough jobs for them. Meanwhile, the army is vying for women to serve in essential, quality home front jobs.

About the Author:


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

8 Responses to “Religious Women Should Consider the Draft – They Aren’t So Fragile”

  1. Anonymous says:

    Reb Yankel- they do serve, what the hell are you talking about

  2. Anonymous says:

    My kid is in a combat unit and she is religious, so what are you talking about? Spreading lies using the Rabbi foil

  3. I don't know who is posting asShirley Cohen – there are quite a few with the same name as me , but it is not me.

  4. Millie Kashuk says:

    Religious Woman and young Woman over the age of 18 do serve in the Military with distinction and Honor…………. They are happy, well adjusted, intelligent
    but most important love the State of Israel……

  5. Ronny Mol says:

    This is another secular media event to kill off our HOLY Jewish women. War is a man's business. There should be NO women in the IDF, not instructors, clerks, intelligence especially in combat. But, the war is coming and unfortunately, by the time the it gets through the heads of generals and the PM it will be too late. Read the Jewish bible, there were no women in the army of King David.

  6. Ora Cooper says:

    men like Ronny Mol are scared of offering women opportunities and some autonomy.I can see it!
    What women with bigger horizons, would want to be the "property"(aka. "wife") of this kind of controling little dictator? I lovet hat he calls women "holy" and then demands that they sit at the back of the bus .. (from holy to Jezebel…) please stop following muslim laws…

  7. Gideon Yavin says:

    War is a terrible thing. We are waging war on many fronts. We might be ahead in the war against the people who want to kill us, but we are definitely loosing the war against the destruction of the family structure. We are seeing more and more divorces and more and more dysfunctional families in ALL communities. The Traditional Orthodox role of the woman is to build the home and build society. She is the only one that can bring physical life into the world and spiritual life into the home and society. The spiritual condition of the unit is dependent on the woman(en). By trying to compete with men in male roles they lowering and degrading themselves to a far lower level. How can we compare the amazing power of bringing life into the world with the primitive and destructive power of removing life from the world. How can we look at the mirror when we are seeing 20,000 murders every year in the form of abortions? Don't attack me for stating my opinion.

  8. War in the 21st century is inevitable. If I were young enough I would fly to Israel from Ireland and fight for Israel too. Building a home cannot built while Islam is ding its level best to raze Israel. Time for children and families after the war is won as it will be. G-d Bless Israel and long may she flourish.

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
Aerial view of Yemenite Village of HaShiloach, Old City of Jerusalem and Mt. of Olives.
Jews to Double Presence in Old Yemenite Village of Shiloach, Silwan
Latest Indepth Stories
Arab children look at pictures of two of a kind - Arafat and Barghouti.

{Originally posted on author’s site, FirstOne Through} The town of Sayreville, New Jersey is in mourning. The superintendent of the town shut the high school’s football program for the rest of the year due to reports of sexual assaults made by upper classmen of the football team against the junior classmen. According to initial reports, […]

Jordan's King Abdullah

The Arab Spring has challenged Jordan with the task of gradual reform with regard to its monarchy.

The Kinneret/Sea of Galilee

Israel offered Syria the entire Golan Heights, only to find that the Syrians were demanding MORE!

Bibeye doctor

Israeli hasbara too can be described at best as pathetic, at worst non existent.

A ‘good news’ story from the Nepal avalanche disaster to warm your heart. Take out your Kleenex.

Journalists see the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as morality play: Israel=evil; Palestine=innocent

Warsaw Ghetto: At its height, the Nazis walled in some 500,000 Jews within the1.3 square mile area.

While police officers face dangers every day on the job, Jews also face danger in their daily lives.

Carter developed a fondness for Arafat believing “they were both ordained to be peacemakers by God”

If Hamas is ISIS, the world asks, why didn’t Israel destroy it given justification and opportunity?

That key is the disarming of Hamas and the demilitarization of Gaza – as the U.S., EU, and others agreed to in principle at the end of Operation Protective Edge.

We have no doubt there are those who deeply desire to present themselves as being of a gender that is not consistent with their anatomy, and we take no joy in the pain and embarrassment they suffer.

Does it not seem ironic that just on the day all of Israel is joyously celebrating another year of having concluded the public reading of the entire Pentateuch, we must mournfully and even tearfully commemorate the death of the individual who imparted to us God’s Torah in the first place?

Why is “Palestine” worthier of “statehood recognition” than ISIS, another terrorist gang seeking it?

More Articles from Rabbi Chaim Navon
Israeli female Border Police soldiers lighting Chanukah candles. There is no reason why religious women not consider military service, although they might do better to avoid combat roles in mixed units.

Despite what some rabbis would tell you, there is no halachic law against women serving in the army.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/opinions/religious-women-should-consider-the-draft-they-arent-so-fragile/2014/01/19/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: