web analytics
December 9, 2016 / 9 Kislev, 5777
InDepth
Sponsored Post
The Migdal Ohr Mishpachton MISHPACHTONIM – Israel’s Children are Your Children.

Support Migdal Ohr by purchasing letters in the Torah Scroll that will be written in honor of Rabbi Grossman’s 70th Birthday.



Home » InDepth » Op-Eds »

There Was No Good Hitler

My own grandfather, Max Schoenwalter, received a letter from the Nazi regime informing him that his paint company was to be liquidated and Judenrein or “Jew free.” That letter was sent to him in January of 1938.



Printer-Ready Page Layout
Hitler.jpg



In an article recently printed in a pro-Kremlin newspaper, Andranik Migranyan, head of a pro-Russian organization here in Manhattan, suggested that had Hitler stopped in 1939 he would be considered a “good Hitler.”

“One should distinguish the difference between Hitler before 1939 and Hitler after 1939” said Mr. Migranyan who argues that if Hitler had stopped after the “bloodless” reunification of German lands “he would have gone down in the history of his country as a politician of the highest order.”

How Mr. Migranyan could make such a statement despite the fact that by this time Hitler had already organized Dachau (the first concentration camp), Kristallnacht, and carried out dozens of Nuremberg racial laws, is beyond me. My own grandfather, Max Schoenwalter, who lived with his family in Germany, received a letter from the Nazi regime informing him that his paint company was to be liquidated and Judenrein or “Jew free.” That letter was sent to him in January of 1938.

But an even deeper question arises: Why would a Russian, representing the current Russian government make such a statement? The Soviet Union lost more than 20 million people fighting the Germans during the Second World War. Communists despise Fascists. How could Migranyan say this?

The reality is that until Germany attacked Russia, the Soviets were largely unaffected by what the Nazis were doing to Jews and other groups they deemed non-Aryan. It wasn’t until the Nazis invaded Russia that the Soviet Union was impacted by Fascism. And so liquidating people’s business, implementing discriminatory laws, instigating pogroms and sending Jews to concentration camps dosen’t make Hitler a bad person. Only attacking Russia does.

The world becomes a very dangerous place when a leader’s morality is evaluated by how he or she treats one people but not by the way they treat another.  It may seem obvious but a person can only be deemed ethical if they behave civilly and fairly to all people. Hitler tried to demonstrate that only some people deserve to be treated with dignity but the Jewish Biblical teaching that all people are created in the Divine image demands that all humanity, irrespective of race, creed or religion be treated with respect and kindness. And so there was never a “good” Hitler, not even before 1939.

Rabbi Mark Wildes

About the Author: Rabbi Mark Wildes holds a BA in Psychology from Yeshiva University, a JD from the Cardozo School of Law, a Masters in International Affairs from Columbia University and was ordained from Yeshiva University. He currently teaches an Outreach Training Seminar at Yeshiva University’s Rabbinical School.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.


Loading Facebook Comments ...



Imported and Older Comments:

  1. HectorRamos says:

    Rabbi, Mark Wildes, how unfortunate to learn that, in one’s unique perspective most politicians, as well as religious leaders, only see what others do or don’t do – except for themselves. And, though God the Creator is demanding that all humans love and respect him, and abide by his laws – especially Israel, like Hitler, Israel has been suffering under one Pharisee leadership, inherently preventing Israelis to learn the truth about the sin of those who have subjugated the chosen people of God even while in exile in, Babylonia. One way of thinking – preventing Israel from worshipping Jehovah as he prescribed on his covenant (the sacrifices of animals, especially for the sins of Israel perpetually and forever), and then even kill all of God’s prophets so that these (Scribes) rabbis would not have to listen to God, is this not the same as an evil man who hated Jews like Pharisees hate God?
    One does not require much education to understand the Torah; failure to follow one law is enough to condemn you; one only need to love God above all else, and ask him to reveal his will through the Holy Spirit in order to understand Moses’ law.
    Why are the Pharisees not letting Israel study the Torah, instead of the Talmud? Is this not the same as a Hitler who only favored those who believed in him, that he would not kill? Is Judaism truly a free sect anyone may choose to follow, or is it a religion that Israel must obey, or else they will not be treated with respect and honor.
    The Pharisees cult can never be a good thing – since Babylonia until now, specially when all of God’s prophets were killed, and the Talmud is the only book full of traditions preventing Israel from worshipping Jehovah, their only God and Savior.

  2. Bryan Baruch says:

    As if there was really a question.

  3. he was just plain evil his direction was evil, his motivation was evil and knew what he wanted to do before he got elected.

  4. All the way evil through and through

  5. Same to China Hitlers today

  6. Eeewww I hate hitler I glad he dead

  7. Why did the zionists conspire with him

  8. Why did the zionists conspire with him

  9. Is it true that hitler was a jew?

  10. Andi Priest says:

    Hitler was possessed by a very dark force that is still running rampant in the hearts of man the world over. Evil in it’s finest- if there is such a thing.

  11. David Cubero says:

    OOPS! I hit “Post” trying to correct a mess-up… To complete My Comment,,,Hitler was The Most Evil! Truly, CONSUMATE EVIL! Forgive My Above Error…

  12. Go to hell Allan Ceasar Vale The Fuhrer was no filthy jew and you sad sacks only perceive righteousness dimly and through sociopathic perception so you can only call his power evil ,when in fact he was a holy man sent to bring the white race back on track. I hope every one of you sleeps well tonight knowing we who love him and love our race see you pigs and mongrels for what you are: genetic expressions of filth and unholiness

  13. Oh yes, Heather, Hitler is dead, deader than a door nail. He was a Jew hater. Read your history books. He had the Jews rounded up like cattle and put on trains to the gas chambers. We’re you sleeping during your history class. He was mean to the Jews. Go back to the history books kidd, you might learn something

  14. Ussama Mirza says:

    i love u man..<3

  15. Is Satan pure evil or there is some good with him?

  16. naes1984 says:

    Good? No way. But if he had stopped his territorial expansion after Czechoslovakia in 1939 he very well could have been successful. Then I can guarantee you a lot more Germans (who would have a much larger and more populated country than they do currently) would conveniently forget about his antisemitism, shrug it off as a mere blemish and argue about him as a “complex figure.” Sad but true.

  17. HildegardBehrendt says:

    what do you expect from someone, whose father or grandfathrr sent their own unloved people to the Gulag?? Nobody really warned anyone of Hitler. And those who did haven’t been listened to or totally ignored. And after the war? How did many nations close their doors in the face of Jewish de ported people?? and yes, Hitler was never a good person. It is a serious indicator for either lack of historical knowledge or t otal ignorance to say that. But I can indeed imagine that the german people would have overseen all his sins had he stopped in 1939.

  18. Please I love everything about Israel and the Jews but don’t put this disgusting thing on any thing I can see

  19. This jew.hater will fsce the lord god almighty . It is a scary moment.

  20. Don’t even put his picture on anything!!!

  21. Ira Abramson says:

    Heather, you need an attitude change. You would fit well with the skin heads, but you need a shave.

  22. Ira Abramson says:

    Heather, why are you reading a Jewish publication?

  23. IrvingWeisdorf says:

    I think the good Rabbi has missed the point. He is supporting and justifying Putin’s attempts to “re-unify” the Russian people, by annexing parts of Georgia in 2009 and parts of the Ukraine this year.

  24. David Elliot says:

    But today there are many Hitlers in Iran, Gaza. PLO and Hezbolahs.

  25. Loren Renee says:

    Crazy pseudo religious rambling from a crazy brain made crazier by advanced syphilis

  26. He didn’t invade Palestine ?

  27. He didn’t invade Palestine ?

  28. God took care of this hitler

  29. God took care of this hitler

  30. Hollund Shaf says:

    The ignorance in this world is astounding.

  31. Heather – first of all, your hair is way too long – your head should be shaved bald, or it should be blonde. Second of all, as die hure, die zicke and die schlampe of The Devil Hitler, there are other words which fit you – ungeziefer, untermentsch, ratte, blydel, pappnase, hundin, tier, saverel, hirnrissig, verryckt and ybergeschnappt. If you need these translated…

  32. and that same spirit of evil is seen today in barrack obam

  33. Mike Stewart says:

    He started out like every young man. But he lost his parents and then he lost his way. He became involved in things that we evil and in the end it cost him and the world over 80,000,000 people during WWII. The greater lesson that we all can learn is that no child is a throw away, if we help lead them with love and proper attention tyrants will not develop and evil will die.

  34. Niels Mayer says:

    Henry Ford and Prescott Bush loved Hitler enough to fund his wars, have the FBI coverup his escape to Argentina all while importing many Nazi War criminals (Werner con Braun, Reinhard Gehlen, Erich Traub) to infest the US with Nazi ideology and psychopathy at every level of government. http://vault.fbi.gov/adolf-hitler

  35. AvrahamAviHecht692 says:

    …the first camps were erected within the same year Hitler took office housing decedents of that regime, by design this camps shortened human life, the entire nation participated in this endeavor… 😉

  36. JohnnyM.Ashburn says:

    Who ever had the idea tat there was a good Hitler?

  37. MichaelK-n230 says:

    Was Hitler-pre-1939 “good” for this Author only?

    Probably, Rabbi somehow omitted information about attempts to split a world by British and Hitler after 1939:
    http://ginasmith.typepad.com/gina_on_gina/2008/08/britain-and-nazi-germany-splitting-the-world.html

    Michael Kerjman

  38. SientjeSeinen935 says:

    Could it be said that Hitler brought out the good in some people and the very worst in others? I know that the nazis left me with being afraid of anyone in uniform.

  39. GaryW.Harper says:

    He is making the statement in the perspective of the Western world. Judaism is an Eastern perspective. In the Western world, if a leader unifies a nation and brings it out of poverty to power, then he is a “good” leader. No matter the course he took to get there. The west is considering the genocide to be a post-onset of WWII phenomenon. It would have occurred inside the unified Reich’s borders anyway, for all Jews who did not emigrate.

    But the writer is delusional. Anyone who has read Mein Kampf (I did in the 6th grade) knows that it was a blueprint that Hitler followed almost exactly, up until the might of the U.S. military (and our manufacturing prowess) crushed his plans. England would have certainly fallen. Hitler was a strategic fool, too. He had a treaty with Stalin that Stalin respected. The Eastern front made it possible to take Germany.

    It can happen again. The Arab nations all talk like Hitler did. There are no lessons ever learned by men from their own histories. So they must forever suffer for it.

  40. GaryW.Harper says:

    I do not have the research behind this one, and it is subjective, but here it goes. This is a 2010 article on the History Channel. Send this one to every Aryan Nation type who comments here:

    http://www.history.com/news/study-suggests-adolf-hitler-had-jewish-and-african-ancestors

  41. DeborahMgedzi519 says:

    God is the judge!

  42. WriterDebbieJ.Callahan says:

    Mein Kampf was published in 1925/1926. As the author of that book, Hitler did not appear to be “good” at that time.

  43. SheilaNovitz834 says:

    Agreed. Through the years I have had various “friends” venture to tell me that “Hitler did some good things too.” I didn’t wait to ask what those things were. And have not ever seen those “friends” again.

    The world holds many people like Migranyan. One tries not to get too upset at their statements, but they’re always a shock, and being deeply upset comes with that. Will it ever change? No.

  44. SheilaNovitz834 says:

    We agree with everything you write. Thank you.

  45. SheilaNovitz834 says:

    No, it could not be said that Hitler brought out the “good” in some people. What “good”? All he brought out was thoroughly evil.

  46. SheilaNovitz834 says:

    WHAT?


Current Top Story
Police on the scene at Giza blast Friday 12-9-16
Bomb Kills 6 Police Near Pyramids [video]

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/opinions/there-was-no-good-hitler/2014/05/18/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: