Photo Credit: unsplash

If the leaders of J Street and the New Israel Fund were in charge of creating new flavors for Ben & Jerry’s ice cream, their newest would be Red Herring. Or maybe Fig Leaf.

Such flavors don’t sound too appetizing? Well, those groups’ responses to the Ben & Jerry’s controversy are equally unattractive from the point of view of intellectual integrity.

Ben-Ami told interviewers this week that Ben & Jerry’s is merely making a distinction between “the State of Israel and the territory it occupies.” Similarly, Sokatch claimed that Ben & Jerry’s is just “distinguishing between sovereign and non-sovereign Israel.”

That’s a classic example of an argument which sounds reasonable at first glance, but crumbles as soon as you think about it a bit deeper.

The entire city of Jerusalem, after all, is part of the State of Israel, to use Ben-Ami’s formula. It’s certainly “sovereign Israel,” to employ Sokatch’s language.

So does that mean that J Street and the New Israel Fund consider the post-1967 sections of the city to be part of Jerusalem, and are denouncing Ben & Jerry’s for boycotting those areas?

Does that mean J Street and the New Israel Fund are demanding that Ben & Jerry’s be made available in mixed Arab-Jewish neighborhoods in the post-1967 part of the capital, such as Shimon HaTzadik/Sheikh Jarrah or Kfar Shiloah/Silwan?

Does that mean members of J Street and the New Israel Fund are bombarding Ben & Jerry’s with letters insisting that “Chubby Hubby” and “Chunky Monkey” be sold in mostly Jewish neighborhoods in the eastern part of the city, such as Gilo, French Hill and Ramot?

Of course not. All their talk about “sovereign Israel” is nothing more than a red herring — a distraction from the real issue — or maybe a fig leaf, a cover for what they really advocate.

Because the cold, hard truth is that J Street and the New Israel Fund don’t accept the fact that the eastern parts of Jerusalem are legitimately sovereign Israeli territory. They and their colleagues on the American Jewish left believe those parts of the city should become the capital of “Palestine.” That’s the Palestinian Authority’s position, and the Jewish far left supports it.

However, Ben-Ami and Sokatch know how unpopular that position is in the Jewish world. So instead of being upfront about their positions, they have constructed disingenuous arguments about “sovereign Israel” and “occupied territory,” so it sounds as if they — and Ben & Jerry’s — are operating according to some noble principle. They’re not. They’re engaged in intellectual shenanigans.

If Ben-Ami and Sokatch really subscribed to the high-sounding principle that they have cited, they would accept the fact that all of Jerusalem — and all of the Golan Heights — are part of sovereign Israel.

But they don’t accept it. They don’t respect the concept of “sovereign Israel.” They only cite it when it’s convenient for scoring political points.

I don’t begrudge J Street and the New Israel Fund to support the Palestinian Authority’s position on Jerusalem. I don’t begrudge them their right to support Ben & Jerry’s boycott of large parts of Jerusalem. In America, people have a right to take whatever repulsive position they want to take. But they don’t have a right to engage in false advertising. They don’t have a right to claim they respect “sovereign Israel” when they clearly don’t.

The position that J Street and the New Israel Fund have taken with regard to Ben & Jerry’s is nothing more than a red herring, or perhaps a fig leaf. Those wouldn’t make delectable flavors of ice cream. They don’t make for reasonable or honest political arguments, either.


Previous articleUkraine, Israel, Agree on Corona Certificates to Facilitate Free Travel Come Rosh Hashanah
Next articleKnesset Plenum Votes Down 3 No-Confidence Motions
Moshe Phillips ( is a commentator on Jewish affairs and was first published in The Jewish Press in 2009. He was a U.S. delegate to the 38th World Zionist Congress in 2020 and a board member of the American Zionist Movement from 2018 until 2021. The views expressed are his own.