web analytics
December 25, 2014 / 3 Tevet, 5775
 
At a Glance
Blogs
Sponsored Post
8000 meals Celebrate Eight Days of Chanukah – With 8,000 Free Meals Daily to Israel’s Poor

Join Meir Panim’s campaign to “light up” Chanukah for families in need.



Holocaust Denial and Critical Thinking Skills

Not every intellectual freedom that we have an inherent right to is a priority for education.
Rows of bodies fill the yard of the Boelcke Barracks located in the south-east of the town of Nordhausen. The barracks was a subcamp of the Mittelbau-Dora Nazi concentration camp.

Rows of bodies fill the yard of the Boelcke Barracks located in the south-east of the town of Nordhausen. The barracks was a subcamp of the Mittelbau-Dora Nazi concentration camp.
Photo Credit: Wikimedia

Charles C.W. Cooke opened up a can of worms at NRO when he opined, on 7 May, that asking 8th graders to prove to themselves whether the Holocaust had actually happened was a perfectly good exercise in academic honesty.  He certainly has no doubts about the reality of the Holocaust, he stressed.  But he also thinks we shouldn’t fear the outcome of an empirical investigation into the question, which can be compared with debates over value questions like whether “war is always wrong,” or whether “sharia law would be good for the West.”

Jonah Goldberg responded promptly, making the main points that occurred immediately to me.  First, 8th graders are not college students; it’s the rare 8th grader who is up to the rigors of an Oxford Union debate.  Second, debating a factual point that’s subject to empirical disproof is a different game from debating what our moral values should prescribe for us (or, indeed, what those values should be).

Cooke acknowledged both points.  He still thinks we shouldn’t reflexively object to a research-and-reasoning exercise on the reality of the Holocaust.  He compares it in his response to a similar exercise treating the reality of the Declaration of Independence.  In his view, it would be an opportunity to stress the value of empiricism and the use of critical thinking skills.

And while he doesn’t state it explicitly, an implied advantage of doing this with a topic like the Holocaust is that a student’s success would be measurable.  Since we know there was a Holocaust, and we know a great deal about it, a student’s performance will be indicated by whether he concludes that the Holocaust most certainly happened.

Right?  Well, that’s where the elevation of abstract reasoning over all else breaks down for me.  What about the student who doesn’t conclude that the Holocaust happened, but can make a compelling argument – in the abstract – that doubt, at least, should be cast on it; and can even “show his work,” very possibly running logical rings around the instructor?

The question about this scenario is not whether we should “fear” it.  The question is what good it has done to put time and effort into it.  (There’s also a question whether putting effort into it is actively harmful.  More on that in a minute.)

Not every intellectual freedom that we have an inherent right to is a priority for education.  A 13-year-old could congratulate himself, for example, on demonstrating that there’s no objective proof of his existence; and from the standpoint of intellectual freedom, we’d all say, “Knock yourself out, buddy.”  But whether we want him to devote his educational time to that effort, and what we expect him to get out of it, depend on our scale of values.  Education is intrinsically a process in which we make value-based choices about what to emphasize and what to do.  No such thing exists as abstract, non-value-weighted education.

There’s thus a big value difference between giving children the tools of thinking, and selecting things for them to approach with skepticism.  The latter can never be a neutral action, in any context.

In recent decades, in fact, much of academia has made something of a fetish of it for very specific purposes, like casting doubt on whether America’s Founders were Christians or not.  The upshot of this has been that “skepticism” itself has been turned on its head, and middle- and high-school students are encouraged to think they’ve been endowed with a refreshing skepticism on one topic or another, when in fact they’ve simply been indoctrinated with an arguable falsity.

About the Author: J.E. Dyer is a retired US Naval intelligence officer who served around the world, afloat and ashore, from 1983 to 2004.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

2 Responses to “Holocaust Denial and Critical Thinking Skills”

  1. someone should deny them their citizenship

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
Naftali Bennett, chairman of the Jewish Home party.
Bayit Yehudi Finally Has the Education Ministry (Until Elections)
Latest Blogs Stories
HaTnua Party Meeting

Is his article satire? Or does Kai Bird really think Tzipi Livni heads a “center-right” party?

Shabbat Table

Much as I’d like to see the Jewish nation fully observant forcing Shabbat on people is NOT the way.

game of thrones

Loyalty seems to be a lost trait in Israeli politics, whether it’s to ideals, principles or parties.

for-rent-148891_1280

Apartment hunting is kinda like dating: You go see anything that looks right on paper-and pray.

Latest headlines say that Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu’s Likud may only make third place if…

What are the roles of leadership and communication in running a “tight ship”?

Sabraman: Israel’s first superhero, combining the courage of the Sabra and the faith of Abraham.

Is Haredi open-ended learning on charity better than earning a living that would obviate that?

Hanuka is the miracle of emunah- belief in the L-rd of Israel and the light of our faith.

Limiting Jewish success and revival is that the anti-Jewish, anti-History Left rules here in Israel

The crisis in Jewish education is of existential importance. How should it be resolved?

BBC GUIDELINES ON TERRORISM: The word “terrorist” itself can be a barrier rather than an aid…

Discussion with entrepreneur William Heinecke on how he became a young, successful businessman

Did Cuba apologize for their spies the way Israel apologized for Pollard?

Nothing binds Jews together more than Torah observance; Or so one would think.

Sukkah tinsel decorations enjoy a robust market but are invariably manufactured for “another”holiday

More Articles from J. E. Dyer
Russia Cuba relations

Obama obtained NO verifiable commitments from Cuba it would desist from acts prejudicial to the US

Iran officials meet with G 5+1 officials in Geneva. Weapons to Gaza will not derail the talks.

We would be fools to take seriously assurances from Joe Biden.

The White House wanted to defame Netanyahu, undermine his reputation, impugn him & his policies

{Originally posted on author’s site, Liberty Unyielding} Never let a crisis go to waste. That’s the mantra – and a new development in Britain demonstrates how the Western left lives by it, and contributes thereby to the destruction of Western culture. Alert readers will remember the so-called “Trojan Horse plot” in Birmingham, first reported in […]

It’s likely that some of the rebel factions, including US clients, have indeed made pacts with ISIS

Another nation – probably Iran, possibly Russia and/or Syria – is entering the fight in Iraq in a new and fully committed way.

There is now NO possible explanation for not evacuating at least non-essential personnel from the U.S. embassy and consulates in Iraq.

ISIS is executing, slowly but surely, a pincer move on Baghdad.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/blogs/guest-blog/holocaust-denial-and-critical-thinking-skills/2014/05/12/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: