web analytics
August 20, 2014 / 24 Av, 5774
Israel at War: Operation Protective Edge
 
 
At a Glance
InDepth
Sponsored Post
Jerusalem Mayor Nir Barkat (L) visits the JewishPress.com booth at The Event. And the Winners of the JewishPress.com Raffle Are…

Congratulations to all the winners of the JewishPress.com raffle at The Event



A Solution to the Draft Controversy

My proposal to solve the contentious issue of Israel’s universal draft.

F121122TA07

Photo Credit: Tsafrir Abayov/Flash90

My proposal regarding the contentious issue of Israel’s universal draft represents a unique approach that cannot only solve the problem but will also provide leverage to strengthen the IDF and Israeli society.

To begin, I object to the premise that army service is a unifying factor, i.e. the melting pot, of Israeli society. Today, a large part of Israeli society – not necessarily the Haredi – finds a way to evade mandatory service. Also, only a small percentage of the entire society serves in the reserves.

Mandatory military service is one of the factors dividing and fragmenting Israeli society. The discussion being conducted now is one of the proofs of that. Additionally, the obligation to draft everyone is actually a burden on the army and economy, as it cultivates hidden unemployment and lack of professionalism.

Proposal’s Main Points

● Create a process that will transform the army into a professional, volunteer force. ● On the other side of the coin, we must exchange our exclusive reliance on the army as an apparently unifying factor in Israeli society with a true investment in the strengthening of our shared national and cultural identity. This entails authentic dialogue between all the main sectors in Israeli society.

Army Service Proposal

● The Mandatory Draft Law will remain on the books, but the IDF will draft only those it is interested in drafting, according to the tracks to be specified below. ● Most of the recruits will serve in a shortened training track (not more than two months) that will prepare them for various roles in times of emergency – and will then be discharged.

● Recruits who volunteer for military units will be drafted for at least three years. They will receive minimum wage during their training and standing army wages during their military service.

● Recruits who volunteer for special units will be drafted for a longer term (5-6 years), in accordance with the training invested in them. They will also receive minimum wage during training and standing army wages during their military service.

● The National Service and Civil Service frameworks will continue to play their roles in society, in accordance with the civil needs.

● Reserve units will receive high pay and high national classification as detailed in the following point.

● A classification on a point system will be set in place. Points will be allotted relative to reserve time served. These points will afford the reservists preference for anything that society honors (academia, housing, employment, etc.) in order to encourage those who give of themselves for the good of the whole.

Proposal Application

● This proposal does not require a change in legislation but rather a change in perspective. The army must be allowed to draft those individuals who it can professionally train and from whom it will truly benefit. Those not needed by the army could give to society in National Service or Civil Service, as well as in their preparedness for active duty during emergencies. Those not wishing to do their part in any way will remain at “the end of the line” in any domain in which society encourages those who give to it.
● This proposal will make the army more effective while freeing those currently forced to perform mandatory conscription (be it in the army or in yeshiva) to enter the work market. Instead of funding unemployed soldiers and yeshiva students who do not want to enlist, a wave of young workers will enter the workforce and create a more just distribution of the economic burden on the shoulders of Israel’s citizens.

MILITARY SERVICE is a privilege – not a burden. Mandatory conscription is not really needed. It weakens our security and economy, creates unnecessary conflicts and fragments society.

I call upon Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his cabinet to adopt this new, fresh approach on the draft issue. I call on them to channel their efforts to truly unite Israeli society – by investing in our national identity and its meaning.

About the Author:


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

10 Responses to “A Solution to the Draft Controversy”

  1. Yehuda Cohen says:

    Is this the conclusion that you made while in the gays bar that you supported with your attendance?

  2. another excellent solution to an army problem!

  3. Shuljac says:

    This is not a new idea whatsoever…the u.s. military had been doing this for quite some time?!

  4. Shuljac says:

    This is not a new idea whatsoever…the united states military had been doing this for quite some time?!

  5. Shuljac says:

    This is not a new idea whatsoever…the united states military had been doing this for quite some time

  6. Shuljac says:

    Oops, I didn’t mean to publish multiple times

  7. It's surely the first time I agree with Mr. Feigilin.

  8. Yechiel Baum says:

    Talmidim being taught about Judaism and the importance to save lives should be among the first to enlist instead of saving others. During WWII, they organized to bribe and save many Rabbis, leaving the rest of the Jews to be murdered. Hence, it is a selfish education they are learning for their own self interest rather than being role models that Hashem demands. End their hyprocracy.In Koheles, it says there is a time for everything under heavan. Hence, after a day of serving, study at night or when there is a peaceful lull it is time for parasites to be removed from Judaism so true jews can survive!
    If the kids can play on tanks, they have the time to learn how to defend Jews around the world, especially in Jerusalem where they are frequently attacked and unable to defend themselves to fight back giving the gangsters the courage to be brazen with their criminal activity.

  9. Yechiel Baum says:

    Talmidim being taught about Judaism and the importance to save lives should be among the first to enlist instead of saving others. During WWII, they organized to bribe and save many Rabbis, leaving the rest of the Jews to be murdered. Hence, it is a selfish education they are learning for their own self interest rather than being role models that Hashem demands. End their hyprocracy.In Koheles, it says there is a time for everything under heavan. Hence, after a day of serving, study at night or when there is a peaceful lull it is time for parasites to be removed from Judaism so true jews can survive!
    If the kids can play on tanks, they have the time to learn how to defend Jews around the world, especially in Jerusalem where they are frequently attacked and unable to defend themselves to fight back giving the gangsters the courage to be brazen with their criminal activity.

  10. Judith Zvaig says:

    As much as I agree with Feigelin on other issues, this time I find his "solution" everything but. Hareidim abhor zionism at large so STOP excusing for them. Thanks

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
The Gaza Region
Live Updates: Hamas Rockets Explode in Southern Israel (15:48pm)
Latest Indepth Stories
Mowing the lawn

Judging by history, every time Hamas rebuilds their infrastructure, they are stronger than before.

Digital StillCamera

His father asked him to read Psalms from the Book of Tehilim every day.

Bosch-Fawstin-They-Say-We-Say

(Reposted with permission from author’s website) Moderate truth-teller Daniel Pipes (Dream) has further moderated his stance on Islam by actually entertaining the idea of “Moderate Islamism”, with Andrew C. McCarthy- whom I’ve debated about this- giving it some credence. We’ve gone from Naming the Enemy -Nazism, Communism- to Renaming the Enemy – “Islamic Totalitarianism”, “Radical Islam”, “Islamism”, […]

Light up the world copy

Maimonides: “Your 1 mitzva may tip the scales and bring redemption to the entire world and creation”

Jerusalem has been aware of the importance of China to its growth and security.

In other words, how by any rational playbook can one even begin to explain anti-Semitism?

Israel has nine Iron Domes, but you Mr. Hannity are the tenth.

Entire movements within “orthodoxy” propagate a Judaism of outlandish folklore and Jewish mysticism

The Rebbetzin began campaigning to increase public awareness of the importance of saying Amen.

Obama is transparent, if you read his oracular signs with the right key.

Everything I imbibe is with my inimitable fervor for being Jewish.

The multiculturalism that animates the hate-Israel crowd is sprinkled with code words of oppression

All the tactical problems have solutions. The real problem is not with the enemy; it is with us.

Israel feebly begged Hamas to end the barrage, promising that “quiet will be met with quiet.”

The UN ignores humanity’s worst war criminals while incessantly condemning Israel.

Haredim possess strong feelings of kinship and belonging, desiring to contribute to Israeli society.

More Articles from Moshe Feiglin
MK Moshe-Feiglin

All the tactical problems have solutions. The real problem is not with the enemy; it is with us.

MK Moshe-Feiglin

Why couldn’t the artillery barrage have been implemented before the soldiers went into that hell?

The Gazan octopus arm is a test case, as the rest of the arms are closely watching it.

It is time for a total military siege on Gaza; Nothing should enter the Gaza Strip.

“The will to triumph is a prerequisite for victory.” Abba Kovner

Immediately end the occupation and declare Israeli sovereignty over the entire Jewish Homeland.

The demographic pessimists have failed.

    Latest Poll

    Do you think the FAA ban on US flights to Israel is political?






    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/columns/moshe-feiglin/a-solution-to-the-draft-controversy/2013/02/13/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: