web analytics
September 21, 2014 / 26 Elul, 5774
At a Glance
Sponsored Post
Apartment 758x530 Africa-Israel at the Israel Real Estate Exhibition in New York

Africa Israel Residences, part of the Africa Israel Investments Group led by international businessman Lev Leviev, will present 7 leading projects on the The Israel Real Estate Exhibition in New York on Sep 14-15, 2014.

Home » InDepth » Op-Eds »

Jews Killed Nobody

jews killed nobody2

With the erection of a replica of Israel’s security barrier wall at a London Church, when a Holland based Roman Catholic Church Association television station airs a video clip titled “Jews kill Jesus”, when a Sydney based Anglican priest, in one of his recent sermons states that “Jews killed Jesus” I say enough is enough. The time has come for a full frontal assault on the basis of the Christian gospels from where all antisemitism emerged.

The unbridled persecution of Jews throughout the centuries should have taught us that in order to legitimize the gospels, Christianity needs to perpetuate the same deception of Jews as the eternal scapegoats. I find it unfortunate that I need to respond in the manner I do, but rest assured this dialogue needs to take place. A tidal wave of antisemitism is currently engulfing the world and the past docile, politically correct and ill-informed posture of world Jewry has been proven to be an abysmal failure.

To address the issue of antisemitism head on, I offer the following.

The Republic of Rome 2,000 years ago would never have tolerated anyone in its midst being proclaimed as the Messiah or King of the Jews. Simply put, under Roman law, calls for a monarchy within the Republic would have been a treasonable offense punishable by death.

It was not an issue for the Sanhedrin, as Christian theology would want us to believe.

The birth of antisemitism would no doubt have come from the Christian narrative of the actions of Pontius Pilate, the Roman Governor at the time. Christianity teaches that at Passover there was a Roman custom whereby one prisoner scheduled for crucifixion would be pardoned. This same narrative goes on to say that when given the choice of who to free, the Jewish mob cried out for Barabbas. Then followed the hand washing scene where Pontius Pilate freed Barabbas and exonerated himself for the death of the Christ (literally the “anointed one”) and so started the beginnings of antisemitism spread so successfully by the Church down the centuries to the present day.

Unfortunately, according the writings of the noted Roman historian Josephus, there was never any Roman custom to pardon anyone scheduled for crucifixion. If this is so, then the whole story is a myth fabricated by the early Church to blame someone (but not the Roman authorities) for the death of their Christ. Who better to blame than Jews?

I offer the following for the benefit of those Jews who find themselves engaged in theological debate, subjected to anti-Semitic vilification or Evangelical Christian attempts to convert them to Christianity. Additionally, never again do we need the spectacle as reported some years back where a guide at the Sydney Holocaust Museum was asked “Why don’t Jews just accept Jesus?” (implying the horror of the holocaust would never have taken place if Jews would only have forsaken the Torah for the New Testament). According to news reports, the guide’s only response was to stand there totally bewildered and unable to answer. Hopefully the following, if absorbed, will ensure this deplorable episode will never occur again.

The psalms were Jewish and written before the birth of Christianity. All references to “Lord” were to the Lord God of Israel. Christian clergy often quote the psalms and the average Christian thinks the references to “Lord” (e.g. Psalm 23 “The Lord is my shepherd”) refer to Jesus. No Christian clergy to my knowledge has ever seen fit to enlighten his flock. So the propaganda goes on and on from one generation to the other. Even the regularly quoted: “The meek shall inherit the earth” often quoted by Christians as a profound and original statement by their Saviour is nothing more than his quoting from the Psalms (Psalm 37 Verse 11).

About the Author: Gil Solomon is a retired finance manager and author.

If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

127 Responses to “Jews Killed Nobody”

  1. It was the sin of the human race.

  2. The Gospels were written by Jews who followed Jesus. The followers of Jesus called him Rabbi. They were angry at the Jewish high priest who had Jesus handed over to the Romans. In later centuries Christians misunderstood the writers of the Gospel and blamed the Jews. As an Irish American Catholic with Jewish friends I can tell you that us Catholics and most Christians are your friends and we do not blame you for anything that happened to Jesus, and if anyone does, have no fear. Rabbi Jesus said: "This world shall pass away, but my words shall never pass away"

  3. Pedro Acosta says:

    I am tired of hearing Jews explicate themselves. There is nothing that some of their ancestors did that they need to apologize for, over and over.

    The Romans crucified Jesus and even his followers admit that his death is part of their messianic message. IE it was preordained to be. Case closed, move on.

  4. Pedro Acosta says:

    I am tired of hearing Jews explicate themselves. There is nothing that some of their ancestors did that they need to apologize for, over and over.

    The Romans crucified Jesus and even his followers admit that his death is part of their messianic message. IE it was preordained to be. Case closed, move on.

  5. Pedro Acosta says:

    I am tired of hearing Jews explicate themselves. There is nothing that some of their ancestors did that they need to apologize for, over and over.

    The Romans crucified Jesus and even his followers admit that his death is part of their messianic message. IE it was preordained to be. Case closed, move on.

  6. Pedro Acosta says:

    Even the Catholics have come to that realization. It’s time for Jews to do the same and stop explaining ourselves.

  7. Judas killed no one either..

  8. Jorgi Reus says:

    Did Jesus ever exist? please answer this with real evidences and then start with that issue

  9. Interesting article

  10. Les Le Gear says:

    You and your friends are a tiny minority. The church inculcated Jew hatred in their followers for around 1800 years. It was only in 1963 that they magnanimously proclaimed that the decendents of Jews from jesus's time are not to be blamed for his murder. Hard to change peoples minds after 1800 years of church lies. Too little,too late.

  11. Karen Bryant says:

    Pedro the difference between the catholics and Jews is that catholics haven’t been murdered in the name of Jesus …Jews have. A little compassion would be a good thing.

  12. If it is real evidence you seek then ask the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob?

  13. Les Le Gear never too late to make reconciliation. Fundamentalist Christians who truly love and respect the Jewish people need to demonstrate this through self sacrifice the way Messiah did for us.

  14. Margaret Salmond there is no such thing as a divided G*dhead in Judaism. That's a Pagan idea that infiltrated the early Church. G*d is ONE, UNDIVIDED, and that's the basic foundation of Judaism – every day we say "Hear O Israel, the LORD G*d is ONE." NOT three. ONE.

  15. Les Le Gear We are not a tiny minority. Most Catholic Irish here in NY where I live have Jewish friends, we often are married to Jewish people. You need to get your mind out of the past.

  16. I have had this discussion with a Catholic online. His response to my explanation about why it was the Romans who killed Jesus was, “Roberta, I don’t know what bible YOU’VE been reading, but…”. Now, not all Catholics, nor all Christians are scriptural fundamentalists, but it is fundamentalism that is dangerous, of all makes and models. Fundamentalism renders reason and fact inoperative. Explanations such as this are ineffective for this reason. I am a Jew by choice. Almost no Christians know Judaism, as they are only taught what Judaism teaches by other Christians. I agree, Jews need to respectfully and confidently leave behind the PC, and the laying low to call no attention to ourselves for fear we may call down another pogrom. But the audience should be carefully chosen.

  17. Walter Richards says:

    There is not one contemperaneous account of what happened, if anything at all did happen. It's all hearsay written decades after and who is to now how much
    was distorted to fil a particular agenda

  18. Les Le Gear In my picture here you see me playing guitar on the left. The drummer is my friend Eric, he is Jewish. I was best man at his wedding. Us Irish have been persecuted just as bad as the Jews, God made everyone, we are all his children.

  19. Is he? How do you know that? Why go on perpetuating a myth, a set of myths that has caused untold suffering to the Jewish people for more than 2,000 years. Why?

  20. And I have a good Catholic friend who recently told me that the Church tells you that all of the Old Testament are just stories. Now why would the Old Testament be 'just stories', but the New Testament be 'the truth'. Perhaps you could consider that it was man/the Church's need for power and control that begun this sorry state of affairs that has resulted in Jewish suffering?

  21. David Brownfield By 'self-sacrifice', do you mean crucify ourselves?

  22. Sylvie Schapira we know that because it is taught to us through our Torah, and through our Sages, and through our Theology. I'm sorry that you have accepted a religion that to us is anathema, you worship a man-god and that to us is idolatry, pure and simple. Any religion that deifies a human is automatically forbidden to us. It's obnoxious for you to try to convince us otherwise. We don't believe in hell the way you do, we don't believe in personal salvation of the soul, in fact we, unlike you, believe the soul is PURE from before birth, and that it isn't full of "original sin" (we don't believe that either). Your religion is an amalgam of 1st-Century Judaism and Paganism. I could give you a hundred examples but let's just start with the basics of your theology – a trinity, a 3-part godhead. What could be MORE pagan than that, or less Jewish???

  23. True! It was the Romans, but at the instigation of the Pharisees and Sadducees leaders. However Jesus forgave all who had a part to play in His murder! The root of anti-Semitism was in anti-Christian Roman Catholic doctrine. That church was not and is not Christian!

  24. Sylvie Schapira The mistake many Jewish people make, is to think they are all Jesus on that cross, to think their ancestors suffered more than everyone else in the world. In reality, most of you are making good money, and people in the world today who suffer real violence and poverty could care less about your stupid whining and complaining. Go see a therapist and stop bitching and moaning, you have the money. Most people in the world don't even have clean water.

  25. Ron Smith says:

    "Unfortunately, according the writings of the noted Roman historian Josephus, there was never any Roman custom to pardon anyone scheduled for crucifixion."

    If Josephus really said this, where is the citation? If this claim is made simply on the basis that Josephus never mentions the custom, that would be an invalid argument from silence.

    There is nothing anti-semetic in the Gospels. Wicked men, like that Serpent of old, will take what God has said and twist it in order to drive their own wicked agenda. "Hath God really said…?" Jesus is the Savior of the World. This includes all people, the first of which were Jews.

  26. Point to two additional facts. First Duet. 13; which by GOD’s law would have required the blood of Jesus. Second, Jesus says 88 times he is the son of man. How can he be the son of man and the son of GOD. He was the Messiah, look up the definition. Also, children can NOT be held responsible for the sins, if it were, of their parents.

  27. The Jews did not murder Christ. Jesus laid down His Life and took it back up again. Judas betrayed Christ. It was the love of God that held Him on the cross and His love raised Him up again. The perfect sacrifice given in love for us all.

  28. One more thing. That picture you have there is totally sacrilegious. Why do you hate Jesus so much?

  29. Alex Rivera says:

    Christopher that picture is in no way Jesus Himself on the cross. But I have to admit this article is a little flawed. His thesis on what gushed meant is inaccurate.

  30. A true Christian does not hate nor blame the Jew. He laid his life down as a perfect sacrifice,(the ultimate red heifer/lamb). We understand who Hashem is. Col 2:9 For in him dwelleth all the fulness of the G-dhead bodily. He was not just a man, he was a clean man, in whom, all of the Spirit dwelt. He did not just die, he rose! Even in Christianity there are many false prophets, but truly there is only ONE. Sh'ma Yis'ra'eil Adonai Eloheinu Adonai echad.

  31. Aldo Mimoun says:

    Jesus was an ordinary jew during the Roman occupation of Judea. The idea that he was turned over to the roman authorities on a Friday night (Shabbat) and on the eve of Passover is so ridiculous that it does not even require an explanation. Jesus the Christ is an invention of another Jew called Paul (Saul of Tarsus). I think that instead of 2000 years of Jewish persecution from the Vatican , the Vatican owes the Jews 2000 years of royalties for using one of ours as their God.

  32. The Jews said "let His blood be on us and our children", JESUS said "I lay my life down and I will take it up again. The Jews are in Their Land now forever and I'm sure Rabbi Yitsak Kaduri got it right.

  33. Christopher Norton, you are the person I was speaking about above. The gospels are not historical. There are so many reasons and proofs against historicity I couldn’t begin to expound on it. To this person, none of these arguments in the article will avail. Why do the Jews hate Jesus? They don’t. They fear Christians.

  34. The reasons why the Jews reject Jesus is that Christian beliefs about Jesus are UnBiblical. Christians claim Jesus died for the sins of humanity, but the Bible states, "Eesh b'chet-o yu-ma-tu, every man shall be put to death for his own sin," in Deuteronomy 24:16, among other places. Christians claim that Jesus was Gd, but Gd tell us, "For I am Gd and not a man," in Hosea 11:9, among other places. Christians claim that Jesus was a part of a trinity, but the the Bible states, "Thus saith the Etrnl the King of Israel, and his redeemer the Etrnl of hosts; I am the first, and I am the last; and beside me there is no Gd," in Isaiah 44:6, but if Gd is the first, then Gd has no Father, and if Gd is the last, then Gd has no son, and if besides Gd there is no other, then Gd does not share being Gd with another entity. Christians claim that Jesus was the necessary blood sacrifice for the forgiveness of sin, but who did the dying in order to be that blood sacrifice? Was it Jesus-the-god, or was it Jesus-the-man who did the dying? Gd cannot die, so it was Jesus-the-human, so Christianity is based on a human sacrifice, and the Bible tells us that Gd calls human sacrifice an abomination and something Gd hates in Deuteronomy 12:31, "..for every abomination to the Etrnl, which He hateth, have they done unto their gods; for even their sons and their daughters they have burnt in the fire to their gods." This assumes that Gd requires a blood sacrifice for the forgiveness of sin, which the book of Jonah, among other places, shows is untrue. The Christian beliefs about Jesus have more in common with the dying/saving pagan man/gods of the ancient world, than with anything in the TaNaCH or in Judaism over the last 4,000 years, give or take. The statement, "his mother was human, his father was god,' sounds like Jesus, but it also sounds like Hercules, Dionysus (a savior god) and Perseus (whose human mother did not become pregnant from the sex act, like a virgin birth). For more on all this, see http://WhatJewsBelieve.org .

  35. Anonymous says:

    Some of the followers of JC will never accept the fact that Jews never crucified anyone. That was a Roman form of punishment. Their "saviour" is quoted in the gospels as saying not to change one letter of the Torah or to add or subtract from it. That too is not accepted by his followers. The faith of his followers was invented many years after his death with antio-semitism incorporated into it because we didn't accept him as the messiah. The fact that we didn't accept him and that we are still here as a people is an affront to their faith.

  36. Dan Riser says:

    Jesus came to save us all. Each of our sins nailed Him to that cross.

  37. Anonymous says:

    It was the Romans.

  38. Juan Gomez says:

    Nobody killed Jesus, he said it himself . John 10:18 “No one takes it from me, but I lay it down of my own accord. I have authority to lay it down, and I have authority to take it up again. This charge I have received from my Father.”

  39. The Romans didn’t kill Y’shua .Y’shua said ,I lay down my life for the sheep and I will raise it up again .The Romans nailed Y’Shua to a stake but Y’shua gave up His own Spirit :-)

  40. You have clues all through their book, ‘We have no king but Caesar” which is a sentiment more general than Jewish, and well known. But trying to reject the charge means someone somehow feels guilty. There was nothing any more damnable about killing this Jew than the thousands by by Rome and millions killed by Christianity later.

  41. You have clues all through their book, ‘We have no king but Caesar” which is a sentiment more general than Jewish, and well known. But trying to reject the charge means someone somehow feels guilty. There was nothing any more damnable about killing this Jew than the thousands by by Rome and millions killed by Christianity later.

  42. I stand with the writer in his comments, but not necessarily his conclusions. First of all the New Testament was given by the Catholic religion who hated and continue to hate both the Jews and the written Torah. They are of the Synagogue of Satan and like Nimrod, hunt the souls of men to turn them from G-d. The Catholic religion is not a Christian religion, it is pagan in origin and concept. They have twisted the truth and instituted a replacement religion and a replacement, i.e. surrogate Messiah, whom they call 'Christ'. The New Testament was altered to conform to the pagan doctrines, traditions, and practices of that time, which were instituted to 'replace' the Sabbaths and Holy Assemblies commanded in Scripture. The name Jesus is not a translation from Hebrew to Greek and English, it is a transition from the Greek god Zeus, Ie-sous, Jesu, Jesus, which is a surrogate name.
    One time a Catholic, who hated Jews, said to me, "Do you know who killed Jesus?" I answered on the basis of Catholic and Protestant theology: "Yes I know who killed Jesus … YOU DID!. Had you not sinned He would not have had to come to die for your sins." I forced him to accept his own contribution to the death of Jesus. I did not debate the correctness of his theology, I only forced him to come to accept his own theological beliefs. It was he who killed his christ.

  43. Perfect explanation….Dan. The SON and the HOLY SPIRIT aka the SPIRIT of GOD were always with FATHER GOD from the beginning. YESHUA is ALL thru the First Testament especially Isaiah

  44. It's sad to read that so many do not see YESHUA bring the FATHERS PROMISES to completion…fulfilling the "LAW".

  45. There are many problems with the gospel accounts ofthe events leading up to the death of Jesus. The gospels were written decades after the events, by writers ignorant of or hostile to Jewish laws and customs. Eg the Sanhedrin would have been forbidden to meet to condemn Jesus on Passover. It is not blasphemous for a Jew to claim to be the Messiah, since he is not divine. There have been a few claimants, all mistaken so far. The meeting of the Sanhedrin could not have taken place,

    William Nicholls
    Professor Emeritus of Religious Studies
    University of British Columbia

  46. Brom Bones says:

    It's just an allegory meaning Jews kill the truth. Christ stood as the symbol of truth and light. That is why Jews all over are trying to pass "hate speech" laws that forbid talking about their control of the media or banks, or investigations of the holocaust hoax under penalties of imprisonment. They are "crucifying" the truth again.

  47. Jesus was NOT killed or murdered, as some people like to say. Jesus purposely LAID DOWN His life in order to restore the relationship between God and man-kind, as it was in the first two chapters of Genesis before sin entered. As for the people themselves involved–the True Jewish members of the Sanhedrin back in the time of Jesus, were against the crucifixion. The others, including Annas and Caiaphas, were appointed by the Romans, like Herod Antipas and his father Herod the (Not so) Great, from the Armenians. This is why John the Baptist was not in the Temple performing the duties of a priest. John was the son of Zechariah, a priest. Therefore, it was his duty to be in the Temple. But when the Romans began occupying the territory, they “threw out” the Jewish priests and instilled their own people. THESE are the ones who crucified Jesus!! But ultimately, it was OUR OWN SIN that caused His death–for He took upon Himself the sin of the whole world!

  48. Brom Bones says:

    Right, as usual.

  49. The birth of antisemitism comes from the Christians? Hey doofus, the Egyptians hated the Jews when they lived in Goshen, the Babylonians hate the Jews and took them captive, the Romans hated the Jews long before there were Christians. Get a grip, learn some history. AntiSemitism has been around for a long long time!

  50. If we're going to follow Christian logic, G-d must have said… I'm going to create man and woman with original sin. Then I'm going to impregnate a woman with myself as a child, so that I can be born as human. Once alive, I will kill myself as a sacrifice to myself. To save you from the sin I originally condemned you to.

  51. Jeff Pergament says:


Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
ISIS executioner holding British aid worker Alan Henning as a hostage.
Muslims Plead with ISIS for Life of UK Aid Worker Alan Henning
Latest Indepth Stories
IDF lone soldier and  David Menachem Gordon (z"l).

Why has his death been treated by some as an invitation for an emotional “autopsy”?


SWOT analysis: Assessing resources, internal Strengths&Weaknesses; external Opportunities&Threats.


Strategy? For the longest time Obama couldn’t be bothered to have one against a sworn enemy.


Seventeen visual skills are needed for success in school, sports, and everyday life.

We started The Jewish Press. Arnie was an integral part of the paper.

Fear alone is substantial; without fusing it to beauty, fear doesn’t reach its highest potential.

Fortunate are we to have Rosh Hashanah for repentance, a shofar to awaken heavenly mercy.

Arab leaders who want the US to stop Islamic State are afraid of being dubbed traitors and US agents

National Lawyers Guild:Sworn enemy of Israel & the legal arm of Palestinian terrorism since the ’70s

A little less than 10 percent of eligible Democratic voters came out on primary day, which translates into Mr. Cuomo having received the support of 6.2 percent of registered Democrats.

The reality, though, is that the Israeli “war crimes” scenario will likely be played out among highly partisan UN agencies, NGOs, and perhaps even the International Criminal Court.

Peace or the lack of it between Israel and the Palestinians matters not one whit when it comes to the long-term agenda of ISIS and other Islamists, nor does it affect any of the long-running inter-Arab conflicts and wars.

Rather than serving as a deterrent against terrorist attacks, Israel’s military strength and capabilities are instead looked at as an unfair advantage in the asymmetrical war in which it finds itself.

Sisi:”The religious nature of the Middle East creates challenges for the governing authorities.”

More Articles from Gil Solomon
Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu.

Foolish me, thinking the goals were the destruction of Hamas thereby giving peace a real chance.


What would Putin do were his country to be faced with constant rocket barrages from over the border?

Is Kerry an Emperor who issues decrees from on high over which poor ghetto Jews have no power whatsoever?

Abbas will have his endless war, whether Israel likes it or not.

Obama and Kerry aim to destroy Israel one way or another.

Under Roman law, calls for a messianic monarchy within the Republic would have been a treasonable offense.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/opinions/jews-killed-nobody/2014/01/06/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: