It is very easy to catch a thief when one has clues and evidence. It is a far different matter, however, when one must attempt to find the guilty party through his own wits alone. It is then that we must have a truly wise man- one as wise as, say Shlomo HaMelech.
Along a lonely country road came three people, merchants who had just completed profitable business transactions. It was a Friday afternoon, and as the hours dragged by, the travelers saw that the sun was about to set and they would not possibly be able to reach town before Shabbos.
“I see that we shall have to camp here for tonight,” said one. “I suggest that since we are forbidden to carry money, we bury it all in one spot and leave it there until after Shabbos.”
“That is a good idea,” agreed the other two.
And so, the three merchants took all their valuables, and buried them together in one spot.
That night, however, one of the merchants waited until his comrades had fallen asleep and getting up stealthily, tiptoed to the place where the money was buried. Despite the fact that it was Shabbos, and despite the fact that it’s forbidden to steal, the thief dug up the money and then walking into the forest, hid it away where no one else would find it.
On Motzei Shabbos, the three merchants went to the place where the money was originally buried. Imagine their horror (that is, except for the thief) when they saw that the money was gone, obviously stolen by one of them.
Immediately, all three began to shout and yell at each other: “You are the thief!”
“No, you are!”
“No, you stole the money!”
After five minutes of accusation and name calling, one of the trio paused and said:
“We are never going to get anywhere this way. It is obviously impossible for us to find out which of us is the real thief. This is something that only a very great and very wise man can do. Let us therefore go to the court of that wisest of all men, Shlomo HaMelech.
Reaching the palace, the three had to wait their turn while hundreds of Jews with problems and lawsuits winded their way through the courtroom seeking justice and help. Finally the three reached the King’s throne.
“State your case,” ordered Shlomo HaMelech.
“Oh great king,” began the merchant, “we have a most difficult problem that we are unable to solve. We have therefore come to you, in the hope that you in your great G-d given wisdom will be able to catch a thief.”
The merchants then proceeded to tell the king how they had hidden their money because of the approach of Shabbos; how during the night, one of them must have awakened and transferred the money to some hidden spot. Now they were at a loss to know how to find the thief, since there were no witnesses or indeed any evidence which might point to one person’s guilt.
Shlomo HaMelech sat in silence listening to the entire story. When the merchants had concluded, he sat without speaking.
Suddenly he announced, “Judgment is in the morning! Return tomorrow and I shall catch your thief.”
The following morning, court opened early, and the three merchants stood once again before the king.
The night before, Shlomo HaMelech had wracked his brain in an effort to find some way to discover the thief. He realized that without clues, his only path was to work through the personality and character of the thief and to trap him by his own words.
“Before I tell you who the thief is,” he began, “I would like your advice. I have heard that you are all wise and learned men, and so I will need your aid in a very perplexing problem that has arisen. Here is the story.”
The merchants were flattered that the wisest of all men should turn to them for advice, and they listened eagerly as the king expounded the problem.
“It appears,” began Shlomo HaMelech, “that there is a young boy who was a neighbor of a young girl his own age. They were very good friends, and became very attached to each other.
“One day, the boy said to the girl:
“‘Let us agree that if the day ever comes that one of us will desire to marry some other person that it shall not be done without the consent of the other one.’
“The young girl agreed and faithfully gave her word to be bound by the agreement.
“The years passed and the two drifted apart. The girl, however, never forgot her vow; and on the day that she became engaged, she told her prospective groom.
“‘I want you to know that I swore many years ago to a boy I knew that I would seek his consent for any marriage that I would enter. I must, therefore, before entering into our marriage, seek this consent from him.’
“‘I understand,’ replied her fiancée, ‘go seek out this person.’
“After many days they arrived at the home of the boy and there the girl began to plead with her old friend to release her:
“‘Take all my wealth if you wish,’ she cried, ‘but allow me to marry the one of my choice.’
“The boy looked at her and replied:
“‘Because you have faithfully observed our oath, I absolve you of it. Go and marry the one you love. And as for the money, I desire nothing from you.’
“Happily, the couple left the home of the boy and set out for home.
“As they were traveling, however, they were suddenly set upon by a band of robbers led by an old man. They were quickly overpowered and brought before the aged chieftain. He was struck by the beauty of the girl and declared his intentions of keeping her for his wife.
“‘Wait,’ cried the girl. ‘Before you do this thing, listen to my story.’
“And she began to tell the old bandit the entire story of her oath, her love for her fiancée and the absolution granted her by the boy.
“‘Now,’ she said, ‘consider carefully. Here was a young man in the prime of his life who had some claim on me and yet knew it would be wrong to hold me against my will. How much more so should this hold true for you who are an old man and a bandit.’
“Upon hearing the words of the maiden, the bandit lifted his eyes to heaven and declared:
“‘Behold, it is true that I am old and I walk daily along the edge of my grave, and how can I do such a terrible thing?’
“Turning to the couple then, he ordered that his bandits release them, wishing them farewell.”
Shlomo HaMelech ended his narrative and turned to the merchants:
“You have heard the story of the incident that occurred. The king in whose domain this occurred now wishes to know the following:
Which of the parties involved is to be the most highly praised?”
The merchants thought for a few moments, and then one spoke up:
“Surely the maiden is to be the most praised for having clung so steadfastly to her vow.”
“I disagree,” stated the second. “In my opinion, it is the betrothed who agreed to go along with her vow.”
“It is the bandit that I feel is the most praiseworthy,” answered the third, “for he had all the beautiful money, and nevertheless, returned it.”
When Shlomo HaMelech heard this, he leaped to his feet and pointing an accusing finger at the third merchant, declared:
“You are the thief! You are the only one who was so impressed by the money. Confess now!”
The merchant began to tremble and in a broken voice cried out: “Yes, yes, I am the thief.”
The people in the court were deeply impressed by this exhibition and “they saw that the wisdom of G-d was in his midst to do justice.”
About the Author:
If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.
Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.