Photo Credit: IDF Spokesman Unit
Brigadier General Ofer Winter

Brigadier General Ofer Winter on Sunday took up his new post as Commander of the IDF’s 98th Paratroopers Division, a.k.a. the Fire Formation and opened his acceptance notes with words of prayer and praise to God: “This is the day that God has made, let us exult and rejoice in it” (Psalms 118:24).

After the verse from the Hallel prayer, Winter added a personal prayer for his success in the new position: “God, give me humility, give me courage and give me the wisdom of the heart so that I know how to lead these people in the challenges we face.”


The IDF Spokesman’s report skipped all the clearly religious content in Winter’s remarks, noting instead that the new commander said: “Today I take upon myself the privilege to command and lead on this precious and significant division, with a sense of mission and great humility. I pledge to give my all and act with you, warriors and commanders, and continue to prepare for war and fight when necessary, using cunning and force in order to defeat the enemy and remove a threat from the people of Israel.”

Also good stuff, but absent any reference to the King of the Universe.

Winter caused a stir during the 2014 Gaza War, due to the battle order he issued his soldiers upon entering the Gaza Strip. He wrote that it is a great privilege to serve in the Givati ​​Brigade at this time, and that “history has chosen us to be at the forefront of the fight against the ‘Gazan’ terrorist, who defies and blasphemes the God of Israel.”

The reference here was clearly to Goliath, the Gazan Philistine who declared: “I herewith defy the ranks of Israel (I Samuel 17:10),” when he challenged the Israelites (until he met his end by the hand of a young, red headed shepherd named David son of Jesse). Incidentally, in Israel the secular schools teach a lot of bible, so it is reasonable to expect that all of Winter’s soldiers got the reference, equating Hamas with Goliath.

“We have prepared and laid out for this time and we take on the task with a complete sense of mission and humility, and because we are willing to take risks and give our lives in order to protect our families, our nation and our homeland.”

In the last paragraph of his 2014 battle order, Winter added: “I lift up my eyes to the heaven and call out with you, ‘Shema Israel, HaShem Elokeinu, Hashem Echad.’ The God of Israel, please support us as we are going to fight for Your nation Israel against the enemy who despises your name. On behalf of the IDF fighters and in particular the brigade’s fighters and commanders, please apply to us the scripture that says, For it is your God who marches with you to do battle for you against your enemy, to bring you victory (Deuteronomy 20:4).”

The commander’s message was published in the general media and sparked controversy as to whether a religious commander should involve God in his leadership of his soldiers. During the ensuing operation, the brigade unveiled terrorist tunnels and infrastructure used by Hamas, and participated in the battle of Rafah. Defense Minister Benny Gantz was part of the IDF brass that delayed Winter’s professional progress, pinning him for the misdeeds of a subordinate, but everybody knew they were teaching him a lesson for that Shema Israel thing.

According to a Ynet report in 2019, Gantz and his successor, Chief of Staff Gadi Eizenkot, were determined to bury Winter’s career, and it was the new IDF chief, Aviv Kochavi, who recognized his considerable skills and demanded his return to active command duty.

Share this article on WhatsApp:

Previous articlePalestinians: We Support China’s Muslim Concentration Camps
Next articleTel Aviv Municipality Presents: Israel’s First Floating Cinema
David writes news at