web analytics
November 29, 2014 / 7 Kislev, 5775
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post
IDC Herzliya Campus A Day on Campus

To mark IDC Herzliya’s 20th anniversary, we spent a day following Prof. Uriel Reichman, IDC’s founder and president, and Jonathan Davis, VP for External Relations, around its delightful campus.



Council of Europe Votes on Circumcision as Human Rights Violation

Banning Jewish circumcisions used to be anti-Semitic. Today it is called a “violation of human rights.” Why aren’t there protests for children’s rights to watch porno and get sick on junk food?

The influential European Council is voting Tuesday on whether to define ritual circumcision a "violation of human rights."

The influential European Council is voting Tuesday on whether to define ritual circumcision a "violation of human rights."

The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, an international organization whose resolutions are non-binding but heavily influence the European Unions, is voting Tuesday on defining ritual circumcision as a “clear human rights violation.”

A general report prepared for the Council reviewed female genital mutilation and added, “Circumcision applied to young boys clearly is a human rights violation against children.”

A German legislator, Marlene Rupprecht, who also is active on the Council’s Committee on Social Affairs, Health and Sustainable Development, presented the “Children’s Right to Physical Integrity” report.

Last week, Sweden politicians and physicians called for a ban on ritual circumcision of all boys under the age of 18.

“Circumcision without medical grounds can only be performed if a boy is of an age and maturity required to understand the information and consent to the surgery,” according to a statement.

The concept of a baby having “the right to choose” apparently applies only to circumcision, one of the most sacred Jewish rites. There have been no protests of the violation of their rights by parents who do not allow them to damage themselves by watching watch pornographic or violent movies and do not let them harm their bodies with junk food.

“This is the first time in recent memory that aggressive political attacks on milah have found a legitimate vehicle at the European level,” Milah UK, a British nongovernmental organization working to defend Jewish circumcision of boys, told JTA in a statement on the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe vote.

While the report will remain nonbinding even if passed, “it does clearly demonstrate that the sustained campaign to conflate the deplorable practice of female genital mutilation with milah is gaining traction at the highest levels,” according to Milah UK.

The JTA contributed to this report.

About the Author: Tzvi Ben Gedalyahu is a graduate in journalism and economics from The George Washington University. He has worked as a cub reporter in rural Virginia and as senior copy editor for major Canadian metropolitan dailies. Tzvi wrote for Arutz Sheva for several years before joining the Jewish Press.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

42 Responses to “Council of Europe Votes on Circumcision as Human Rights Violation”

  1. TeachESL says:

    JewishPress Time for all the Jews of Europe to leave and come to Israel.

  2. Amii Flanagan says:

    No comparison.

  3. Nathan Katz says:

    It is time for the few of us remaining in Europe to leave.

  4. Nathan Katz says:

    It is time for the few of us remaining in Europe to leave.

  5. Being a gentile is a human right violation.

  6. Shemayah Shiloh Phillips says:

    Being a gentile is a human right violation.

  7. David Kieserman says:

    B.S.

  8. Charna Carole Ball says:

    And go where? so awful. they tried to do this here in CA.

  9. And go where? so awful. they tried to do this here in CA.

  10. David Neubart says:

    But Muslims beheadings are not?

  11. But Muslims beheadings are not?

  12. Eugenio A. Alonso says:

    Time to leave Europe and leave it for the Arabs to rape.

  13. Time to leave Europe and leave it for the Arabs to rape.

  14. Randy Spate says:

    i was one who wasn't circumcised back in 1952 …. nor was my brother in 1949 but at 40 or so years old, it became a serious problem that the skin began to grow closed on both of us … i guarantee you it is worse to have that done at 40 and created serious health problems … so get off your high horses about what folks should or should not do… most physicians are not jewish yet advise their patients to do the right thing which is to circumcise the baby rather than the adult

  15. Candy Jenkins Hammond says:

    tell that to God!

  16. Candy Jenkins Hammond says:

    no it’s not. don’t be ridiculous ! God had mercy on you and suggests you don’t forget that . Be a light.

  17. no it’s not. don’t be ridiculous ! God had mercy on you and suggests you don’t forget that . Be a light.

  18. Shemayah Shiloh Phillips says:

    America will follow.

  19. RebeccaFine says:

    Are Europeans aware that there are also health benefits to circumcision?  In the United States, the majority of non-Jewish boys are circumcised.

  20. I wish you were just as passionate about protecting unborn baby's rights to live.

  21. Lamargo L. Petersen says:

    I seem to recall that the United Nations made a law for protecting children.

  22. UnivLaurel says:

    RebeccaFine  
    Europeans are all too well aware that the claims of ‘health benefits’ are fallicious.

  23. Madsws says:

    oivindman Hva er egentlig coe? Har du link til deres offisielle uttalelse?

  24. Myriam Obadia says:

    Max, Since G-d created us the way we should be, we shouldn't perform any surgery, even if it's life-saving because, after all, maybe G-d decided it's our time to die, no? We should also quit those silly vaccination and medical treatment habits, because he is also the creator of the bacteria and viruses. It's awfully arrogant of us to feel we are worthier than his other creatures, n'est-ce pas? Ever heard of the concept of Tikkun Olam? Currently, South Africa is importing Rabbis to teach their doctors how to circumcise the boys to get a higher survival rate in male babies and, on average, a circumcised man lives 10 years longer than a man who isn't. That's what has been actually proven. Now, if you think that this 5000 years old tradition practiced by all North African and Middle Eastern people is so bad, don't do it to your sons. No one is forcing you. I just hope you won't have to deal with a teenager with phimosis, because it's a lot more painful when the nerve endings have matured.

  25. oivindman says:

    Madsws hørt om Europarådet der Thorbjørn Jagland er generalsekretær? http://t.co/vADdW3qs72 http://t.co/qdGGrg9X9t

  26. oivindman says:

    .Madsws d r PACE (Europarådets parlamentariske forsamling http://t.co/Z5LS0B39vX) som stemte gjennom Rupprechts plan http://t.co/sQOq9Np5nY

  27. Yechiel Baum says:

    Circumscusion has proven to be healthy for me. If those UN activists are against healthy circumscion, then they should not be circunsized and nor should their sons so they life expectancy is shorten- either way, they are circumsized by life expectancy or their penis size bit women tell me they find more please from circumsized men so obviously they have a problem in their inability.

  28. Seshemisham says:

    Marlene Rupprecht is worth a closer look I think. She is responsible for childrens issues in the German Socialdemocratic party the SPD, previously a teacher in a school for educationally subnormal children, was one of the main circumcision opponents in the Bundestag, the German parlament. Here is what she said in an article of “Die Zeit Online”: “I don’t want that Germany will be remembered in history as the country that legalized physical injury to defenseless children because of some scriptural passages and traditions some thousand years old. Respecting life – this is what we should have learned from the Nazi era!” She is 65 and sees herself as very religious. “G’d made us perfect, he doesn’t want us to cut something away. As especially the Jews were a people with a learning potential they should be careful not to harden too much in the diaspora sticking to traditions outdated a long time ago.” She said she was reluctant to use force, it would be better the jewish parents would see that by themselves. She would do everything to revive Jewish life in Germany. But she was cross that Jewish circles used the “Shoah club and all that” and that then everybody gave in. She had the deepest respect for the Jewish and the Muslim religion in Germany “but we are not a religious state. Here the Grundgesetz, the Constitutional law is in force. No religion stands above it.”
    For those who read German here is the link: http://www.zeit.de/2012/42/Beschneidung-Gesetz

  29. James Loewen says:

    Michael Dulin, I see your comment to Yechiel Baum here on your facebook page but not on the jewishpress page. Makes me wonder if they are censoring comments, or experiencing serious "glitches" with their system for comments, again.

  30. RicardoD says:

    Seshemisham Thank you for this summary. I had been hoping to learn more about her.

  31. Becky McBride Wierzbicki says:

    We all need a cause to believe you…good for you.

  32. Cynthia Denomme Maurer says:

    So what? Who the hell are they?

  33. How do you know what your lifetime health and sexual history would have been like had you not been circumcised??
    Life expectancy at birth in the USA is one of the very worst of any western nation. Major factors at play are drug overdoses and murder. The Japanese have the longest life expectancy, and seldom circumcise.
    Contemporary mores humour women who have a number of sexual partners between the time they leave for college, and when they settle down in their 20s with one man. American universities have many foreign students. Hence it is not hard for American women to have college flings with both kinds of men. Some women who have done this have used social media to share that they prefer intact.

  34. myrick says:

    I never heard of the “Parliamentary
    Assembly of the Council of Europe” before this brouhaha. I bet it is, in effect, an NGO.

    “…an international organization whose
    resolutions are non-binding but heavily influence the European Unions [sic]“It sounds like a large committee filled with well-educated people with opinions and goals, a sandbox where Scandinavian idealists can play. I bet the European heavyweights, France, Germany and the UK, pay it little mind.

  35. myrick says:

    @Shemayah Shiloh Phillips: It is extremely unlikely that states or Congress will ever pass a law saying anything about Jewish or Moslem ritual circumcision, other than it must be performed by well trained persons.
    That said, our sexual and child rearing cultures are evolving in such a way that the circumcision of gentile boys will die out, because parents will see it as cruel and sexually damaging. This will create a serious dilemma for secular and progressive Jewish parents. “Uncircumcised Jew” is already not an oxymoron in Europe and Latin America, will acquire traction in the USA and Canada, and is an emerging category even in Israel, where many Jews are very secular.

  36. myrick says:

    @David Neubart : No one defends Moslem barbarity, especially honour killings. The Nordic defense of the natural penis is aimed at their growing Islamic minorities, with their very small Jewish communities being “collateral damage”.

  37. myrick says:

    @Charna Carole Ball : And got nowhere at all.

  38. myrick says:

    @Shemayah Shiloh Phillips : Sir, I invite you to be a part of the solution, not part of the problem.

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry .
NYT Ignores US Condemnation of PA Incitement, Prints Info on Ferguson Cop
Latest News Stories
U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry .

The NYT published sensitive info on a Ferguson cop — but ignored a US condemnation of terror.

It's business as usual as Gazans repair the tunnels used to smuggle in the long-range rockets that hit Tel Aviv.

Some of these Gazan tunnels were estimated to have cost $3 million to construct, but will they sustain continued flooding by rain and sewer water?

IDF Chief Rabbi Rafi Peretz delivers lecture.

“Ninety percent of them [Arabs] don’t know what is written in the Kuran.”

Soldiers start asking questions after Arab sniper narrowly misses killing Jewish motorist on Highway 60, south of Jerusalem.

“Lone wolves” trying to murder Jews are popping up too frequently.

The Gurlitt Museum promises all looted art will be returned to the rightful owners.

Liberal Jews are for tolerance until they also have to be tolerant.

Israeli Shayetet 13 Naval commandos discovered a wounded fellow swimmer in the water, while they were doing a training exercise on Thursday morning. The commandos helped and treated the dolphin until a marine animal doctor could arrive to help it further. By the way, the temperature in Israel was between 52-66 degree Fahrenheit on Thursday, […]

A pre-Thanksgiving speech for Americans. Obama, are you listening?

“You’ve been hacked by the Syrian Electronic Army.”

Murderers have upgraded their weapons from rocks and firebombs to guns.

Thanksgiving is an American secular holiday that most Jews have no problem celebrating due to its lack of overt religious symbols (unlike the American holidays right before and after it). Still, there are always holdouts for some reason or another. Let’s hear what you do…

Maybe he thought those white hoods are prayer shawls although they are closer to being burkas.

As the expression goes, “Don’t bring a knife to a gunfight.”

Hamas snipers fired from Gaza at an IDF routine patrol operating along the security fence early afternoon on Thursday. No injuries were reported, and the vehicle was damaged. The IDF responded with an artillery shell aimed at the source of fire.

Jacob Richman found this amusing mistake in the store. Do we eat these “extra crispy” soap nuts, or wash the dishes with them?

For every terrorist cell Israel announces it has captured, there are many more kept under wraps.

More Articles from Tzvi Ben-Gedalyahu
IDF Chief Rabbi Rafi Peretz delivers lecture.

“Ninety percent of them [Arabs] don’t know what is written in the Kuran.”

Soldiers start asking questions after Arab sniper narrowly misses killing Jewish motorist on Highway 60, south of Jerusalem.

“Lone wolves” trying to murder Jews are popping up too frequently.

Liberal Jews are for tolerance until they also have to be tolerant.

A pre-Thanksgiving speech for Americans. Obama, are you listening?

“You’ve been hacked by the Syrian Electronic Army.”

Murderers have upgraded their weapons from rocks and firebombs to guns.

Maybe he thought those white hoods are prayer shawls although they are closer to being burkas.

For every terrorist cell Israel announces it has captured, there are many more kept under wraps.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/council-of-europe-votes-on-circumcision-as-human-rights-violation/2013/10/01/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: