web analytics
May 23, 2015 / 5 Sivan, 5775
At a Glance
Kidz
Sponsored Post


Shemayah and Avtalyon


Tales-of-The-Midrash-logo

One of the disciples overheard this conversation and said, “G-d forbid that Rabi Shimon should be embarrassed; it would lead to the Prince’s disgrace.”

Feeling that it would be wrong to disclose the plot openly, he went and sat down outside of Rabi Shimon’s study and began expounding on Uktzin aloud, repeating it again and again.

Hearing this, Rabbi Shimon was perplexed. “What is going on?” he wondered. “Perhaps something is brewing at the college and this was done to call it to my attention.” He concentrated his attention on this tract and he soon knew it perfectly.

 

The Punishment The following day when the Rabi Shimon arrived, Rabi Meir arose and said, “Will the master teach us the tract Uktzin?” Rabi Shimon obliged and lectured on that subject. After he had finished, he said to them, “Had I not familiarized myself with this subject, you would have put me to public shame.” He thereupon gave the order to expel them. They did not take this lying down. They would write out questions on slips of paper and throw them into the beis medrash. When they could not be solved, they would write out the answers and send them back.

Rabi Jose arose and in an exasperated tone said, “The Torah is without (the knowledge is outside) and we remain within!”

Rabi Shimon, realizing that this might lead to open revolt, thereupon retracted his expulsion order and said, “Let them come back. However, they must be pun­ished that no halacha shall be reported in their name. They must not receive any credit for a law.”

Henceforth, Rabi Meir was named “Anonymous” and Rabi Natan, “Some say.” Sometime later, they both had dreams urging them to seek reconciliation with Rabi Shimon. Rabi Natan did so, but Rabi Meir did not, say­ing that dreams are not to be followed and are of no conse­quence.

When Rabi Natan finally came for reconciliation, Rabi Shimon said to him, “Granted that your father’s influence helped you to become the chief justice, but could it have helped you to become a prince?”

It was many years later that Rabi Shimon’s grandson returned the honor to Rabi Meir and quoted his name, say­ing, “It was said in the name of Rabi Meir.”

About the Author:


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

No Responses to “Shemayah and Avtalyon”

Comments are closed.

Current Top Story
Tzipi Hotovely, new Deputy Foreign Minister.
Foreign Minister Hotovely: Tell the World ‘God Gave Israel to the Jews’
Latest Kidz Stories
Gaonim-Midrash-logo-NEW

The great giant of his time, the Vilna Gaon, once said that the Shaagas Aryeh had the entire Talmud and its commentators at his fingertips and that he could relate the gist of all of them and their sources in one hour.

Gaonim-Midrash-logo-NEW

As for myself, I can only answer that the yetzer hara has persuaded me to take the position because of the honor.

Gaonim-Midrash-logo-NEW

“It must be that beggar,” he exclaimed. “He probably stole my cane.”

Gaonim-Midrash-logo-NEW

“If, however, he rules the other way – that something is not kosher when in reality it is kosher – and thus robs a poor man of his money, this is a far more serious thing.

“Come now, I insist. Tell me what errand of mercy you are on so that I too may have a share in the mitzvah.”

One of the most remarkable men in chassidic lore was Rav Yaakov Yitzchak Horowitz, known as the Chozeh of Lublin. Rav Yaakov Yitzchak was responsible for chassidus capturing the hearts of the vast majority of Polish Jewry. He was not only a great scholar but also possessed humility and modesty, traits that drew many other […]

The story of the Bnei Yisrael in the land of Mitzrayim is a tale that has become tragically repetitive in the history of our people. It is the story of a land which allows Jews to enter, devote their talents and energies to building that land and making it strong, only to have the inhabitants […]

The man has been found guilty and his soul is bitter because of it.

Now I know why Hashem punished us with the confiscation of our shul.

But the words would penetrate their hearts and each would say to himself: “But I, too, am doing this terrible thing.” In this way Reb Elimelech would inspire the people to teshuvah.

“I will tell you,” replied the rav. “I am very puzzled at why you suddenly desire to honor me and have me as your guest. What quality do you find in me that is new and worthy of merit?

“I wanted you to have a taste of the cold,” answered Rav Chaim. “This way, you too can feel the intense cold and realize the suffering of this man and his wife, who are now residing in a bitterly cold house.”

“Don’t worry,” said the king, “what could it be worth, two or three talents of gold? I’ll give you ten talents of gold, so you can forget about it.”

Shmuel HaKatan shook his head and said: “No, what happened here today is a sign not of great love. On the contrary, it is a bad omen.”

The arguments, however, could never appease his wife and one Thursday she came to him for money to purchase food for Shabbos.

He walked out of the room, making sure to leave the door ajar so that the two litigants could hear his voice.

More Articles from Rabbi Sholom Klass
Gaonim-Midrash-logo-NEW

The great giant of his time, the Vilna Gaon, once said that the Shaagas Aryeh had the entire Talmud and its commentators at his fingertips and that he could relate the gist of all of them and their sources in one hour.

Gaonim-Midrash-logo-NEW

As for myself, I can only answer that the yetzer hara has persuaded me to take the position because of the honor.

“It must be that beggar,” he exclaimed. “He probably stole my cane.”

“If, however, he rules the other way – that something is not kosher when in reality it is kosher – and thus robs a poor man of his money, this is a far more serious thing.

“Come now, I insist. Tell me what errand of mercy you are on so that I too may have a share in the mitzvah.”

One of the most remarkable men in chassidic lore was Rav Yaakov Yitzchak Horowitz, known as the Chozeh of Lublin. Rav Yaakov Yitzchak was responsible for chassidus capturing the hearts of the vast majority of Polish Jewry. He was not only a great scholar but also possessed humility and modesty, traits that drew many other […]

The story of the Bnei Yisrael in the land of Mitzrayim is a tale that has become tragically repetitive in the history of our people. It is the story of a land which allows Jews to enter, devote their talents and energies to building that land and making it strong, only to have the inhabitants […]

The man has been found guilty and his soul is bitter because of it.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/kidz/midrash-stories/shemayah-and-avtalyon/2011/12/05/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: