Photo Credit: David Vaaknin / POOL / Flash 90
An exultant Balad MK Hanin Zoabi after successfully appealing her disqualification to run in the 2015 national elections.

Israel’s High Court has ruled that Israeli Arab candidate Balad MK Hanin Zoabi can run for re-election — despite her numerous statements, and actions, in support of terrorists from the Palestinian Authority.

In addition, the Court ruled Israel’s electoral authority must also allow Yachad candidate Baruch Marzel to run in the country’s national election on March 17 as well.

Advertisement



A panel of nine judges voted 8-1 in favor of reinstating both, with Deputy Supreme Court President Elyakim Rubenstein as the sole dissenting justice. The decision on the matter was moved up due to the proximity of the election.

Zoabi had been disqualified from running for the Balad Knesset seat by an overwhelming majority of the Central Elections Committee. This is the second time the High Court has overturned such a decision; a similar move took place just prior to the election of 2013.

Adalah NGO attorney Hassan Jabareen argued before the Court that all six statements attributed to the Balad MK that were used to disqualify her from running would “fall apart” once they were “placed into context.” Zoabi, he said, would be found to exhibit a record of consistent opposition to violence once her statements were examined, despite her statements in support of the Palestinian Authority.

Considering the law – and only the law – meant Zoabi’s recent six-month suspension by the Knesset also had no bearing on the case, he added. The MK’s recent visit to Qatar likewise was ruled a non-issue, inasmuch as Qatar is not considered an enemy state: Israel and Qatar actually do trade with each other.

Although the state described the MK’s conduct as “very troubling” it found that in principle it was forced to agree with Jabareen that there was no legal basis for her disqualification.

Nevertheless, attorney Yoav Mani, arguing for Yisrael Beytenu, warned the Court was setting the bar at an unreachable “high” in terms of the standard for evidence for disqualification. “When do you decide that enough is enough?” he asked. It was not about what the MK would do, Mani said – “say you’re against [her views] because they’re against who we are!”

Arguments for and against the disqualification of Baruch Marzel, candidate for the Yachad faction, were equally fierce.

Attorney Itamar Ben-Gvir argued – as had Zoabi’s lawyer – that Marzel’s statements had largely been taken out of context, and in some cases “he didn’t say them at all!”

He also contended that saying “Kahane was right” did not constitute a crime, nor did it violate the standard for election law violation. Marzel, once a member and leader in the banned “Kach” movement, had changed over the years, Ben-Gvir argued – but public and court opinion may not take that into account, with memory casting its long shadows back into the past instead.

A statement by Marzel made after an attack on a Jerusalem school that focuses efforts on co-existence was examined: the Court questioned its “anti-Arab” tone while Ben-Gvir said the intent was an expression of doubt that co-existence is possible today.

As with Zoabi, Rubinstein dissented, saying it seems likely Marzel has not changed at all. “If it walks and talks like a duck, why isn’t it a duck?” the judge asked.

Nevertheless, both candidates, seen as extremists by each others’ constituencies, are back in the race and will run for election with their parties on March 17.

Advertisement

SHARE
Previous articleLiberal Rising Star Elizabeth Warren: Where Does She Stand On Israel?
Next articleLetters To The Editor
JewishPress.com brings you the latest in Jewish news from around the world. Stay up to date by following up on Facebook and Twitter. Do you have something noteworthy to report? Submit your news story to us here.

13 COMMENTS

  1. Israel's Supreme Court is and has always been a danger to the integrity and security of Jews (the world over). It has nullified a reasonable legislative action – disqualifying the execrable Zoabi – has equated her with Marzel, a person whose views on security, if presented to any objective human without mentioning "Israel," are very reasonable. IN fact, Kahane was more right than Rabin and Peres and the other destructive leaders of Israel who are responsible for the death of many Jews thanks to their policy of appeasement that has inspired two generations of Arabs who, as a result, go and commit crimes of terror against Jews.

  2. this is what happens when a country has a supreme court but no constitution. What exactly is the purpose of Israeli Supreme Court? What does it use to guide them? clearly neither Jewish Law, nor common sense – both of which are anathema to most of the Supreme Court Judges.

  3. Exactly! Exactly what I predicted. I totally guessed the Israeli Supreme Court would allow Marzel ש"י in order to give the Looney Left the excuse they were looking for to allow Zoabi ימ"ש to run too. In fact, it is probably just the opposite. It became way too difficult for these leftist Oligarchs to disqualify Marzel without also disqualifying Zoabi. So they were left with little choice but to allow Marzel in order to allow Zoabi. So in truth, Marzel really needs to "thank" Zoabi that he was allowed to run at all. And look my brothers, it could have been much worse. When the Israeli Leftist Supreme Court struck down Kahana הי"ד in 1984 they simultaneously allowed a vicious Jew Hater to run at the same time. But all is well and soon Marzel can show his 'appreciation' to Zoabi as often as he wishes during the coming Knesset Term.

  4. What game changer? Are you kidding? Your video is a childish utopia. Islam is not "one of the three great Abrahamic religions". It's a pagan religion, that has nothing to do with Abraham. There is a lot of literature on this subject and of course Torah is the major source of information. When Jews, and especially religious Jews, are saying this, it's just scary, it means that they have no knowledge, and no understanding of the situation.

Comments are closed.

Loading Facebook Comments ...