Photo Credit: Yonatan Sindel/Flash90
Who the heck cares if some gentile denies that our millions of brothers and sisters were murdered in the Holocaust? Why should their opinion matter?

Last week I published here an article about an international committee that set out to establish, once and for all, what constitutes Holocaust denial. I wrote the story in near-deadpan delivery, believing in the power of the nonsensical assertions on the part of the government official making those pronouncements to provide its own tongue in cheek: the newly accepted definition of a holocaust denier is “anyone who doubts the number of Jews killed, who denies the existence of the gas chambers, as well as anyone who claims the Jews have brought on the holocaust intentionally, to serve their own ends, such as the establishment of the State of Israel, and also anyone who includes the 1939-1945 holocaust among other great tragedies in human history.”

The child of a Holocaust survivor, I’ve long since learned to own my father’s experience and my own consequent complex emotional ties with those dreadful years. I also believe I’ve earned the right to speak out on these issues honestly and fearlessly. There are no sacred cows in my Holocaust meadow.


I also believe the Holocaust is a purely Jewish issue, painfully intimate, like the destruction of two temples we mourn on Tisha B’Av. Who the heck cares what some gentile thinks about Tisha B’Av? In that same vain, who the heck cares if some gentile denies that my grandfather, Chanina Yanover, may God avenge his blood, was murdered in Auschwitz?

But I didn’t add that last paragraph, just relied on the deadpan delivery to deliver the message.

And then the Nazis showed up, at the comments section. I’m saying “Nazis” for shorthand. I’m sure many of them are not Nazis, not even remotely related to any Nazi or neo-Nazi group, but when there’s a wave happening, it tends to obscure the subtle differences between innocent commenters and dedicated followers of the Führer. For sure, my article was cited lavishly on neo-Nazi forums out there, and their readers took the link ride over to our own corner of the Web.

Here’s a chilling one, from Jonna Larsen, of Lyngby, Kobenhavn, Denmark:

“The time is not far away when Jews like Moshe Kantor, president of EJC, Abe Foxman, of the ADL and Zuroff and Cooper from the Wiesenthal Center, as well as a whole bunch of other prominent censorship promoting Jews, will fall victim to the laws they designed themselves. “

OK, very critical but still reasonable. Then she writes this:

“I seriously think of finding a good opportunity to put one or more of these people on trial for their endless slander and hate speech against white people, Christians, whole Nations and other groups and individuals who oppose the efforts of international Zionist Jewry to darken the world with their heinous proposals for censorship and state prescribed enforced history, thereby undermining the very corner stone of Western Civilization.”

Now, that’s Nazi talk, girl, don’t you know that? Don’t you know if you keep talking like that you’ll get a hairy, Chaplin style moustache growing right under your nose? Oh, but she goes on:

“The main part of organized Jewry is a threat to all other peoples on earth wherever it manifests itself politically. Always mongering for war, always (more or less legally) bribing their way in order to get the results they want. More special rights for Jews, including animal abuse and bodily mutilation of infants, more wars for Israel, mass immigration, censorship and hate speech laws for the Goyim.”

And she’s frothing at the mouth at this point, making it difficult to understand which specific Jew things she’s hating.

So that one was truly vile. At that point, our website boss, Steve, who had been fighting bravely to chop off those five-headed dragon messages, was getting a serious case of carpal tunnel syndrome. The last time he had to work so hard to clean up the messages was when I suggested the Turkish head of Intelligence who sold out Israeli agents to Iran deserved a spanking, causing approximately half of Turkey to visit us and express their unintelligible indignation. And before that, he had to fight the anti-Turks, when we ran here a few items by Turkish Muslims who love Israel. man, that caused a stir.



  1. Given the absolute fact that over 4 million non-Jews — homosexuals, gypsys, those considered mentally retarted, Communists, and many others who simply disagreed with Hitler were murdered in the same death camps at the same time and by the same Zyklon-B, bullets, carbon monoxide, and disease that Hitler used to kill the Jews with it's an outrageous canard on your part to say the Holocaust was only a "Jewish" issue.

    Your next couple of sentences belie your true bigotry. "Who cares if some gentile denies your grandfather was murdered?" Well plenty of them care that 6 million Jews were murdered, and that over 4 million others were too.

    The fact is that holocausts are far from unique. Let's start with the 30 million Stalin murdered, and continue with the 50 million slaughtered by Chairman Mao. More recently, there's been Pol Pot and the Hutus killing the Tutsis, the list goes on…

  2. A great number of people are foolish, misinformed, racist, and devoid of logical and critical thinking. Obama was elected…then re-elected. Proof. May God bless Israel and keep her safe.

  3. The whole of Jonna Larsen’s tirade of a more or less mysterious Jewish conspiracy against civilization sounds familiar. It’s heard before. It’s true Nazi babble.
    One can point out that some sad irony is in the fact that Nazi-occupied Europe sought to exterminate all of the European Jewry (approximated eleven million), because of a delusive concept of perceived danger.
    The irony is that today the European countries have allowed hordes of non-integrative people from the Middle East into Europe to benefit from the generous social welfare systems without prospect to work for their living. Furthermore these Muslim immigrants have just contempt for their host’s culture.
    Now Europe gets what it feared 70-80 years ago. The fear back then was delusive and sheer paranoia. To day it’s a living nightmare. European culture will be overruled by sharia law and semi-Christians will be reduced to dhimmi status in a dominant Islamic Europe.
    This fate is not due to The Russian Federation. They know the Muslims through several hundreds of years of co-existence – or something like it.

  4. Sounds like the re-hash ofd the protocols of the Elders of Zion dribble again! especial of this is the Mutilation of infants. I am such she is speak of the ritual ob Bris Malach ,our male entering into the Covent of our 8th. day of life. of course they always attack this first.. Russia was always the most strict about this , under death sentences if we did. Well, we did! For we are faithful to Hashem.

  5. Mr. Silagi, the reason the Jewish Shoah is the most important part of the Nazi killing enterprise is because Nazi Germany established itself on the basis of eliminating Jews from Germany. Please read all the Hitler speeches. Then count how many anti-Jewish ones there are, how many anti-Roma ones there are, & how many anti-disabled speeches there are. You will soon get the idea. Now the other killings are vital for the information they provide. It was because the disabled were killed, specifically gassed to death, that the mass killing of Jews became quite facile after Barbarossa began. The Roma were chosen after Nazi "science" revealed they suffered from genetically induced homelessness, petty theft, & prostitution (not true, but that's what the cause was said to be). Who kills prostitutes? Jack the Rippers, that's who. O Porrajmos shows that, at their best, the Nazi's were a bunch of worthless, scummy fiends, the kind who murder homeless victims to "clean up the neighborhood." Stalin never killed on a genetic basis. The "Holodomar" was known to be a fraud back in the 1930's. Just read Douglas Tottle's famed book if you doubt that. Stalin never set up factories of death; neither did he gather together thousands of CIVILIANS & shoot them dead in a single day on a regular basis.

  6. World wide anti-Semitism is proof that the Bible is true. In Moses day God told the Jews that if they turned their backs on him they would be cursed. And for the most part that is what they have done. (Deut, 28 Jewish Bible). In Jesus day, when Pontius Pilate told the Jews that they were responsible for putting Jesus to death, they called a curse on themselves when they cried: "Let his blood come upon us and our children !" (Matthew 27 New Testament). AND SO IT HAS !

  7. No mystery here, the one by the name of Silaghy is nothing less or more a Hungarian anti Semite, they were even worse than Germans, followed by the Lithuanians and poles. An ignorant peasant type, who wanted “research Semitic people” and ends up with Ashkenazis being Balkans, duhh yea, there are Sephardic and Ashkenazi Jews both Semitic tribes!

  8. Dear AJ Mac Donald,
    I suggest that you would complete more research on this subject. Not everyone's destination was to the ovens. If you do not have time to read up on the subject, I can suggest many fine documentaries of which you could educate yourself .

  9. Yeah, Stalin was really a great guy, as was Chairman Mao. And, after the war, when the Russians slaughtered everyone in Poland and Czechoslovakia with a German name, they were justified in doing so. They were no better than Hitler. Not a bit. And if the gulags weren't factories of death, just what were they? Places where they worked you to death? The Nazi concentration camps were too.

  10. Obama was re-elected through a tiny less-than-2-percent "majority". Putting that aside, what about the constant incoming stream of "new Obama voters" being shipped into the US, hidden and masked from the public eye. No. No need to answer. I can smell a greedy, treacherous fox from miles.

  11. Leslie Green – Sorry you are so ill informed and ignorant about what a racist is and Larry H. Gentry believes in what he is saying and what he clearly indicates is that people who voted for him are not too smart and only he is and that my friend is a statement rife with racism!

  12. Al Law Do you practice being stupid or were you born that way! First President Obama was reelected by a landslide! He won the popular vote by well over 5,000,000 million votes! and crushed willard by getting over 50% more in the electoral college! No matter what you say or what you think, you are wrong!

    You certainly are foolish to believe that there was any voter fraud and that massive amounts of illegal voters were allowed to vate! There is no basis in truth to that thinking and you certainly cannot prove it! If you think your are right and you can smell a "rat" I strongly suggest you see a ENT about your problem with your nose as it is not functioning correctly!

Comments are closed.

Loading Facebook Comments ...