web analytics
November 21, 2014 / 28 Heshvan, 5775
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post
IDC Herzliya Campus A Day on Campus

To mark IDC Herzliya’s 20th anniversary, we spent a day following Prof. Uriel Reichman, IDC’s founder and president, and Jonathan Davis, VP for External Relations, around its delightful campus.



KEEP PRAYING

Sharansky to Suggest Women’s Kotel Prayers Away from Main Plaza

Sharansky says the Western Wall is long enough for women to have their own minyan and Torah reading. The Women of the Wall leader accepts the compromise. Will the Rabbinate big enough to agree?

Jewish Agency Chairman Natan Sharansky

Jewish Agency Chairman Natan Sharansky
Photo Credit: Miriam Alster/Flash90

Jewish Agency chairman Natan Sharansky is preparing to suggest that women pray whenever they want, complete with prayer shawls and a Torah scroll, at the southern edge of the Western Wall, known as Robinson’s Arch.

The proposal was reported by the Forward, and afterwards the Jewish Agency released a fudgy statement that “Sharansky will present his recommendations to Prime Minister Netanyahu upon the chairman’s return to Israel from his visit to college campuses in the United States.”

“One Western Wall for one Jewish people,” Sharansky said, adding that he hopes his recommendations will allow “the Kotel will once again be a symbol of unity among the Jewish people, and not one of discord and strife.”

“Strife” is a police war. “Hatred,” ”jealousy” and “stiff-necked” are closer to the truth.

The Women of the Wall argue that the Haredi rabbis in charge of the Western Wall are insensitive to their needs and treat them as second-class citizens.

Although many if not most Orthodox rabbis in the United States have no problem with a women’s prayer minyan, the Chief Rabbinate as well as  and many non-Haredi Orthodox rabbis in Israeli have a problem with it, based on their application of Jewish law.

They charge that a women’s prayer minyan, complete with their own Torah reading, would offend their religious sensitivities.

An unstated but obviously huge difference is that there is no place for prayer in the Diaspora that has the holiness like the Western Wall, and there is no public area for prayer that is attended by both women and men.

The conflict will probably hit the headlines again Wednesday and Thursday, the two days that are the beginning of the Hebrew month of Iyar. The High Court has allowed the Women of the Wall to hold their own minyan at Robinson’s Arch, but the women demand they be allowed to pray at the more widely attended portion of the Western Wall.

Every Rosh Chodesh, they try to break the ban at the Western Wall and frequently are arrested. Pictures in  American media of a policeman struggling with a woman holding a Torah scroll have helped rip to the seams the fragile relationship between the Diaspora and Israel.

Sharansky has come up with a compromise that would give the women half of what they want and would spare the Western Wall rabbi and Haredi worshippers from having to pray at the Kotel while knowing a women’s minyan is taking place next to them, despite a partition, and being exposed to hearing women’s singing, which they consider a violation of Jewish law.

Anat Hoffman, leader of the WOW movement, previously has rejected what she calls a “separate but equal” solution.

Her position has been that having the right to pray in a separate minyan is only part of an overall goal, in her words, “to dismantle the Western Wall Heritage Foundation,” the Haredi Orthodox entity that oversees the Western Wall.”

After Sharansky’s proposal went public, she backed off and said she welcomes the compromise.

The idea is “very ambitious,” Hoffman said. ”You don’t always have to be right; you have to be smart — and compromise is a sign of maturity and understanding what’s at stake here.”

Neither side can get it wants without grossly offending the other, but the Haredi community cannot be expected to accept her agreement without suspicion.  If WOW want to pray as they wish, there is nothing to stop them from claiming they have the right to pray together with their husbands or male friends in a mixed minyan, which is totally prohibited in all Orthodox circles and would offend Orthodox worshippers.

But Hoffman appears to be smart enough to accept the Sharansky solution, putting the Western Wall rabbi in a position that he might as well agree gracefully rather than pitting himself against the entire political establishment outside of Haredi circles.

If he does agree, there is a good chance that the power of prayer can exceed political power.

About the Author: Tzvi Ben Gedalyahu is a graduate in journalism and economics from The George Washington University. He has worked as a cub reporter in rural Virginia and as senior copy editor for major Canadian metropolitan dailies. Tzvi wrote for Arutz Sheva for several years before joining the Jewish Press.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

11 Responses to “Sharansky to Suggest Women’s Kotel Prayers Away from Main Plaza”

  1. Dan Silagi says:

    If "one wall for all" is Scharansky's mantra, Robinson's arch hardly cuts it. For one thing, it's located away from the Kotel. For another, it's rocky and isn't set up to be a synagogue.

    This is like saying the "separate but equal" hotels for blacks in the American South were equivalent to the ones where white folks stayed.

    Surely, if the facilities are separate but equal, why would any Haredi Jew object t noreligous Jews praying at the Kotel, while the Haredim are relocated to Robinson's Arch, $8 fee included.

  2. feminism, leftism. zionut, Judaism is non existent in Israel almost except for a few Charedi streets.

  3. Yehuda Cohen says:

    Robinson’s Arch is still part of the last wall of the Temple area (Kotel). There is a law that prayers should not be held in a place of filth. The bathrooms are located in the Plaza area opposite Robinson’s Arch in the parking lot area. The stench is tremendous and depending on which way the wind is blowing, the stench reaches up to the Jewish quarter. So, HaShem will decide if He wants to validate the WOW prayers depending on what direction He makes the wind blow.

  4. Mark Bernstein says:

    This idea does not create unity – we had far more unity when only Orthodox Judaism existed for thousands of years. This idea, like the Reform and other man-made movements that were created in the last mere 100 – 200 years, is what creates division among Jews. Most Israelis who are concerned at all about Judaism in any way are traditionalists, even if they are not observant. So here comes the tyranny of the tiny minority, who are out to make an ego-driven point at the expense of the general population's preferences. Most Orthodox rabbis in the US have no problem with "a woman's minyan"? Really? That is total nonsense and misinformation to push this agenda. In Judaism, halacha and minhag determine what is correct and proper, not people's trendy, progressive whims or activists writing for the Jewish Press.

  5. Grace Acosta says:

    They should pray at the Eastern side. No Haredim to offend over there!

  6. Grace Acosta says:

    Well put, and 100% accurate.

  7. Women are not worse than men in any way? Why should they pray separately? It's time to change.

  8. Yehuda Cohen says:

    Miriam: “Women are not worse than men in any way?”
    Not worse but different and appreciated for that difference.

    Miriam: “Why should they pray separately? It's time to change.”
    That difference requires separation which can’t be changed unless you want call all the Jews back to Mount Sinai and ask HaShem to change the laws about Niddah, cleanliness, etc.

    So maybe the women want equal rights to men? Then they should pay the price. As men had circumcision so should women have a female circumcision and a complete hysterectomy so there would be no concerns with niddah. To insure that the women remain calm and quiet at all times during prayers instead of constantly talking then they should have a lobotomy. I mean if the women of the wall had all three of these surgeries, there would be no fight for rights and she would be very happy to give up wearing her tallit and go scrub clean the Kotel parking lot with a tooth brush. Are you sure that you don’t want to change your mind?:-)

  9. Maybe they are doing it wrong from a religious of point of view, but arresting people for not praying correctly is wrong. Maybe no religion should be followed to extreme. If one person said he saw the God that told him to do so and so and other people had to follow, that does not sound smart. That's how primitive people lived. I can't wait till Israel stop taking these people seriously. Women have right to dress how they want. If you don't like how they dress, do not look, but throwing stones at them is so Stone Age like.

  10. Philip Moran says:

    The WOW are liberals with a destructive agenda. They have no respect for orthodoxy yet demand respect for their offensive behavior. What hypocrites they are. Give them nothing but a cell.

  11. Philip Moran says:

    No its not – never.

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
Masked Arabs clash with Israeli security forces  in anti-Israel riot outside the Ofer prison between Jerusalem and  Ramallah.
Israel Law Center Wins Landmark Decision Against PA in NY Court
Latest News Stories
Masked Arabs clash with Israeli security forces  in anti-Israel riot outside the Ofer prison between Jerusalem and  Ramallah.

The Israel Law Center wins a landmark decision against the Palestinian Authority (PA) on behalf of 11 families of victims of terror.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu surveying the Israeli Golan Heights, January 13, 2013.

Young Jewish women and a family come under attack from Arab elementary students hurling rocks in the Golan Heights.

Terror rockets fired at Israeli civilians from a United Nations (UNRWA) girls school in Beit Lahiya, Gaza, on August 23, 2014.

Israel has agreed to cooperate with a UN board of inquiry appointed by Ban Ki-moon, probing UNRWA events in Gaza this summer.

Esther Pollard met with President Peres on the eve of his meeting with President Obama.

A U.S. parole board has turned down a request for release by former Israeli agent Jonathan Pollard, now in his 30th year in prison.

Dmitri Diliani, a spokesperson for Fatah in Jerusalem and a member of the Fatah Revolutionary Council, had taken issue with Klein’s characterization of recent violence in Jerusalem as being instigated by the Palestinians.

Hundreds of Ethiopian Jews take part in a prayer of the Sigd holiday on the Armon Hanatziv Promenade overlooking Jerusalem on November 20, 2014. The prayer is performed by Ethiopian Jews every year to celebrate their community’s connection and commitment to Israel. About 80,000 Ethiopian Jews live in Israel, many of them came in massive […]

Cleared for publication: Security forces have determined that the hit and run near El Aroub in Gush Etzion was a terror attack and not a traffic accident.

Why not? Obama already lives like he is on his own island.

There were disguised as Christmas gifts, which were to be used to kill Jews.

The alert guard at the entrance decided to check the car when the man drove up and discovered the knife.

But perhaps the thought of racism will make Arabs speak out against murderers.

To clear up a misunderstanding, you cannot apply for your gun license on the plane and receive it with your Teudat Zehut when you land.

Wholesale discrimination against Arabs is blatantly illegal and racist but sends a strong message to the police.

The army believes that the Gazans are testing their rockets in order to increase their rocket launching capabilities.

Mayor Shimoni was looking to provide security, albeit in an unpopular way, because his prime minister has not been able to. Calling him names does not change the fact that Israeli civilians are not safe from being murdered in the street by blood-crazy Arab individuals.

More Articles from Tzvi Ben-Gedalyahu
A moat would help keep Obama safe from Americans  - and perhaps the other way around.

Why not? Obama already lives like he is on his own island.

Swords Knives and Fireworks

There were disguised as Christmas gifts, which were to be used to kill Jews.

Wholesale discrimination against Arabs is blatantly illegal and racist but sends a strong message to the police.

The motto of the Druze is to be faithful to the country in which they live.

Israel has a tough job trying to correct 20 years of concessions to terror.

Fortunately, the police have rejected the idea that is great populism and is greatly stupid.

Israelis must not fall into the trap of fear that would mean victory for the enemy.

They also are not assailants, attackers, resistance fighters or martyrs – they are murderers, plain and simple.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/sharansky-to-suggest-womens-kotel-prayers-away-from-main-plaza/2013/04/09/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: