Photo Credit:
Picture from Facebook page of 'Untold History'

Facebook is the world’s largest social media website, one with hundreds of millions of users in well over a hundred countries. Despite its size, however, Facebook is not an entirely public forum on which “anything goes.” Rather, it is a worldwide gathering place where certain forms of speech and certain kinds of images are not allowed.

On its community standards page, the site lists a variety of types of speech that are not allowed, including threats of violence, pornography, and spam. Among those prohibited is “hate speech,” about which the policy is as follows:

Advertisement

“Hate Speech: Facebook does not permit hate speech, but distinguishes between serious and humorous speech. While we encourage you to challenge ideas, institutions, events, and practices, we do not permit individuals or groups to attack others based on their race, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sex, gender, sexual orientation, disability or medical condition.” [Emphasis added.]

This has nothing to do with censorship (which is a government activity, and cannot be engaged in by a private individual or organization), but with maintaining a civil space for the exchange of ideas. Granted, that isn’t always the case, but that’s why Facebook makes provision for hate speech to be reported. One can disagree with the policy, but it is clear what sorts of speech are being curtailed.

I was recently pointed in the direction of a Facebook page entitled The Untold History, run by a group out of Sweden that calls itself the European Knights Project, a partner of the Institute for Historical Review. On its masthead, it proclaims in all-caps that it is a “HISTORICAL SITE NON-POLITICAL,” but this is a sham. It is, in fact, a Holocaust denial site that not only presents bogus and falsified history, but also traffics in the vilest sort of anti-Semitism.

Presented primarily in the form of graphics with messages, Photoshopped pictures, and cartoons, the page offers all of the anti-Semitic greatest hits: Jews control America and want to control the world; the Holocaust never happened; Jews exploit the Holocaust myth for money; the Allies did far worse to the Germans, Japanese, and Japanese-Americans than the Nazis did to the Jews; Hitler was a great guy who was just standing up for Christian civilization; Communism is a Jewish tool; Israel is the source of all evil in the world; 9/11 was a Mossad job; etc. In one graphic, a “quote” fabricated by the American evangelist Texe Marrs is put in the mouth of Menachem Begin:

“Our race is the ‘Master Race.’ We are divine gods on this planet. We are as different from the inferior races as they are from insects…. other races are beasts and animals, cattle at best. Our destiny is to rule over the inferior races. The masses will lick our feet and serve us as our slaves.”

Once I had examined “The Untold History” for myself, I reported it to Facebook, and expected it to be quickly removed. Instead, I received this response from administrators:

“Thank you for taking the time to report something that you feel may violate our Community Standards. Reports like yours are an important part of making Facebook a safe and welcoming environment. We reviewed the page you reported for containing hate speech or symbols and found it doesn’t violate our community standard on hate speech.”

Flabbergasted by this response, I began contacting my Facebook friends, and urging them to report “The Untold History” for violating site standards. Dozens have done so, and all have received the same response. For some reason that is impossible to fathom, the administrators of Facebook seem completely incapable of recognizing anti-Semitism when it is staring them in the face, or see how it constitutes a violation of terms of use that ban hate speech.

In an effort to put pressure on Facebook to act, I have set up a page called Protest “The Untold History” and Other Anti-Semitic Pages. Oddly enough, this page seems to have a problem with disappearing posts. But you can still “like” it to send a message. I have also contacted the Simon Wiesenthal Center and Anti-Defamation League to look into Facebook’s non-disapproval of hate speech directed at Jews. As the word gets out, hopefully the company will do some serious self-examination, and ask itself why it has such a difficult time seeing what is obvious to all but the most bigoted observer.

This article was written for JNS by David Fischler, an Evangelical Presbyterian pastor and writer who blogs religious and moral issues.

Advertisement

61 COMMENTS

  1. I know of facebook prejudice against the truth when it come to defend israel and the jews, whenever I post something in favor of israel or jews they don't post it.
    and they say so:we will not post this' I think that only a BOYCOT could work as a protest.

  2. I reported an anti-semitic page making jokes about the Holocaust to them several times, and I got the standard message that the page does not violate their guidelines even though it obviously does

  3. You can't boycott facebook but what you can do is to lobby for legislation in your home country to make fb a special case because of its global reach and either hit it in its pocket (special tax) or as a special case – threaten to internationalize it and make it the property of 'all nations' – an international movement to do this would have an effect.

  4. Everything in that cartoon is fact, but most people are afraid to leave their cocoons to discover the truth. From John 8:44 KJV 44 Yes are of your father the devil, and the lusts of your father yes will do. He was a murderer from the beginning, and abode not in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he speaketh a lie, he speaketh of his own: for he is a liar, and the father of it.

    Basically, the birth of Jesus ended Judaism, the exception is the remnant of 144k mentioned in Revelation—it is those Jews who will have accepted Jesus. The rest of the supposed Jews will burn in hell.

  5. Please stop whining. No one gets it worse than the Christians. I mean look at the piss Christ exhibit! You Jews applaud it as a work of art and back up the “freedom of speech”.

  6. there  are anti-semitic posts on this thread. why are they being posted and not being removed. obviously, those comments are written by very low IQ brain damaged muslim crap but still…

  7. João Eduardo Ramos Alves please show me one instance where the Bible foretold future events that proved to be false? I am certain you cannot do so. Are you saying Jesus Christ was ignorant?

  8. Mr Shields you are in fact spiritually blinded and are believing the lie of the father of lies, you know, the one who has no truth in him. Why do you suppose the father of lies would want you to believe what you just posted? I personally know many, many Jews who believe in Yeshua that have nothing to do with the 144K of Revelation, and if the birth of Yeshua ended Judiasm why were so many even after the death and resurrection of Yeshua becoming believers. Why did Paul who was commanded to go preach to the Gentiles, but was told to go the Jew first and then the Gentile. Paul always went to the Synagog first. You sir, are calling God a liar with your statement because he said his covenant with the Jews was forever and was not dependent on anything they did, but on what he said. God cannot lie and if He said His covenant was with the Jews forever, then that's exactly the way it is. Why would he have his son be born into that race, Yeshua who is Jewish, and then turn his back on His people? Don't you think Yah/God knew in advance how all this was going to turn out? I would ask you Mr. Shields that you get into the Word of God and really, really read and study His Word because I don't see how you could and make a statement like that.

  9. Mr. Solovitz it would do no good to lobby legislation in the USA because the government has their people watching everything that goes on in FB and FB receives tax breaks because of it. Interesting too because the owner of FB is a Jew.

  10. unpcguy Why don’t YOU stop whining. There are billions and billions of Christians and only 14 million Jews. You have no idea how pervasive anti-semitism is, or what its like to carry the weight of millennia of relentless persecution. We have a right to oppose hate speech which Facebook refuses to do anything about. So why don’t you just shut your mouth until you think of something intelligent to say

  11. The Jewish people have survived countless attempts by Christians to destroy or convert us but we're still here and we'll never embrace your idol worship and your false pagan god

  12. mike shields Paul has written that we are not to say who goes to hell and who goes to heaven," so therefore you are not a true christian but one of Hitler fanaticks, If some in Israel had not rejected Christ our Lord, then how would salvation have come unto us, their rejection was our salvation, shame on you Mike, you must be one of those pope lovers. who really the roman empire now under the guise of christianity with the pope as head instead of their ceasars. May the Lord have mercy on you.

  13. Mike, you can believe these lies of your false religion if you'd like. They were used as cover to commit the world's worst atrocities for the better part of 1,700 years on innocent people.
    It takes a devil sub-human like John to write such vile screed.
    It's just one of a number of vile things in the New Testament, a well-disputed number of contradictory books, including Jesus stating that he had not come to bring peace on Earth, but the sword; to set man at variance against man, the opposite of what will be the messiah of the Jews, a concept exclusively created for the Jews, with ancillary benefits to only good non-Jews, not scoundrels who attempt to inflame people on Facebook with condescending falsely based contentions.
    It's as obvious that Judaism didn't end as there are hundreds of denominations of Christianity, so that there is effectively no such thing as Christianity, since each one says the other one is false.

  14. If a stranger told you…that he heard someone claim he saw a ghost named Teddy while fishing one day on the river…and that the Ghost teddy had all the secrets of life, and that everything he said made so much sense…would you also suddenly believe in Teddy? And say you DO decide to believe this guy, and accept Teddy as the Truth, wouldnt you then thank him for all the good feelings you have as a result?

  15. Additionally, the administrator of The Untold History has now blatantly announced on the page that "i will not open personal account in fb no more, only fake account.
    will only open personal accounts outside jewbook.
    i protest facebook, and advise all to find other social site"
    The page has now opened 21 more pages, and if we are to believe the administrator's statement, they may well all be fake accounts..which is in violation of Facebook Community Standards. And Facebook's response will be..???

Loading Facebook Comments ...