web analytics
September 15, 2014 / 20 Elul, 5774
At a Glance
Judaism
Sponsored Post
Apartment 758x530 Africa-Israel at the Israel Real Estate Exhibition in New York

Africa Israel Residences, part of the Africa Israel Investments Group led by international businessman Lev Leviev, will present 7 leading projects on the The Israel Real Estate Exhibition in New York on Sep 14-15, 2014.



Under The Oak Tree (Daf Yomi Sukkah)


Grunfeld-Raphael-logo

The equivalent of the “OU” kashrut certification in England is that of the London Beit Din. There is also a competing kashrut certification called Kedassia. Those who eat Kedassia do not eat Beit Din.

My father, one of the principal dayanim on the bench of the London Beit Din and someone who had invested much of his working life on matters of kashrut, ate Beit Din. His younger brother, my uncle, ate only Kedassia. My father didn’t like that. One Erev Sukkot, shortly before Yom Tov, my uncle invited my father to admire the sukkah he had built with much care and enthusiasm.

“Beautiful,” remarked my father, “but unusable. Look up; you’ve built your sukkah under the branches of an oak tree. But never mind, come and eat in our sukkah. We do, of course, only eat Beit Din.”

The sukkah, which means “shade,” must be built for the purpose of providing shade and must be outside under the open sky. There can be nothing interceding between the sukkah and the sky. Accordingly, the sukkah cannot be built in a house or under a tree, which already provide shade and which, therefore, render the sukkah redundant. But why couldn’t my uncle’s sukkah be fixed by cutting away the overhanging branches? The answer is that the sukkah must be valid when originally constructed. It cannot originally be built invalid and then corrected and made valid.

Thus, for example, a sukkah fashioned by hollowing out an existing haystack is invalid. This disqualification is known as “taaseh velo min haasui,” which means you must create a valid sukkah and not fix an invalid one. This principle is derived from the verse “[Chag] hasukkot taaseh lecha” – “[the festival of] Sukkot you shall make for yourself.”

The principle of taaseh velo min haasui is derived from the fact that the word “sukkot” precedes the word “make.” The only way to save my uncle’s sukkah would have been to cut away the overhanging oak tree branches and then pick up each piece of the existing leaves and lay it down again on the roof of the sukkah. That way, by laying the sechach again, the sukkah would be kosher at inception, because it is the laying of the sechach, which is the essence of the sukkah. But being shortly before Yom Tov, there was no time.

Another remedy would be to bend the branches of the tree over so that they merge with the existing kosher sechach already on the roof of the sukkah. Based on the halachic rule of bitul b’rav, (the majority nullifies the minority), as long as the kosher sechach outnumbers the invalid tree branches, the sukkah is kosher.

In the same way as one may save the sukkah by cutting down the branches and laying the sechach again, one could also remove roof tiles from a roof and sit under the wooden beams. The very act of removing the roof tiles is considered a sufficient act of “taaseh” and renders the remaining construction a valid sukkah. Because of the principle of taaseh velo min haasui, a rain roof on a sukkah should be open when the sechach is laid down and the sechach should not be inserted from the inside with the roof closed.

Other examples of taaseh velo min haasui are tzizit and mezuzah. From the order of the words “gedilim taaseh lecha” the rabbis derive that four separate fringes must be inserted into the garment and then doubled over into eight, which must then be tied and knotted in the prescribed way. One cannot, however, insert one long string, double it over twice, tie and knot it and then snip the ends to make eight. Similarly, one may not fix a mezuzah onto a detached doorpost and then build the doorpost with the mezuzah on it into the house.

About the Author: Raphael Grunfeld’s book, “Ner Eyal on Seder Moed” (distributed by Mesorah) is available at OU.org and your local Jewish bookstore. His new book, “Ner Eyal on Seder Nashim & Nezikin,” will be available shortly.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

One Response to “Under The Oak Tree (Daf Yomi Sukkah)”

  1. It seems like a bad idea to cut the branches of a living tree just to cover up our mistakes. It makes more sense to move the sukkah or bend the branches like you said. Seems more kosher not to destroy a natural form of shade that took decades to grow in order to make room for an artificial source of shade that took a weekend to build and merely provides shade that the tree was already providing. Seems wasteful from so many angles.

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
A Jew, a soldier and a Druze watch - very carefully - the Syrian side of the Golan Heights.
IDF Stands By as Al Qaeda Offensive Threatens Golan Farmers
Latest Judaism Stories
15th century Book of the Torah

This week’s parsha offers a new covenant; a covenant that speaks to national life unlike any other

Leff-091214

All Jews are inherently righteous and that is why we all have a portion in the World to Come.

Grunfeld-Raphael-logo

If mourning is incompatible with Yom Tov, why is it not incompatible with Shabbat?

Taste-of-Lomdus-logo

Since it is a Rabbinic prohibition we may follow the more lenient opinion.

How can the Torah expect me today, thousands of years after the mitzvahs were given, to view each mitzvah as if I’m fulfilling it for the first time?

Torah isn’t a theological treatise or a metaphysical system but a series of stories linked over time

In contrast to her Eicha-like lamentations of the previous hour or more, however, my youngest was now grinning from ear-to-ear.

An Astonishing Miracle
‘Why Bring the Infants to Hakhel?’
(Chagigah 3a)

Question: I recently loaned money to a friend who has been able to repay only part of it. This was an interest-free loan. We exchanged a signed IOU, not a proper shtar with witnesses, since I have always trusted her integrity and only wanted a document that confirms what was loaned and what was repaid. Now that shemittah is approaching, what should I do? Should I forgive the loan? And if my friend is not able to repay it, may I deduct the unpaid money from my ma’aser requirement?

Name Withheld

e are in a time of serious crisis and must go beyond our present levels of chesed.

According to Ibn Ezra, the Torah was stressing through this covenant that hypocrisy was forbidden.

“Tony said that the code in most places in the U.S. is at least 36 inches for a residential guardrail,” replied Mr. Braun. “Some make it higher, 42, or even 52 inches for high porches. What is the required height according to halacha?”

Simcha is total; sahs is God’s joy in protecting us even when we are most vulnerable.

Not only do we accept You as our King, it is our greatest desire that the name of Your Kingdom be spread throughout the entire universe.

More Articles from Raphael Grunfeld
Grunfeld-Raphael-logo

If mourning is incompatible with Yom Tov, why is it not incompatible with Shabbat?

On Chol HaMoed some work is prohibited and some is permitted. According to some opinions, the work prohibition is biblical; according to others, it’s rabbinical.

Based on the opinion of the Ramban, the Territorial School believes that leaving any territory of the Land of Israel in the possession of non-Jews is a violation of a biblical mandate.

To properly fulfill the mitzvah of listening to the megillah, each word must be heard.

If the only person available to perform the milah on the eighth day is a person who is not an observant Jew, the milah should be postponed until a devout mohel is available.

The kohen gadol may not enter the Temple unless his hair is cut every seven days.

A commonly employed and permissible device regarding the prohibition of wearing fresh clothes during the Nine Days is to don them for a moment or two before the Nine Days.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/judaism/halacha-hashkafa/under-the-oak-tree-daf-yomi-sukkah/2014/02/13/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: